Nancy's profile

Nancy's reviews

  5  
Nancy has 158 reviewsacross 35 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Excellent

Knowledgeable, personal and thorough.

over 3 years ago
Nancy is an amazing REALTOR!

Nancy is an amazing REALTOR! She sold my house in 8 days (would have been sooner, but negotiations were at play!) She’s very dedicated to what she does! I’ve never met someone so on top of things at nearly every hour of the day. She makes the entire process so smooth. During the process, I needed a plumber and a handy man. She found them both, made the phone calls, and booked it all within moments (w/ my approval). I also got some work done to my house BEFORE I involved her in the sale. She reached out to them for warranties in minutes of me providing her the phone number. She’s crazy organized, thorough, informative, personable, fun to work with, and simply “on it.” If you’re looking for a REALTOR and you're unsure, she’s it. Just give her a text or call, she’ll answer, she always does!

over 3 years ago
Best Agent Ever!!

Nancy Bartlebaugh is the best agent ever. We could not have done this without her. The energy she brings to the table is amazing. Her knowledge is outstanding. My husband was selling his childhood home after his parents passed away. This was a very difficult process. for him. She guided us through every step, She answered every question along the way. She went above and beyond and then some. It was truly a pleasure working with her. She has an amazing team. We could have chosen anyone. We chose Nancy Bartlebaugh we put our trust in her. It paid off. She was able to take the burden off of us. So there’s no need to look any further. Choose Nancy you will not regret it!

over 3 years ago
NANCY WAS A GODSEND

Nancy was a true Godsend for my family and was probably one of the best aspects about our entire moving process. She coordinated staging, photos, an open house, and got us set up with an app to coordinate showings. We most appreciated how she talked us through comparisons, pricing strategies, and helped us understand and weigh our offers based on our goals. I felt completely confident that anything she was involved with was handled with the utmost professionalism and efficiency. Can't say enough good things!

over 3 years ago
Wonderful Realtor!

One of my new colleagues recommended that we work with Nancy -- and I am so glad that they did. Nancy took time to ensure that we were familiar with ALL he neighborhoods in and surrounding Akron. She showed us so many options -- and made sure to point out both positive and negative features of the properties we looked at. She was incredibly patient -- and we eventually found a home that met all of our criteria, including our budget. Working with Nancy was great!

over 3 years ago
Simply the best!

Nancy is so great to work with! She brings a vast array of skills to the table. Her real estate knowledge, her extensive network of contacts and her positive attitude make buying and selling a breeze!

over 3 years ago
Simply the Best!

Nancy is so great to work with! She brings a vast array of skills to the table. Her real estate knowledge, her extensive network of contacts and her positive attitude make buying and selling a breeze! Verified by RateMyAgent

over 3 years ago
I have fun

Maria’s very patient we’ve bought a bunch of places and I know I probably make things tougher than it could be! Always a pleasure, always exciting.

over 3 years ago
Great working with Nancy’s team

Maria was wonderful, selling my house and finding a new one….she was so willing to help every time I needed some info. I never felt like I was a bother, Maria was professional and kind 100% of the time!

25 - 36 of 158
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent