Reid's profile

Reid's reviews

  5  
Reid has 52 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Reid's qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, clear communication, supportive, strategic, well-prepared, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Couldn't Have Asked for a Better Agent
8 days ago
Couldn't Have Asked for a Better Agent

I am so happy that I worked with Reid to buy my dream house. He's incredibly knowledgeable, well-connected, and genuinely cares about his clients. What I appreciated most was how honest and patient he was throughout the process - even after countless showings and offers being drafted late at night, he never pushed me to make an offer. You won't regret choosing Reid to be your agent!

Seller review
Reid Rosenthal is the consummate real estate professional.
22 days ago
Reid Rosenthal is the consummate real estate professional.

We hired Reid to represent our property on Rittenhouse Square that had already been listed by 3 other agents. His knowledge and approach to marketing our home were right on target and he was able to bring a significant buyer to the table within the first 3 months of the listing. We loved his use of AI to target specific buyers and held his own open houses almost every weekend until the right buyer was found. He does not send assistants - he does all showings on his own so that every client visit is meaningful. We had many perks associated with our listing that made our property special and Reid was masterful at conveying exactly what the opportunity would be if the prospective buyer was interested. He held showings morning, afternoon and evening (at dusk) to showcase our views which are the best in the city! I cannot say enough about how special and rare Reid is in this industry. He really cares about getting the sale over the finishline to everyone’s satisfaction!

Seller review
Exceeded all of my expectations.
3 months ago
Exceeded all of my expectations.

I couldn’t be happier with my experience working with The Rosenthal Group. Reid was incredibly professional, knowledgeable about the local market, and guided me through every step of the process with confidence and expertise. From the very beginning, he made my home feel special and showcased its best features in a way that truly stood out to buyers. Thanks to their strategic approach and market insight, I received multiple offers over asking price. I highly recommend Reid to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

Buyer review
Always available as an excellent advocate in a highly competitive market
4 months ago
Always available as an excellent advocate in a highly competitive market

Reid and Joann were an incredible asset in buying our home on the Main Line. They know the area inside and out and helped us navigate competitive market dynamics very well. We are thrilled with our purchase and credit their expertise and work ethic in landing our forever home.

Seller review
Excellent Services
5 months ago
Excellent Services

Working with Reid to sell our property was truly a pleasure. His professionalism and urgency to sell our property was outstanding. We had our property on the market with other agents and we weren’t able to get the results that we got with Reid.

Buyer review
The best realtor we could have asked for!
5 months ago
The best realtor we could have asked for!

Working with Reid was the best decision we made when starting the journey of buying our first home. We had countless questions, and Reid made everything feel manageable and stress-free. He is incredibly knowledgeable, responsive, and always had our best interests in mind. He went above and beyond to secure the best deal possible for us. We couldn't be happier and can't thank Reid enough for all of his help throughout this process. We would not have been able to do it without him!

Buyer review
Always professional
5 months ago
Always professional

Without Reid we would never have ended up at the Arthaus. It’s an amazing building and he really thought it was a good fit for us. Love a realtor who actually makes you think outside your comfort zone. Thank you Reid

Seller review
Seamless sale
6 months ago
Seamless sale

Reid was so efficient throughout processing the sale. Highly recommend.

Buyer review
Knowledgeable and professional
6 months ago
Knowledgeable and professional

I can't say enough about Reid and his team. Always responsive, always helpful and very knowledgeable about the Philadelphia area. I thought it would take me a long time to find what I was looking for. I bought the first place I looked at, all because Reid listened to what was important to me. I've never had such a positive experience buying real estate. Thank you Reid and the Rosenthal Group!

Seller review
5-star experience
7 months ago
5-star experience

Reid was very responsive - during weekday, weekends and off-hours. He and his team provided a seamless experience - great communication. He helped with contractors, movers, negotiating, and provided the must needed advice but was always receptive to my thoughts as well. It was a pleasure to work with him. I felt like I got the 5-star experience that I was looking for.

Buyer review
Great experience!
7 months ago
Great experience!

Reid is the best. He is super responsive, patient, and great at answering questions. He definitely has your back, and I felt comfortable and confident during the whole process.

1 - 12 of 52
© 2026 RateMyAgent