Sandra's profile

Sandra's reviews

  5  
Sandra has 70 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Sandra's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, well-connected, great negotiation, clear communication, responsive, reliable, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Thorough and professional.
over 1 year ago
Thorough and professional.

Though Sandy represented the seller, she was extremely helpful, thorough, responsive, knowledgeable and approachable to us the buyers. She has keen insight into lenders, title companies, insurance agents, home inspectors, and an encyclopedic grasp of local dependable contractors. Sandy was always within reach via text, email or phone. Very smooth process. No hesitation in rating Sandy with five stars.

Buyer review
A pleasantly thorough and detailed experience!
almost 2 years ago
A pleasantly thorough and detailed experience!

Sandy was very responsive and professional with our buying process. Sandy was very helpful in communicating and making sure she got back to us quickly with answers to any of our questions and concerns. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to purchase their dream or vacation home. She will get the job done in a very professional and thorough way. Thank you again Sandy for being part of our journey!

Seller review
Brilliant! Very Professional Realtor
almost 2 years ago
Brilliant! Very Professional Realtor

Sandy goes above and beyond anyone’s expectation as she is extremely knowledgeable, outgoing and very professional! If you want to buy or sale real estate, Sandy is by far the best realtor in the Florida lower keys!!

Seller review
Grateful!!
almost 2 years ago
Grateful!!

Sandy Tuttle and her team were professional and gave support every step of the way which we are extremely grateful for. We trusted them and they never let us down. We are completely happy with the sale of our home.

Seller review
Very positive experience
almost 2 years ago
Very positive experience

Sandy delivered beyond my expectations. Her market knowledge and price guidance were spot on. I will highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Keys

Seller review
SIMPLY THE BEST!!!!
almost 2 years ago
SIMPLY THE BEST!!!!

Sandra Tuttle and her Team at Island Welcome Real Estate helped make our dreams of owning a beautiful canal front home in the Fabulous Florida Keys a reality. From the moment we met Sandy at an open house, we knew she was the agent for us. Her positive "CAN AND WILL DO" attitude made working with her and her team an amazing experience! Our situation was unique in that we needed to sell our dry lot to purchase a canal home. When we told Sandy this, she was ready to go and make it all happen! And that she DID! Her and her team were always there for us at a drop of a hat! Her knowledge of the local housing market and the properties on which they stand are second to none. Her and her team are WONDERFUL, AUTHENTIC people and you will love working with them, just as we did. We are so lucky to have her and her team at Island Welcome Real Estate a staple in our awesome community. We are so proud to be a part of the Sandra Tuttle and Island Welcome Real Estate family! Working with Sandy Tuttle was truly an Island Welcome experience! Sincerely, Rick and Shannon Fuqua

Seller review
Extraordinary
almost 2 years ago
Extraordinary

Sandy has deep knowledge of the real estate market in the keys. She has helped us greatly from our purchase five years ago to our recent sale and everything in between.

Seller review
Sandra makes it easy
over 2 years ago
Sandra makes it easy

I really enjoyed my experience. I purchased and sold with Sandra. She made the process easy in both transactions.

Buyer review
Excellent
over 2 years ago
Excellent

The Buying process went extremely smooth and Sandra made sure everything went that way.

Seller review
One of the best real estate agents I've ever met.
over 2 years ago
One of the best real estate agents I've ever met.

Proactive full-time agent Sandy is easy to work with Great at communication and has really good connections in the keys community. She help me make decisions that led to exactly what I wanted in the sale of my house I would use Sandy again in a heartbeat. I would absolutely use her as a buyer's agent as well terrific in all respects.

Seller review
Highly recommend Sandra Tuttle
over 2 years ago
Highly recommend Sandra Tuttle

We’ve worked with other real estate agents in the past and Sandra is by far the best agent we’ve ever worked with!! From the day we decided to list our property with Sandy, to the day of closing, she stayed on top of everything. She kept us updated regularly, was very professional, friendly, and patient with all of our questions and concerns. She was a pleasure to work with and we appreciate everything she did for us.

Buyer review
First round Hall of Famer
over 2 years ago
First round Hall of Famer

I own about 14 properties, I have dealt with real estate agents in Maryland and now in Florida. Sandy was the absolute delight. She went above and beyond to help me after the closing with electric, water, and handyman. She is a wonderful human being and the best real estate agent ever. I will continue to give her name to anyone. I know purchasing a property in the keys. Thank you Sandy you hit it out of the park for this old man

25 - 36 of 70
© 2026 RateMyAgent