Polly's profile

Polly's reviews

  5  
Polly has 24 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Polly's qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, great negotiation, friendly, responsive, dedicated, reliable, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
A consummate professional with many years of experience from the Ranch to the Coast and Beyond
5 months ago
A consummate professional with many years of experience from the Ranch to the Coast and Beyond

We can’t recommend Polly Rogers enough! From the very beginning, she made the entire process of selling our home so smooth and stress-free. Her deep knowledge of the market, attention to detail, and unwavering dedication truly set her apart. Polly went above and beyond in every aspect, and we felt confident that the sale of our property was in good hands. If you’re looking for a realtor who is professional, trustworthy, and genuinely cares about your needs, look no further!

Seller review
Exremely high market knowledge, communication and professionalism
9 months ago
Exremely high market knowledge, communication and professionalism

Polly is extremely knowledgably technically with all the never ending rules and regulations required to buy and sell a house. From fire zoning, inspections, market pricing to the endless details on contracts she was top notch. On top of that she is a lovely, caring person and was a joy to work with.

Seller review
Working with Polly is always a joy!
over 1 year ago
Working with Polly is always a joy!

Working with Polly is always a joy! Polly's professionalism and knowledge of the Cardiff market is outstanding as she has been my exclusive leasing agent for over 17 years and has sold 2-of our rental properties in the Cardiff market, both sold in record time! Polly gets 5-stars from us. Dennis & Jeannie

Seller review
Above & Beyond
over 1 year ago
Above & Beyond

Polly is the best agent we have ever worked with. We have sold and bought a few houses in our lives but she was by the far the best. Polly truly went above and beyond, handling every detail with expertise and care, she even took care of arranging all the work that needed to be done on the house before it was ready for sale. She earned our trust through proactive communication and hands-on management through some unexpected challenges that arose during the sale. Polly and her team executed with skill and calm, ensuring that we still maximized our return on investment. Polly’s dedication and professionalism truly set her apart, and we couldn’t have asked for a better experience. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a reliable and skilled real estate agent." Polly became family.

Buyer review
Straight and reliable agent
almost 2 years ago
Straight and reliable agent

This is the second property we have bought with Polly. Polly was on the top of whatever we asked for and she did a nice job negotiating the price and some of the repairs with the seller. We trust her with doing the due diligence and making sure we are getting the best deal. Looking forward to working on more deals with Polly in the future.

Buyer review
New Home Purchase
over 2 years ago
New Home Purchase

I recently worked with Polly to purchase a new home in the Del Mar area. With her highly respected reputation in the industry, she was able to get very quick access to a number of homes that met my search criteria. Throughout the process, Polly was exceptionally responsive, extremely well-versed in the inventory, prices, and listing agents of properties in the neighborhoods I was looking in, and negotiated a very good deal for the property (and contents!) I eventually purchased. Polly knew exactly what a competitive offer would be and what it would take to get what turned out to be a very popular property amongst potential buyers. Her experience, diligence, and attention to detail got me into my dream home. She never pressured me into one home or another, but provided sage advice on both the pros and cons of every property we evaluated. I'd unconditionally recommend Polly for your real estate needs, whether it's buying or selling.

Seller review
Greatest Experience!
almost 3 years ago
Greatest Experience!

Polly was professional and kind, she had terrific ideas and the sale was quick and easy! Would recommend to everyone!

Buyer review
Pleasant and smooth experience
almost 3 years ago
Pleasant and smooth experience

We were looking for an agent to help us find a desired house as part of our moving process to San Diego. Since we didn't know the area that well, we were looking for an honest and experienced realtor. Polly was recommended through a friend and after our first meeting it was clear she is the realtor we wanted to work with. It seems her passion and energy has kept increasing despite being in this business for decades. She was always available to meet in person even after a short notice, and toured several places for us patiently through FaceTime and video chat since we had not moved yet. We felt confident in our decisions since she always provided ample information, tried to understand our perspective and taste, and shared her honest opinion. After we found the right property to purchase, she was instrumental in securing the deal despite multiple bidders. Her instincts and good communication and negotiations with selling agents helped us understand what the seller was looking for and how to bid to get the property for the price and terms we were conformable. Polly spent countless hours to have smooth closing, either by scheduling inspections, preparing documents and identifying issues that sellers needed to address while we were out of town living in another city. We can't thank her enough because she continued helping us after closing, by either recommending contractors, meeting with them in the house and also sharing her valuable suggestions on remodeling our house. Beyond being a great realtor we found Polly a great human being, full of kindness and care and it was a pleasure to get to know her and work with her. We feel we have found a good friend and would love to work with her in future

Seller review
Experienced Agent Who is There For You
almost 3 years ago
Experienced Agent Who is There For You

I’ve bought two houses with Polly and the reason I’m a repeat customer is because I know she will be looking out for my best interest. She’s an expert negotiator and has the experience to get the job done right. She is the agent to have for San Diego county.

Buyer review
Polly was with us at every step to make the process a wonderful experience.
over 3 years ago
Polly was with us at every step to make the process a wonderful experience.

My family and I recently relocated to the San Diego area and worked with Polly to find our dream home. From the moment we met her on our house finding trip to the day we moved into in, Polly was with us at every step to make the process a wonderful experience. Polly's knowledge of the local market made our home search very efficient and she looked after our interests during the inspection, including recommending several local contractors to help take care of some improvements before we moved in. Polly and her team went above and beyond to make us feel very welcome here in San Diego.

Seller review
A GREAT BROKER!!
over 4 years ago
A GREAT BROKER!!

I was in the middle of a real estate transaction when my current realtor had to step back for health reasons, so she referred me to Polly and I am so glad she did. Polly was nice, helpful, tireless in her efforts to sell my condo, and above all, GREAT at her job. I have worked with sales people at different times in my life, and I would have to say that Polly is one of the best. She is professional & knows what she is doing. She sold it quickly and for a great price, all the while keeping me apprised was happening during the sales process. I was beyond happy to have her as my broker, and would not hesitate to use her again should the need arise.

1 - 12 of 24
© 2026 RateMyAgent