Reid's profile

Reid's reviews

  5  
Reid has 42 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Reid's qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, strategic, supportive, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Reid Rosenthal is the best in the business
over 4 years ago
Reid Rosenthal is the best in the business

Reid Rosenthal is the best in the business – a pro who goes above and beyond. We have worked with a handful of (what we thought at the time were) excellent realtors over the past 15 years, buying & selling houses up and down the East Coast, but none as all-around expert as Reid. Not even close. Arguably the most critical part of the process is pricing & promoting the home, and negotiating the deal – and this is where Reid shines, truly without peer. He has a beat on the market and truly understands what's happening. This was crucial during the pandemic where the market was constantly changing and a unique house like ours became more difficult to sell. Since Reid and his team work across several regions, he was able to keep track of micro trends, adjust based on this knowledge, and strategically price our home to get the best sale possible. We had an unfortunate occurrence when our house was first put on the market: a crazy storm/flash flood caused water damage to the house when it was unoccupied. Reid literally saved the day by helping us find the experts to quickly fix the situation. His calm demeanor kept us calm throughout the process. Reid is personable, smart and a real pleasure to work with, and honestly wants the best for you, his client. Reid is a problem-solver who gets it done. He is extremely responsive to all calls and texts, which always impressed us because we knew we were not his only clients, but felt like we were. We feel incredibly fortunate to have had Reid and his team represent us. They made the process of selling our house simple, regardless of the hiccups we ran into. THANK YOU, Reid!!

Seller review
Incredible support and expertise!
over 4 years ago
Incredible support and expertise!

I needed to sell my condo within a prescribed window of time. After examining information on several realtors regarding location, sales record, and overall reputation, I wisely chose Reid. He worked with me on the timeline, provided untiring guidance at every step, made wise pricing decisions, and engaged in well- structured marketing. As a result, the condo sold in two days for a price over ask. Success, and I met my timeline perfectly! Besides Reid’s obvious expertise, I think that what I appreciated the most was his availability. He kept in frequent contact, and every one of my calls and emails yielded quick responses. I guess that what I’m saying is that Reid is not only excellent at his job, but is a true partner in the process. I’ve bought and sold several properties with a variety of realtors, so I can honestly say from my comparative experiences that Reid Rosenthal is a stellar real estate professional.

Buyer review
Best Agent in Philly Area
over 4 years ago
Best Agent in Philly Area

Reid and his associates were amazing to work with for my Philly townhouse purchase. If I called him with a question, he either answered the phone right away or got back to me within minutes. No matter the time of day. And he always had the answer to my question, or got it right away. When I needed to get estimates for repairs that were needed, he contacted service providers and made sure they responded in a timely manner. He helped with obtaining the title company and homeowners insurance. Basically he assisted with the whole transaction, from soup to nuts as they say. And everyone I dealt with was top notch. Five star service all around. Anyone that uses Reid and his company will be extremely satisfied they did so.

Seller review
Made selling as painless as possible!
over 4 years ago
Made selling as painless as possible!

Reid (and team) were all so helpful in getting our house sold. We met with a lot of agents in the selection of our selling agent and were impressed with his knowledge of the market, honesty in what to expect, and his attentiveness to getting our house sold. We wanted to move quickly and he scheduled a photographer, got our house on the market, and got open houses scheduled within a very short amount of time. We were very happy with our experience selling our home and would recommend Reid for any and all real estate needs!

Seller review
Reid Rosenthal is the best in the business – a pro who goes above and beyond
over 4 years ago
Reid Rosenthal is the best in the business – a pro who goes above and beyond

Reid Rosenthal is the best in the business – a pro who goes above and beyond.  We have worked with a handful of (what we thought at the time were) excellent realtors over the past 15 years, buying & selling houses up and down the East Coast, but none as all-around expert as Reid. Not even close. Arguably the most critical part of the process is pricing & promoting the home, and negotiating the deal – and this is where Reid shines, truly without peer. He has a beat on the market and truly understands what's happening. This was crucial during the pandemic where the market was constantly changing and a unique house like ours became more difficult to sell. Since Reid and his team work across several regions, he was able to keep track of micro trends, adjust based on this knowledge, and strategically price our home to get the best sale possible. We had an unfortunate occurrence when our house was first put on the market:  a crazy storm/flash flood caused water damage to the house when it was unoccupied. Reid literally saved the day by helping us find the experts to quickly fix the situation. His calm demeanor kept us calm throughout the process. Reid is personable, smart and a real pleasure to work with, and honestly wants the best for you, his client. Reid is a problem-solver who gets it done. He is extremely responsive to all calls and texts, which always impressed us because we knew we were not his only clients, but felt like we were. We feel incredibly fortunate to have had Reid and his team represent us. They made the process of selling our house simple, regardless of the hiccups we ran into.  THANK YOU, Reid!! Sincerely, Angel & Robert Padulo

Buyer review
Great Experience!
almost 5 years ago
Great Experience!

This was our second time buying a home in Philadelphia and had every sort of bad experience with developers and agents the first time around. This time we were intent on working with someone with integrity. We knew this might be a long search since we wanted a very specific kind of high value home in a very challenging market. Reid stayed with us for more than a year...always responsive, always working to the best of his ability, with a solid support team. Nothing is ever easy in real estate, but after more than a year we found and closed on that exceptional property, with a deal at a fair market value to the satisfaction of both ourselves and the sellers. Reviewed by zuser20200614065308726 on 1 Aug 2021

37 - 42 of 42
© 2026 RateMyAgent