Nancy's profile

Nancy's reviews

  5  
Nancy has 86 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Nancy's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, reliable, dedicated, great negotiation, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
HIRE NANCY!
almost 2 years ago
HIRE NANCY!

Nancy has in depth knowledge of the Munds Park and the surrounding mountain communities. If your looking for an HONEST realtor, who knows what you should and should not expect, this is the one! I've worked with several realtors and she is at the top of the list! Don't miss an opportunity with someone you know, branch out and get what you deserve :)

Seller review
Nancy is awesome
about 2 years ago
Nancy is awesome

Nancy was amazing to work with. She was always available to us, very knowledgeable, helped us though every curve ball, and helped ease our minds along the way. I would highly recommend Nancy to anyone looking to buy or sell a house. You won't be disappointed.

Seller review
Beyond Expectations!
over 2 years ago
Beyond Expectations!

Nancy is in a league of her own in the real estate game, distinguishing herself as the epitome of professionalism and dedication. Having engaged the services of numerous realtors throughout our lives, none have come close to the exceptional service Nancy provided. Her support and guidance clearly highlighted the ways other realtors fell short. Nancy's attention to detail paved a seamless path for selling our home and purchasing a new one, ensuring our journey was as stress-free as possible. She brought an unmatched level of honesty and transparency to the table. She walked us through the contract, explaining details that mattered in a way no other realtor did. She was with us through the inspections and the walk-throughs, truly every step of the way. Her effective communication set accurate expectations, significantly alleviating the usual anxieties associated with real estate transactions. What truly sets Nancy apart are her remarkable listening and intuitive skills. She anticipated our needs and questions, providing answers before we even asked our questions. This foresight was reassuring and reflective of her talent and deep commitment to our satisfaction. Before, finding the right home often felt like a solitary journey, with realtors presenting options that scarcely matched our desires. Nancy, however, shattered this pattern. The first property she introduced us to was perfect in all the essential ways, a testament to her attentiveness and understanding of our needs. I actually had my sights set on another house and wasn't interested in looking at another, but Nancy insisted. So we did, and we fell in love with the home, and we fell in love with Nancy! Nancy, we cannot thank you enough for your hard work, mad negotiating skills that got us over asking for our home, knowing how to price our house so it sold quickly, and humor, which made the stress of buying and selling a home fun and dare I say it? Easy!

Buyer review
Extensive and detailed knowledge of Munds Park
over 2 years ago
Extensive and detailed knowledge of Munds Park

We had an excellent experience working with Nancy on an extensive search for the right property for us in Munds Park. She quickly came to understand the things that were important to us. Nancy was easy to communicate with and diligent in answering all of our questions related to the multiple properties that we viewed prior to finding the right one. Many times she was able to provide detailed information and documentation to make sure we would be completely comfortable with our selection. We would highly recommend Nancy Shelton to anyone buying or selling a property in the Munds Park or Flagstaff area.

Buyer review
Highly Recommend- Nancy Knows Northern AZ!
over 2 years ago
Highly Recommend- Nancy Knows Northern AZ!

I am so grateful for Nancy’s hard work and dedication. She came highly recommended to me and now I know why. Her knowledge of Northern AZ is unparalleled. She was on top of every detail, from the initial home search to closing and even after closing. Her professionalism, knowledge, and attention to details made the whole experience a joy. Thank you Nancy!

Seller review
We highly recommend her as an agent
over 2 years ago
We highly recommend her as an agent

Because she lives in Munds Park, where our home was she is very knowledgeable of the area and the market. She was always available to answer our questions and keep us informed of current conditions. Because we don’t live in the area she was always willing to help take care of things that came up with the house. She always conducted herself in a very professional manner and we enjoyed working with her. She followed up to make sure that all the details of the sale were completed.

Buyer review
Amazing customer service!
over 2 years ago
Amazing customer service!

Nancy was very professional, courteous and patient with us throughout our buying process. We highly recommend her!

Seller review
Munds Park
over 2 years ago
Munds Park

Nancy was very motivated to help us sell our house during a very stressful time in our lives. She was always there for us and an excellent communicator.

Buyer review
Nancy is the best realtor I have ever worked with!
over 2 years ago
Nancy is the best realtor I have ever worked with!

Nancy is a gem. We used her to purchase a home in Munds Park. She was on top of the market and very communicative. Her knowledge of the area was so helpful. I have purchased many homes and would rate her as the best realtor I have ever hired!

Seller review
Local expert
over 2 years ago
Local expert

Nancy is a local expert that helped us navigate some of the unique details of our transaction. She made sure we were set up for success. We ere very pleased with her knowledge and professionalism, and besides that, we consider her a new friend.

25 - 36 of 86
© 2026 RateMyAgent