Nicole's profile

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 15 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
She came highly recommended by our builder!

We were referred to Nicole by our builder. She has a ton of experience in the McCall area and did an excellent job representing us in the purchase of a building lot.

over 3 years ago
Nicole is the consummate professional.

I am a lifetime real estate investor and an Idaho home owner and resident. I have bought dozens of homes over the past forty years and no one has ever matched the integrity, creativity or steadfast efforts to help me convey or obtain interest in property than Nicole. She is quick to network with other agents, potential sellers or buyers pursuing my interests. She is creative in marketing and constantly demonstrates enthusiastic effort to make deals work for her clients. Robert M Flaten...

over 3 years ago
I have had nothing but excellent service with ReMax

From the few days that went by between buying my new house and trying to sell my current property, it went from a sellers market to a buyers market. I started to think I would never sell my house, but Nicole came through and actually got me much more than I thought I would get, considering the housing market down turn. I have dealt with ReMax three times and everytime has been a positive experience. I don't think I will ever use another company other than ReMax.

over 3 years ago
This girl is the “BEST”

Nicole is not just another nice realtor-she’s truly honest, up front and “knows her stuff!” She’s not in it to just make a sale, but is there for you and your best interests. We’ve had 3 different properties we’ve bought with her, she makes it easy and effortless. She also dresses so cute!! We love her!! M&M

almost 4 years ago
Nicole is awesome! Going above and beyond!!

Nicole made shopping for a new home a great experience. If she wasn’t available to show something she made sure someone else was! Great communication

over 5 years ago
Only agent I would recommend for selling or buying up there

Nicole has been great at helping sell my house in Donnelly and helped me get a good agent to sell a house even in Boise. She also was the buyer's agent on several of the Greystone Village Town homes that I built in McCall. She has always been very friendly with the clients and does her best to represent everyone fairly. She is the only realtor I would recommend for buying or selling in the area.

over 7 years ago
Thank you Nicole!

Thank you Nicole. You went beyond our expectations when selling our home. I will highly recommend you to everyone I find looking to buy or sell a home. Thank you again Bret R.

over 7 years ago
My husband and I took a leap of faith and Nicole made it happen!

My husband and I took a leap of faith and moved our family to McCall about 2 months ago. I contacted Nicole immediately as we wanted to get settled into a house quickly before the snow hit - she was always able to work with our hectic schedules when it came to showing us homes. After a couple of weeks we found our forever home, made an offer and Nicole made it happen! She was so great to work with, very knowledgeable about the community - we felt like we walked away with a great deal on a home and a friendship with Nicole. I highly recommend!

over 8 years ago
Nicole is an excellent local realtor and she really represented us and our interests!

Nicole is an excellent local realtor and she really represented us and our interests well, when we bought our home. She has good relationships with the other professionals in the industry, was able to make loads of recommendations for services and contractors and has kept in touch to ensure we're melding into the community. Nicole Youkstetter is top-notch and has the knowledge, experience and organization to be considered one of McCall's best realtors.

almost 10 years ago
Nicole is a real professional!

Nicole is a real professional. We listed our McCall lakeside property with her and she had it sold within the time frame we were hoping for. She kept in constant communication with us through emails and phone calls and offered to assist us in property improvements and maintenance per buyer contingencies. We were very pleased with her services and those of AmeriTitle.6

over 10 years ago
Was a pleasure working with Nicole. She took...

Was a pleasure working with Nicole. She took care of all of our questions and tried to meet our unique demands. We not only had a great real estate agent but made a nice friend in the meantime.

1 - 12 of 15
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent