Polly's profile

Polly's reviews

  5  
Polly has 24 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Polly's qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, great negotiation, friendly, responsive, dedicated, reliable, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Polly is a seasoned real estate professional and the epitome of class
over 4 years ago
Polly is a seasoned real estate professional and the epitome of class

Polly is a seasoned real estate professional and the epitome of class. She has helped us with multiple real estate transactions of both buying and selling in San Diego. She is truly a pleasure to work with and brings a refreshing calmness to the stress and anxiety that comes with buying and selling a home. We trust her to get things done right and highly recommend both her and her team.

Buyer review
You are fortunate to find her!
almost 5 years ago
You are fortunate to find her!

We give the highest recommendation to Polly Rogers & Associates. Polly made buying a San Diego house in a wild unpredictable market look easy! Having offered unsuccessfully previously to an unresponsive listing agent with time ticking on our 1031 exchange, we greatly appreciated Polly's timely efforts to present our offer promptly to her sellers and their acceptance promptly to us the same day! 15 days later escrow closed and we couldn't be happier with our beautiful Pacific Beach property! Polly is a kind, sparkling and intelligent woman who helps both buyers and sellers achieve their goals while treating them well. You are fortunate to find her! Aloha!

Buyer review
It is a dream to work with Polly! She helped us find our perfect house!
almost 5 years ago
It is a dream to work with Polly! She helped us find our perfect house!

Polly is the best! She is extremely knowledgeable and a true professional. She has a lot of experience and is well respected within the industry. From the beginning Polly took the time to find out what was important to us. Looking for a home can be a very stressful process, especially in the current market. Polly was very responsive and we never felt any pressure to write offers. It is a dream to work with Polly! She helped us find our perfect house! Throughout the process Polly made sure every detail was taken care for a smooth transaction. Polly continues to be an outstanding resource for home remodeling recommendations! We highly recommend Polly!

Buyer review
We were referred to Polly by a colleague
almost 5 years ago
We were referred to Polly by a colleague

We were referred to Polly by a colleague . We were moving from Bay Area and didnt know much about San Diego . Even before coming down here, Polly went and toured a few house for us and gave us valuable feedback on how the houses are versus the pictures we saw on Redfin. She was well aware of market situation, fully heard what we were looking for and streamlined our house searching process . We put offer on two houses, both offers went through (we got out of the first one when we found the second house we liked more). That shows that Polly knows what the seller/their agent is looking for and we were able to easily write offers that got accepted in this crazy market. Apart from her professionalism, she is really sweet and fun, we enjoyed talking to her even outside the house buying process. Looking forward to working with Polly for future purchases..

Buyer review
There is no better agent... You are 'home' with Polly.
almost 7 years ago
There is no better agent... You are 'home' with Polly.

Polly is the consummate real estate professional. I was in a situation where I needed to shop for a house remotely. She was my eyes and ears through the entire process. Polly helped make it easy for me to fly in and view the property when I needed to. I don’t think I would have had the best chance to get my dream house without her. There is no better agent, and you are ‘home’ with Polly.

Buyer review
She helped us write a competitive offer that was accepted out of multiple buyers!
almost 7 years ago
She helped us write a competitive offer that was accepted out of multiple buyers!

Polly helped us buy our first home the DAY it came on the market! A good buyer's agent is hard to come by, and we really appreciated her communication and vigilance to find us the best property! She was constantly on the lookout for us, and once she told us about the house, we were able to get in for the first showing and made an offer that day. She helped us write a competitive offer that was accepted out of multiple buyers! We were in great hands throughout the entire escrow. Not only does she have decades of experience, she is so personable and pleasant to work with. She also has wonderful referrals and connections with good trustworthy vendors (home inspectors, plumbers, etc) that make the whole process seamless! I highly recommend you use Polly if you're looking for your first home or your forever home!

Buyer review
Without your knowledge and wisdom, my wife and I would never have been able to secure this home.
almost 8 years ago
Without your knowledge and wisdom, my wife and I would never have been able to secure this home.

Thank you POLLY . Without your knowledge and wisdom , my wife and I would never have been able to secure this home .In our minds you did AMAZING, to help to secure this wonderful Beach condo . We will be eternal grateful for you help before during and not least YOUR AFTER SALES SERVICE . You do not care how many hours you have to spend to make both buyer seller and HOA satisfied . I can only say you are the most honest realtor in the World Thank you

Buyer review
So far the best expirience with a realtor...
about 8 years ago
So far the best expirience with a realtor...

So far the best expirience with a realtor. Polly Rogers really care for you and make sure all is correct for buyer and seller. Her AFTER sales service is however the most amazing. I my case I had serious troubles with the HOA both before the sale and after . She stayed on the case for both seller (me) and buyer and spend minimum 100 hours to solve all issues .WITHOUT asking one penny for Polly . True and honest and caring is the best describtion and i can only give her my best recommendation . Thank you Polly

Seller review
I cannot say enough good things about Polly
almost 10 years ago
I cannot say enough good things about Polly

After interviewing 3 different real estate agents it became very clear, very quickly that Polly Rogers was the best fit for the sale of our home. She was enthusiastic, professional, passionate and very experienced. She always came to our home with a "can do" attitude and that was reflected in the price she negotiated for the sale of our home. She worked with us during a very difficult phase in our life and did so with grace. I cannot say enough good things about Polly. I will definitely be using her in all my future real estate ventures.

Buyer review
She did... another wonderful job this time
almost 11 years ago
She did... another wonderful job this time

My husband and I worked with Polly 6 years ago to purchase this home. She did a great job for us then and another wonderful job this time. Her expertise helped us price the home right for current market conditions. It was her knowledge of getting the house exposed to as much traffic asap that helped us get 6 offers in 6 days. As a home owner it's great to have the sell go quickly and relieve the stress of maintaining show conditions every day.

Seller review
She is the best realtor I have ever known, a really great person
almost 12 years ago
She is the best realtor I have ever known, a really great person

Polly Rogers brought me a qualified buyer within a couple days of listing with her, and her help was crucial in the negotiations to sell my property on terms that were very acceptable to me and to the buyer. She is the best realtor I have ever known, a really great person.

Seller review
Her knowledge of the area and experience in San Diego real estate helped us tremendously.
about 12 years ago
Her knowledge of the area and experience in San Diego real estate helped us tremendously.

We recently moved to San Diego from New Jersey, and was recommended to Polly from one of her past clients (a friend-of-friend). We made several trips to San Diego during the home search and Polly visited other good candidate homes in our absence. <br/><br/>Polly assisted in getting us the house we loved, for a fair price. <br/><br/>When my parents decided to follow us cross-country, we recommended they use Polly too. Like us, she helped them while they searched for properties from the East Coast and during their trip to San Diego. They found their house and closed during their first trip. Polly went over-and-above the call of duty to help them through the inspection and closing while they were selling up their NJ property. Her knowledge of the area and experience in San Diego real estate helped us tremendously.<br/><br/>We were very happy with Polly and would definitely recommend her.

13 - 24 of 24
© 2026 RateMyAgent