Nicole Starner

Nicole Starner

REALTOR® at RE/MAX 1st Advantage
PA: RS326418
  •   5   (3 reviews)

About Nicole

I am born and raised in central PA, living on both the east shore and west shore so I can help you buy or sell in any area. Working with me will be a very easy process as I will make sure everything in the background runs smoothly so you have an enjoyable experience.

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 3 reviewsacross 3 different locations, showing 3.
Review Nicole
almost 6 years ago
A positive experience from start to finish

Nicole could not have made this process any easier! I was buying a house from out of area, so the capability to look at houses was limited. She had no problem accommodating our schedule for that. Communication was flawless, and trust me, the amount of questions I had I'm sure tested that. She never made it sound like I was inconveniencing her, truly she was here to help any time any day. Nicole helped us get the house we wanted, even after there was already an offer on it! We came up one weekend to look at a handful of properties we had saved online, but this one was our favorite. When we got here, she informed us there was an offer on the house. The disappointment was so great. But Nicole didn't just give up, she contacted the seller and got us set up to look at the house still. When we walked in, we knew it was our house, but had some apprehension with the offer being on it. Nicole came up with a plan, reached out to the seller's agent, and within that same day, the offer was accepted and the house was ours! Nicole got us our dream house that had an offer on it already! Talk about an accomplishment right there! The paperwork on buying a house can be inundating of course. Nicole made the process so smooth. With all electronic documents labeled clearly where we needed to sign and what we needed to look over, it took a lot of that burden away. I cannot express my gratitude for Nicole and what she did for us enough. If you are looking for an agent, look no further. Thanks Nicole!

about 6 years ago
Above and Beyond

Nicole truly went above and beyond when selling our home. This process could have been a nightmare since we were trying to sell while living overseas but Nicole is an phenomenal professional that accommodated ya in every situation. I can not recommend her enough!

about 6 years ago
Fabulous Experience

In 2017, my husband and I used Nicole Starner to find our very first home together and she was outstanding. With both my husband and myself being first time home buyers, we were nervous with starting the process. However, Nicole instantly put us at ease. Talking with her was like talking to an old friend. She clearly explained the home buying process in a manner that was easy to understand. If any questions arose, she answered them promptly. When looking for homes, Nicole set up an auto search for our areas of interest, including the features we wanted in the home. This was very convenient as we were often able to see homes as soon as they came onto the market. As we are just starting out, price was of our utmost concern, and Nicole was very mindful of our budget and never once attempted to persuade us to spend more than we were comfortable. After selecting some homes we had interest in, Nicole quickly set up viewing times and was not just on time to meet us, she was early. What I really enjoyed was how she let my husband and I explore the home on our own. She never once tried to gloss over an area of concern so she could make a quick sale. In fact, she was very good at pointing out potential problem areas we should consider. She also took into consideration that we were using an FHA loan, which requires stricter inspections. Again, being new to the process, this knowledge was immensely helpful. Because of Nicole’s expert guidance, we were able to put an offer on a home that had been on the market for just one day. We accepted their reasonable counter offer. Everything concerning the inspections and appraisals was smooth and easy to understand. I cannot recommend Nicole Starner enough. The home buying process is not always easy and it is quite often stressful, but you’d be hard pressed to find a better realtor.

Nicole's properties

Nicole has 3 properties for sale and sold 2 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 8, 2026
$355,000
23 Dewalt Dr
Mechanicsburg PA 17050
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty and Howard Hanna Company-Carlisle
Pending
$224,900
253 Worcester Ave
Lawnton PA 17111
3
2
1
Townhouse
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty
Under Contract
$145,000
1821 State Street
Harrisburg PA 17103
4
2
1
Townhouse
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty
SoldJun 25, 2025
$335,900
403 North 48th Street
Lawnton PA 17111
4
2
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty
Show all 5 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent