Reid's profile

Reid's reviews

  5  
Reid has 42 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Reid's qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, strategic, supportive, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
5-star experience
24 days ago
5-star experience

Reid was very responsive - during weekday, weekends and off-hours. He and his team provided a seamless experience - great communication. He helped with contractors, movers, negotiating, and provided the must needed advice but was always receptive to my thoughts as well. It was a pleasure to work with him. I felt like I got the 5-star experience that I was looking for.

Buyer review
Great experience!
29 days ago
Great experience!

Reid is the best. He is super responsive, patient, and great at answering questions. He definitely has your back, and I felt comfortable and confident during the whole process.

Seller review
Seamless, professional, and truly top-tier from start to finish
3 months ago
Seamless, professional, and truly top-tier from start to finish

Reid Rosenthal and his team did an absolutely amazing job selling my condo. From my very first outreach, they were incredibly responsive and quick to set up a meeting. They came prepared with clear, thoughtful information about the market, pricing strategy, and what to expect at every step. The marketing was outstanding. The photography of my space was beautiful and truly showcased the condo at its best. The listing had strong visibility and was shared broadly, which gave me a lot of confidence that we were reaching the right buyers. What really stood out was how seamless the entire process felt. Every step leading up to closing, from coordinating showings to managing paperwork, was handled efficiently and professionally. They made what could have been a stressful process feel straightforward and manageable. I’m so grateful for their expertise and support, and I would absolutely recommend Reid and his team to anyone looking to buy or sell.

Seller review
Great experience…again
3 months ago
Great experience…again

Reid was great to work with again. He was familiar with the "comps" in the area and made a good recommendation on price point. He was able to advocate and negotiate on our behalf. We definitely had lots of little and not so little questions for him throughout the process which were answered immediately. We have now purchased two homes and sold one home with Reid and his team. Thank you!

Seller review
Great Experience working with Reid
4 months ago
Great Experience working with Reid

We had a great time working with Reid and David at The Rosenthal Group. They were professional, friendly, and responsive during the entire process. As first-time homebuyers, we felt they provided good advice on the quality of homes we were buying to make an informed decision, including in leading an informed approach to help secure meaningful seller concessions. We recommend all buyers rely on their own in-depth research, of course, but Reid and David will be there for validation and to provide insightful context.

Seller review
Excellent
5 months ago
Excellent

It was a pleasure working with the team and they listened to our suggestions and thoughts concerning pricing, etc.

Seller review
Excellent
5 months ago
Excellent

Very knowledgeable & fast responses

Buyer review
5 Star Experience for All Individuals
5 months ago
5 Star Experience for All Individuals

Reid was recommended to us by a friend and within a few hours of contacting him he was on the phone with us talking about all of our desires in a home. He is not only timely, but a truly pleasure to talk to. Outside of his demeanor and professionalism he has decades of experience with real estate that are clear as soon as you are onsite with him. He is able to give advise, what to watch out for, why something may be of value to you, etc with ease. He was always present for us, advocated for our needs, and was able to get us the house we wanted at a great price. We would recommend Reid to any and all buyers and sellers.

Seller review
Above and beyond - would highly recommend!
6 months ago
Above and beyond - would highly recommend!

After working with Reid for about two and a half years in search of our new home, we finally found a new construction dream home in the location we wanted that he helped negotiate a full finished basement at roughly the same asking price, rent stipend in case it went longer than expected, a 5-figure landscaping credit and additional warranty package. When it came time to sell our new home, Reid found us a very thorough photographer and after having the house listed for about 24-hours, we received an offer about 4.5% over asking with small concessions requested and a 30 day close, which we immediately accepted and cancelled all future showings. That was just the icing on the cake for a long and extremely fruitful relationship. I would highly recommend Reid and his team to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Philadelphia area.

Seller review
Reid Rosenthal is the real deal!
6 months ago
Reid Rosenthal is the real deal!

Having worked with Reid when we bought our home, it was a no-brainer to go back to him when we needed to sell it. Smart, insightful, creative, responsive, genuine and dedicated, Reid helped our house fly off the market at a price over-asking. He's the best!

Seller review
Excellent and right on point
7 months ago
Excellent and right on point

Reid was very responsive and professional throughout the entire process. His knowledge of the market place and relationships greatly facilitated the sale of the house.

Seller review
Best Agent
7 months ago
Best Agent

I have worked with Reid for years. He is a miracle worker. He has sold condos for me in the toughest markets. Highly recommend him and his team.

1 - 12 of 42
© 2026 RateMyAgent