Penny's profile

Penny's reviews

  5  
Penny has 97 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Penny's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, patient, friendly, clear communication, supportive, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
An angel was sent to me.
about 2 months ago
An angel was sent to me.

To sell my home on beautiful Lay Lake after the death of my husband of 53 years was the most heart wrenching decision. Penny jumped right in and handled everything with patience, humor, compassion, understanding, a lot of much needed hand holding, guidance and advise. As a result, the house sold in 3 days for full asking price and closed in 4 weeks. With that same energy, she helped me find a perfect home mere blocks from my son and daughter-in-law. Both houses closed and I was able to move from one house to the next on the same day. She was God sent and I will always, always be grateful for her.

Seller review
Amazing realtor!
about 2 months ago
Amazing realtor!

My husband and I had an absolutely fantastic experience working with this realtor. From start to finish, Penny was professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in helping us sell this property. She took the time to understand this was not the easiest home to sell but made the entire process feel smooth and had the resources we needed to get the sale complete. Her communication was excellent—she was always quick to respond to questions, kept us updated every step of the way, and explained everything clearly so my husband and I felt confident that it would sell. What really stood out was her dedication and attention to detail. She went above and beyond to make sure we received the best possible outcome. We truly felt like we had someone in our corner who cared about us successfully selling our flip not just the sale. I would highly recommend Penny to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. You won’t find someone more reliable, hardworking, and easy to work with. Penny is already in the process of selling a second house for us.

Buyer review
Penny is the Best and has your best interest in mind.
2 months ago
Penny is the Best and has your best interest in mind.

We have used Penny for both buying and selling during different times. Recently we were the purchaser. Penny will always make you feel like you are her first priority. When actually she is a great juggler. She hears what you are saying and attends to your wants. She will jump through hoops to make it happen for you. I am happy to call her my friend and realtor! She will always be our first choice in a realtor. There are good realtors and there are GREAT realtors and Penny is the BEST of the BEST.

Buyer review
Excellent in every aspect
3 months ago
Excellent in every aspect

I bought the property sight unseen with the excellent description and knowledge of the area that Penny gave us.

Seller review
Excellent Agent!
3 months ago
Excellent Agent!

Penny did a fantastic job getting this estate sale ready for market. She staged it so it was a welcoming home. In fact, it was so welcoming that it was under contract the first weekend on the market! Penny is easy to get to know and a great communicator. She made the process easy from the beginning through the closing. I cannot recommend her enough!

Seller review
Penny has a deep understanding of the market and took the time to understand my goals.
3 months ago
Penny has a deep understanding of the market and took the time to understand my goals.

Penny did a masterful job. She was very professional and thorough and followed up on every detail at every point in the process. Her experience and market knowledge was obvious from the outset, and she quickly became our trusted adviser. The preparation she put in to marketing our house and how she presented it online was extremely impressive, including professional photography and aerial video footage. She did an excellent job in designing the sale process, scheduling and managing many dozens of showings within a short time, and generating multiple offers that were at or above our expectations. She is a dealmaker, the best I’ve worked with.

Seller review
Exceptional agent and stress-free experience
5 months ago
Exceptional agent and stress-free experience

Working with Penny was truly a great experience. From the beginning, she listened closely to what we felt and what was most important to us as the sellers. She guided us with her expertise while still respecting and incorporating our input— it always felt like a team approach. We felt supported every step of the way and confident that she had our best interests at heart. Penny made the selling process feel surprisingly easy and even enjoyable. The extra touches and thoughtful hints she offered helped highlight the positive features of our home in ways we hadn’t even considered. We couldn’t have asked for a better agent to represent us and would highly recommend Penny Miller to anyone looking to sell their home.

Seller review
Fantastic Experience
6 months ago
Fantastic Experience

Penny is an excellent realtor. Penny has now sold 2 homes for us and both experiences were great. She is attentive to what we wanted, worked hard to market the property and was very in tune with the local markets. I have already recommended Penny to one of my best friends and would do so again. We couldnt have asked for a better experience.

Seller review
Penny Goes Above and Beyond Every Step of the Way!!
8 months ago
Penny Goes Above and Beyond Every Step of the Way!!

Working with Penny Miller was an absolute pleasure! From start to finish, she went above and beyond to make the process smooth, stress-free, and successful. Penny is not only incredibly knowledgeable about the market, but she’s also attentive, patient, and genuinely cares about her clients. She took the time to explain every step, answered all of my questions promptly, and always made me feel like a top priority. Her professionalism, attention to detail, and strong communication skills gave me so much confidence throughout the entire process. Penny’s dedication, expertise, and warm personality truly set her apart. I couldn’t have asked for a better agent to guide me, and I’m so grateful for all her hard work. If you’re looking for someone who will go the extra mile and truly have your best interests at heart, I highly recommend Penny Miller!

Seller review
Professionalism And Expertise
11 months ago
Professionalism And Expertise

Selling my mother’s home was a deeply personal experience, and I feel incredibly fortunate to have had Penny Miller by my side through it all. From our very first conversation, Penny brought a rare combination of professionalism, compassion, and deep knowledge of the market. She understood the emotional weight this sale carried and handled everything with genuine care. Penny managed every detail seamlessly with poise and confidence. I always felt informed, supported, and never pressured. It was clear she had our best interests at heart every step of the way. What I appreciated most was Penny’s warmth and integrity. She treated the home with the respect it deserved, and I always knew I could trust her guidance. She didn’t just help sell a property—she helped us honor a chapter of our family’s life. I wholeheartedly recommend Penny Miller to anyone looking for more than just a real estate agent. She’s a true partner, and I’m so grateful for everything she did for us

Seller review
Above and Beyond!
about 1 year ago
Above and Beyond!

From the first meeting at the house we knew we had the best in the business. Penny was professional and really got to know us and knew what we need to get things moving on the sale of our lake house. Penny took care of all the details very quickly; getting comps in the area and took time to also stage the home for its first showings. Communication was excellent between us and other agents. We had an offer within 2days and we closed 3 weeks later! Not only did we have the best experience but we made a new friend as well. I highly recommend Penny Miller for all your real estate needs!

Buyer review
Highly Recommend Penny – Perfect Agent!
about 1 year ago
Highly Recommend Penny – Perfect Agent!

We had the pleasure of working with Penny to purchase our lake house, and we couldn’t be more impressed! From start to finish, Penny was incredibly knowledgeable, attentive, and helpful throughout the entire process. No question or request was too much, and she always took the time to ensure we felt confident and informed. It’s not easy to find a real estate agent who makes you feel truly comfortable and supported, but Penny made that happen. We felt completely at ease working with her, and we know that when it comes time for our next real estate transaction, Penny will be the first person we call. We’re excited to work with her again in the future!

1 - 12 of 97
© 2026 RateMyAgent