Nancy's profile

Nancy's reviews

  5  
Nancy has 158 reviewsacross 35 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Professional

Nancy was great throughout our whole buying process, patient, extremely helpful especially since this was our first purchase. Always on time, great communicator, and an all around professional at what she does. Thank you again, Nancy!

over 3 years ago
I was fortunate enough to have Nancy bring a buyer for one of my listings

I was fortunate enough to have Nancy bring a buyer for one of my listings. The offer was well written, clear and concise. Her buyer was clear to close weeks ahead of schedule. We had great communication throughout the process. I look forward to working with her again in the future.

almost 4 years ago
Nancy and her Team are Top Notch!!

Super great things to say about Nancy and her Team!! Top notch and very communicative through the whole process of selling our Duplex. Definitely a 5 star experience!!

about 4 years ago
This was a great experience

This was a great experience. Also my first and she was so awesome. I am very thankful for her and her team. Everyone was great!!!

over 4 years ago
I 100% recommend Nancy to be your real estate agent

I 100% recommend Nancy to be your real estate agent. She checks all of the boxes in what you need and want in an agent. It doesn’t matter if you are buying or selling, she’s got you. Our transaction with her by our side was completely seamless! You’ll walk away more than satisfied hands down.

over 4 years ago
Nancy is everything you need and want in a realtor and so much more! Her knowledge of this business

Nancy is everything you need and want in a realtor and so much more! Her knowledge of this business and her business connections are out of this world. She is extremely professional and punctual. Nancy is a very busy agent, yet her responsiveness to each of her clients is lighting speed. Most importantly, she listens to you. She checks all of the boxes and gets the job done! I promise you won’t be disappointed when choosing her as your agent! She made our dream come true!

over 4 years ago
I would give Nancy more than 5 stars if we were able to! She went above and beyond, to make sure my

I would give Nancy more than 5 stars if we were able to! She went above and beyond, to make sure my family got their dream home. She put in countless hours and last minute showings, to be there for my family. She was professional, hard working and determined. She took the time to understand what my husband and I were both looking for, setting up a customized portal, which was super convenient and easy to use and browse. Buying a house in today’s market was difficult, but nothing was impossible, with Nancy Bartlebaugh! She will make it happen! She walked us through it all, from start to finish, flawlessly. Thank you Nancy!!!

over 4 years ago
I’d recommend Maria to anyone who needs a realtor in NE Ohio!

Maria was great to work with. She was helpful throughout the entire home-buying process and was able to track down answers to questions quickly. She kept me updated and attended all events, walk-throughs, and inspections. I’d recommend Maria to anyone who needs a realtor in NE Ohio.

over 4 years ago
Nancy’s team puts your needs first!

Working with Nancy both personally and professionally has been a pleasure. Nancy has the ability to get it done! When looking for a realtor you can not go wrong with this team. She puts people first but don’t be mistaken this group of ladies work together to ensure the job gets done! Stop looking and call her!

over 4 years ago
Nancy knew what we needed to help us find the perfect forever home for our family so she connected u

Nancy knew what we needed to help us find the perfect forever home for our family so she connected us with her sister Maureen (Mo) Brown. Mo went above and beyond all of our expectations. She was very honest and forthcoming with us about everything. She made us feel like we were important and not just a commission for her. Because of her we were able to find the perfect HOME for our family! We would recommend Nancy and her team to anyone who's looking for the perfect HOME for their family. We love you Mo!

49 - 60 of 158
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent