Sarah's profile

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 21 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Sarah's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, flexible, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Happy Homeowners
4 months ago
Happy Homeowners

Sarah helped us find our perfect home. It took many offers and a lot of viewings, but Sarah kept our spirits up and provided her knowledge and expertise until we finally had an offer accepted! She stayed in complete communication until everything went through successfully. Since we were first-time homebuyers we required some guidance on the process and Sarah had patience with us the whole way through, which we are very thankful for. We felt comfortable telling her our feelings on each house we viewed, whether we could see ourselves there or not so much. We would 100% recommend working with Sarah to anyone we know and if we ever were to move again, she would be the one we would contact right away.

Seller review
Sarah Everett was very helpful and knowledgeable
5 months ago
Sarah Everett was very helpful and knowledgeable

We couldn’t be happier with our experience working with Sarah From start to finish, Sarah was outstanding- professional,knowledgeable,and truly dedicated to helping us find the right property. We were searching for a cabin with acreage and a pond, and she exceeded our expectations by finding several options that fit our vision perfectly Sarah was always responsive,proactive,and incredibly thorough, making the entire process smooth and enjoyable. Her attention to detail,work ethic, and commitment to her clients are exceptional. We highly recommend Sarah Everett at Nicole City Realty to anyone looking for an excellent realtor who goes above and beyond.

Seller review
Great experience
5 months ago
Great experience

We decided to give Sarah a call when we were ready to sell our house and she was very helpful and responsive during the process. Moving can be a very stressful but she made sure we were organized and answered any questions we had. She made the process very smooth! Thank you, Sarah!

Buyer review
Very happy and satisfied
6 months ago
Very happy and satisfied

She’s vey helpfull and asnwers my question right away very patient with us im so thankful for her. I’m so glad i have her as my realtor. I would definitely recommend her.

Buyer review
A WONDERFUL EXPERIENCE
about 1 year ago
A WONDERFUL EXPERIENCE

When I thought about doing a review for Sarah Everett, it was hard for me to put into wards how happy I was that I got matched up with her as my realtor. Sarah was always available for me when I had any questions or wanted to see a property. I had no idea what kind of property I was looking for, so Sarah sent me a wide variety of houses until she found me the perfect home in Lancaster. Sarah was patient, thorough and accommodating. She made me feel like I was looking at house with a friend, not a realtor. I am so happy with the house I purchased. It is perfect for me and my young children. I would recommend Sarah immediately if anyone needs a realtor.

Buyer review
Efficient, hard worker
about 1 year ago
Efficient, hard worker

Sarah was a pleasure to work with for our recent condo purchase. She went above and beyond her duties to ensure our purchase went smooth and timely. She is excellent with communication, even with us both working night shift, she accommodated our irregular schedules to ensure things would work. She was always available to answer questions that would arise and very knowledgeable.

Seller review
Highly recommend!!!
over 1 year ago
Highly recommend!!!

As exciting and rewarding selling your house can be, also comes anxiety and stressful situations. Sarah took her time, explained the entire process in a detailed organized way. From getting the house ready for the sale, to showings to final sale, Sarah was attentive, helpful, and available for every question and possible scenario she was prepared, as well as preparing me for the emotion of selling my home. Sarah explained the closing process when we first discussed listing the house, there were no surprises when it came to the sale. Sarah explained each offer in a balanced way. Each showing Sarah made sure everything was as it should be. I would highly recommend Sarah as your real estate agent.

Seller review
Great Experience!
over 1 year ago
Great Experience!

Sarah was very professional and motivated. She helped me a great deal in selling two vacant pieces of land I had in Orchard Park. I would highly recommend her.

Seller review
Very hard working
almost 2 years ago
Very hard working

I can’t say enough about Sarah, she was always there when I called, always made time to take us to see houses and got my house sold in 2 weeks, absolutely loved working with her and I would use her 1000 times over for any real estate needs I might have, thank you Sarah for selling my house and finding me a forever home 😁

Seller review
Outstanding
almost 2 years ago
Outstanding

I have never met a more kinder, hard working, understanding realtor. Sarah went above and beyond to help me through this process of selling my home. When I was not able to get to the house for an appointment she stepped in to help me get through the process. She held my hand and helped me from start to finish. She was such a pleasure to work with, I would highly recommend her.

Buyer review
Sarah Everett realtor
almost 2 years ago
Sarah Everett realtor

Sarah was a pleasure to work alongside with looking for my first investment property. She was very knowledgeable and helpful answering all my questions that I had. She was always willing to set up appointments anytime to whatever I needed. I was always prepared by her before looking at a property by giving me the comps and any information I needed on the house before the appointment.Sarah would always adjust or tweak the areas I wanted to look into and offer advice, sending mailers or zeroing in on a certain area if I wanted. If I had a question she couldn’t answer she would find out and get right back to me. Sarah was a great communicator always sending emails and texts keeping us informed and updated constantly. There were times I was frustrated with not getting a certain property by being over bid but she would encourage me and allow me to come back when I was ready. She knew how far she could go. Sarah made it fun and exciting for me. I definitely know I wouldn’t have stayed with my searching if it wasn’t for her. It was a pleasure working alongside Sarah and I can’t wait to do it again.

1 - 12 of 21
© 2026 RateMyAgent