Nicole Youkstetter

Nicole Youkstetter

Associate Broker / Owner at Mountain Resort Realty
  •   5   (17 reviews)

About Nicole

Nicole Youkstetter is the dynamic Associate Broker and Owner making waves in the Idaho real estate scene. With an impressive local expertise spanning several key locations like 83638, 83615, 83611, 83647, and 83654, ID, Nicole has solidified her reputation as a go-to expert in the area. In the past year, Nicole has spearheaded the listing of 31 properties while successfully sealing the deal on eight remarkable properties. Her effective strategy leads to an average market duration of just 82 days, showcasing her commitment to quick and effective sales. With over 15 stellar reviews, earning her a perfect 5-star rating, her clients consistently praise her dedication, professionalism, and keen market insight. Nicole's diverse portfolio highlights her versatility with a special knack for land and townhouse transactions as well as expertise in dealing with condos and single-family homes. This breadth of knowledge makes her an invaluable asset for clients seeking to buy or sell in the area. Her insightful approach, backed by her dedication and experience, ensures each client receives personalized, results-driven service tailored to their unique needs. For a seamless real estate experience in Idaho, Nicole Youkstetter is the expert to trust.

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 17 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 6.
Review Nicole
about 1 month ago
Quick close

We found our dream property in McCall online and reached out to the Nicole the listing agent to see it the very next day. She made time for us immediately, and from our first meeting she was personable, welcoming, and genuinely interested in helping us with the sale. She quickly recognized how much this property meant to us and worked hard to keep the transaction moving forward smoothly and efficiently for both parties. Nicole was incredibly accommodating and went out of her way to make the entire process easy with a quick close. What really set her apart was her willingness to continue helping even after the sale. She generously shared recommendations for painters, contractors, and other local professionals to help us make improvements to our new home. Her professionalism, responsiveness, and kindness made buying our dream property a wonderful experience. We are so grateful for everything she did and would highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling in the McCall area.

about 2 months ago
Very professional and excellent to work with.

Nicole far exceeded our expectation of enthusiasm and knowledge of our location of our property and really embraced working with us to get our house sold in a timely manner. The photographer Phil took wonderful pictures at dusk with all the lights on which was amazing and gorgeous. Nicole is a delight to work with and we highly recommend her.

over 3 years ago
She came highly recommended by our builder!

We were referred to Nicole by our builder. She has a ton of experience in the McCall area and did an excellent job representing us in the purchase of a building lot.

over 3 years ago
Nicole is the consummate professional.

I am a lifetime real estate investor and an Idaho home owner and resident. I have bought dozens of homes over the past forty years and no one has ever matched the integrity, creativity or steadfast efforts to help me convey or obtain interest in property than Nicole. She is quick to network with other agents, potential sellers or buyers pursuing my interests. She is creative in marketing and constantly demonstrates enthusiastic effort to make deals work for her clients. Robert M Flaten...

almost 4 years ago
I have had nothing but excellent service with ReMax

From the few days that went by between buying my new house and trying to sell my current property, it went from a sellers market to a buyers market. I started to think I would never sell my house, but Nicole came through and actually got me much more than I thought I would get, considering the housing market down turn. I have dealt with ReMax three times and everytime has been a positive experience. I don't think I will ever use another company other than ReMax.

almost 4 years ago
This girl is the “BEST”

Nicole is not just another nice realtor-she’s truly honest, up front and “knows her stuff!” She’s not in it to just make a sale, but is there for you and your best interests. We’ve had 3 different properties we’ve bought with her, she makes it easy and effortless. She also dresses so cute!! We love her!! M&M

Show all 17 reviews

Nicole's properties

Nicole has 31 properties for sale and sold 7 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldJul 9, 2026
Price not available
656 Douglas Dr/304 Samson Court
McCall ID 83638
3
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Real Estate of McCall and Mountain Resort Realty
SoldMay 21, 2026
Price not available
383 Rio Vista Boulevard
McCall ID 83638
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Mountain Resort Realty
Pending
$464,900
PO. Box 2973/1630 Davis Avenue
McCall ID 83638
2
2
2
Condo
Listing courtesy of Mountain Resort Realty
SoldApr 27, 2026
Price not available
117 Morgan Dr
McCall ID 83638
Land
Listing courtesy of REMAX Resort Realty | Kihei
Show all 38 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent