Nicki's profile

Nicki's reviews

  5  
Nicki has 24 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
almost 5 years ago
Thank you Nicki!

I have known Nicki for years, and we have successfully executed several transactions together over the years. However, nothing in our past prepared us for this most recent Sarasota market. Anyone can do well in an easy market, but only a true market knowledgeable professional with extensive experience and exceptional people skills can successfully navigate a challenging market. Nicki represents all of the above. Nicki tirelessly worked her extensive network, and every issue, to help us find and close on exactly the home we hoped for. It was not an easy process, and there were several different homes in the mix; each with their own challenges. In the end, Nicki led us through all the twist and turns ultimately landing the home we really wanted. Without Nicki I am certain that would not have been the case.

almost 5 years ago
Hardworking , dedicated, and experienced! I began searching for a home in the end of 2020

Hardworking , dedicated, and experienced! I began searching for a home in the end of 2020. The market was sparse, so I met with Nicki and explained what I was looking for. In addition to the automated email alerts of listings in my location and price range, she always let me know when one of them came up that seemed "tailor-fit" for me - she really knew my tastes and knew me as a person, rather than just a client. When I found my home, she worked closely with the listing agent, encouraging her that I was credit-worthy and would be a good fit for the neighborhood. After my bid was accepted she continued to guide me through the process to closing, and always available to answer my questions. If not for her personal efforts, I would probably still be looking for a home. Buying a home is hard. Nicki made this as stress-free as possible for me.

about 5 years ago
Hardworking , dedicated, and experienced

I began searching for a home in the end of 2020. The market was sparse, so I met with Nicki and explained what I was looking for. In addition to the automated email alerts of listings in my location and price range, she always let me know when one of them came up that seemed "tailor-fit" for me - she really knew my tastes and knew me as a person, rather than just a client. When I found my home, she worked closely with the listing agent, encouraging her that I was credit-worthy and would be a good fit for the neighborhood. After my bid was accepted she continued to guide me through the process to closing, and always available to answer my questions. If not for her personal efforts, I would probably still be looking for a home. Buying a home is hard. Nicki made this as stress-free as possible for me.

about 5 years ago
Another successful transaction and delightful client experience!

Nicki is always a consummate professional with exceptional market knowledge and wonderful interpersonal skills. Her business acumen is only surpassed by her style and approach in working diligently on behalf of her clients. Nicki's poise under pressure is a differentiator, especially in such a challenging (sellers) market. As a buyer, the process has not been easy, but Nicki's unwavering, selfless client-first commitment is to be commended. She does not take the easy approach over the right approach, and there were several occasions that without Nicki's guidance we would have ended up in a situation that was not in our best interest as her client. In the end, Nicki found the ideal situation for all parties (seller and buyer), and I am very pleased with the outcome and suspect the seller feels the same. I highly recommend Nicki Conway to both sellers and buyers as she has represented me in both over the years with the same excellent result.

about 5 years ago
Sold our house in 3 days for asking PLUS $20K !!

Nicki set up everything -- from the stager (our option) to the professional photo shoot to the marketing on MLS and internet to the showing of the house. She was there for 3 days -- 21 showings, 4 offers ! Helped us thru the move and was at the closing to make sure everything went smoothly. Would recommend her to anyone selling, or buying a home in Sarasota. JB

about 5 years ago
Highly recommend

Nicki is professional, knowledgeable and dependable. She made our purchasing experience stress-free.

over 5 years ago
5 star service

We had been planning a move for over 10 years. Nicki was kind enough to send me real estate listings all those years. I am sure she was shocked when I emailed and told her we were ready to make the move. We we flew down to look at homes because virtual was not how we wanted to shop for a home although Nicki was willing to do the virtual showing if we wanted. We only had 2 days to look so Nicki looked over all my saved homes to get an idea of what we were looking for. She picked us up and drove us all over Sarasota and Lakewood Ranch. She made the process of buying a home an easy one. Finally after 2 very full days of hunting we found two home that we really liked. We decided on the very last home we saw and we couldn’t be happier. As far as the closing process, Nicki was knowledgeable and very helpful. Todd and I would highly recommend Nicki for all your real estate needs.

over 5 years ago
Best of the Best!

Best of the Best! Nicki's years of experience in this area has given her an in-depth knowledge of the real estate market, neighborhoods, builders, and the competition. This, coupled with her work ethic and commitment to managing your success, puts you in good hands. Whether you are buying or selling her wealth of contacts developed over the years of success is a significant plus in achieving your goals. You can't go wrong with the Best of the Best. Verified by RateMyAgent

over 5 years ago
Patient and Attentive

Nikki was patient and understood what we were looking for. ( it wasn’t easy-lol). I highly recommend her skills and expertise when looking for your future home. :)

over 5 years ago
Relocated to Florida with Nicki's help

We contacted Nicki from Ohio and she was always available and ready to assist. She promptly answered any questions we had regarding Florida homes. This may sound routine to some but it was a two year process over the phone and via email before we even visited Florida. Nicki was professional in all of our interactions. Her knowledge of the market made our search for a new home so much easier. We have a new home and love it!

1 - 12 of 24
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent