Natalie's profile

Natalie's reviews

  5  
Natalie has 104 reviewsacross 42 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Natalie is great agent and everything was very professional
about 4 years ago
Natalie is great agent and everything was very professional

We were very happy to work together with Natalie and it was only thanks to her that we found a wonderful home. My wife and I highly recommend our agent Natalie to anyone who wants to buy a home. She is a very professional agent who knows a lot and her advice was very useful to us. She led us to a successful and joyful purchase our house.Thanks a lot Natalie!

Buyer review
Highly Recommended Agent
about 4 years ago
Highly Recommended Agent

We were very happy to work together with Natalie and it was only thanks to her that we found a wonderful home. My wife and I highly recommend our agent Natalie to anyone who wants to buy a home. She is a very professional agent who knows a lot and her advice was very useful to us. She led us to a successful and joyful purchase our house.Thanks a lot Natalie!

Buyer review
Great experience with Natalie
about 4 years ago
Great experience with Natalie

I purchased 3 properties with Natalie and I always had a great experience. She guided me through every step of the process and gave good recommendations for the investment properties, inspector services, title, attorney, insurance services, and many more. Natalie is very easy to work with, she is reliable and trustworthy. She was always looking out for my best interests and made me aware of any potential risks or pitfalls. Natalie is very transparent in her communications and she is on top of things and always proactive. She continued helping me even after closing with the rental process and questions. If you are looking for an honest, trustworthy and competent realtor, I highly recommend reaching out to Natalie. You will be in great hands with her.

Buyer review
Amazing, helpful, and congenial!
about 4 years ago
Amazing, helpful, and congenial!

On top things always! Amazing, helpful, and congenial! Goes out of her way to make sure things are heading in the right direction. Excellent service!!! Very great full!!!

Buyer review
Without Natalie, I wouldn't have bought a home
over 4 years ago
Without Natalie, I wouldn't have bought a home

I was an extremely picky buyer for investment properties, and nothing that I've seen on the market was appealing to me and hit all my criteria. Until Natalie came into the picture and did all the heavy lifting - she found opportunities that other agents wouldn't have found, and consulting with me on my needs at every step along the way. I recommend everybody have at least 1 intro conversation with Natalie before talking with other agents in the area.

Buyer review
Natalie is phenomenal!
over 4 years ago
Natalie is phenomenal!

She is phenomenal. She is knowledgeable in her scope of practice and honest if there might be something unclear. However, she goes the extra mile to research every inquiry to answer you with confidence. She was an absolute pleasure to work with and made the daunting process more of a nice adventure. I am a first time homeowner so there was a lot of patience required on her part. I trust her so much that I’ll be repeating this whole process for my mother now. Thank you so much for being our agent and our #1 advocate.

Buyer review
Great experience!
over 4 years ago
Great experience!

Natalie is fabulous! She took great care of my mom’s transaction, and then a few months later, mine. Natalie is professional, dependable, smart, and caring. She really made the process stress-free because I knew I was in great hands. She’s super-wonderful to work with and I highly recommend her!

Buyer review
Natalie is fabulous!
over 4 years ago
Natalie is fabulous!

Natalie is fabulous! She took great care of my mom’s transaction, and then a few months later, mine. Natalie is dependable, smart, and caring. She really made the process stress-free because I knew I was in great hands. She’s super-wonderful to work with and I highly recommend her!

Buyer review
Positive,Professionalism, Responsiveness
over 4 years ago
Positive,Professionalism, Responsiveness

She helped us understand what to expect throughout the buying process, identifying the best offer, and getting through the inspection process. Right thru closing, she was incredibly responsive. I’d highly recommend her, and use her again without a second thought.

Buyer review
Working with Natalie was a real pleasure!
over 4 years ago
Working with Natalie was a real pleasure!

Working with Natalie was a real pleasure. Natalie is the most genuine, responsible, trustworthy, and professional realtor there is. From the day I met Natalie to the day I closed, Natalie was there every step of the way. She always made me feel like a priority. She became more than a realtor to us, she became a family. Her strong knowledge and experience made the process of buying a house stress free. I am so grateful for Natalie and would highly recommend her to anyone!

Buyer review
Natalie is a talented, energetic, transparent and warm realtor!
over 4 years ago
Natalie is a talented, energetic, transparent and warm realtor!

Natalie Pantelo from Realty One Freehold is a talented, energetic, transparent and warm realtor. She worked with my husband and I to sell our home of over 50 years. When we engaged her to be our realtor, we were in the process of buying a new condo that was closer to our daughter and her family. Natalie provided truly white glove service that started with a very detailed sellers report which explained how she derived the hyper-local market value of our home. She determined the perfect listing price that was low enough to attract a large number of buyers, yet still exceeded our expectation of what our home could be sold for. Her efforts to list at the perfect price, market via 3D video tour, professional photos and floorplans lead to multiple offers received within 2 days of listing. She managed the "Highest and Best" bidding process and we were astonished when the winning bid came in at $25K over listing (all cash and flexible closing). She provided reliable referrals (always more than one choice) for an attorney, electrician, plumber, mover, clean-out service, cleaning service and radon remediation. She assisted us in clearing out our house by listing items for us to lower the cleanout expense. We trusted her to represent us at appointments at the house, after we had moved to our new home before closing. We cannot thank her enough for walking us through this very personal, confidential and critical home selling process. Natalie was there at every step to provide honest information and advocate for us on the many issues and questions that came up. We would definitely recommend her to anyone interested in finding the best realtor to sell their home!

Seller review
My One and Only Agent
over 4 years ago
My One and Only Agent

I am an investor buying, selling and renting properties all the time and I've used many agents in the past before choosing Natalie as my one and only agent for all of my real-estate transactions. She is super dedicated, very professional, honest, transparent and the most active and hard working person I've ever met. She understands the real-estate market, she knows how to approach different people and situations, and she is a very competent and knowledgeable realtor. I was amazed with the level of analysis and research she performed on the properties I considered for investment! Nobody ever done that for me in the past. She is very effective in how she lays out the information, numbers, and facts to help her clients make the most educated decision. Most importantly, Natalie is very open and straight forward in pointing out potential pit falls and problems. She is not there to make a quick sale! She is there to help her clients make the right decision and it's important to her to see her clients happy with their decision. TRULY AMAZING. I highly recommend her.

73 - 84 of 104
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent