Monica's profile

Monica's reviews

  5  
Monica has 255 reviewsacross 34 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Monica's qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, detail-oriented, trustworthy, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Monica is the best in the Biz!
almost 2 years ago
Monica is the best in the Biz!

Monica Shea is an absolute top-notch realtor! This is the third time we've worked with her, and each experience has been fantastic. From buying our first home in the area, to selling it when we moved away, and now helping us return and find the perfect home in Gleneagle, Monica has been an invaluable resource. She and her team are incredibly professional, knowledgeable, and always go above and beyond to make the process smooth. We couldn’t be happier with our new home and highly recommend Monica to anyone looking for a realtor!

Buyer review
Monica, she is the best real estate agent ever!
almost 2 years ago
Monica, she is the best real estate agent ever!

This woman is one of the hardest working woman in Real Estate. She is so knowledgeable and very smart and patient and kind! She made my buying experience with her go unbelievably smooth. She had my back every step of the way. She keeps on giving and I highly recommend her for buying or selling real estate. You will not be sorry. She is fantastic and rain, shine, or snow, she shows up. For all your real estate needs choose Monica Shay! She’s the best.

Buyer review
5 Stars for Monica Shea & Team
almost 2 years ago
5 Stars for Monica Shea & Team

Purchase of home went smoothly, with Monica Shea & Team. Great guidance on process, kept me informed every step, and made sell/buy closings work perfectly. Monica was always available for questions and showings in the lead-up to finding a home in my preferred location. Monica and Team kept communication flowing between all entities to reach an easy & successful buy! Post-buy advice on vendors was available & valuable, too! I’ll be happy to work with her and team in future.

Seller review
No one better!
almost 2 years ago
No one better!

When I first met Monica, I was at the end of my rope. Extremely stressed, working full time, taking care of family and going back to school. The market was iffy, and I had been dealing with shady contractors, realtors that seemed to not know what they were doing, and facing a difficult time in my life. I was told my home was only good for investors and would lose money selling it. Then I met Monica. The first thing she did was give me a hug and tell me it was going to be ok. And somehow, she made it ok. Her calmness, confidence and knowledge of real estate made one of the scariest and stressful times in my life one of the easiest. She was able to sell my home for full asking price 2 days after it went on the market. She took care of everything and somehow kept me calm, even with having extreme anxiety. She is friend, confidant, magician, and somehow her sweet nature also shows through as a confident powerhouse to get the job done. I’m truly blessed to have met her and her husband Ryan, and her assistant Nan. These three are a team I will never forget and I look forward to working with them again.

Seller review
Efficient with great positive energy !
almost 2 years ago
Efficient with great positive energy !

Monica was great with the details and helped us navigate all aspects of selling our home. She kept us well informed and was excellent at pricing our home for market. She arranged all of the repairs after inspection, left detailed instructions and delivered on everything she said. I was amazed at the whole experience and would recommend her 100% !!

Seller review
Professional & Thorough
almost 2 years ago
Professional & Thorough

Monica Shea is the epitome of professional realtor. Great evaluation of the prospective sales process, and knew the market perfectly. Got better than expected price quickly! Her staff is top tier and keeps the process moving. Would recommend!

Buyer review
Monica earned 10-Stars!!
almost 2 years ago
Monica earned 10-Stars!!

We are transplants from Texas and interviewed a dozen or so agents and builders. From the beginning, Monica and her team distinguished themselves through their thorough understanding of the new state laws, neighborhoods, and what we were truly looking for in our forever home. We have closed on many homes but have never had our agent at our closing and final walk through. By far, Monica and her team stand head and shoulders above anyone else we have ever worked with!! We offer our strongest endorsement for Monica Shae.

Seller review
Phenomenal Agent!!! Monica is who you want on your side!!!
almost 2 years ago
Phenomenal Agent!!! Monica is who you want on your side!!!

Monica and her team were incredible!!! Her strategy for making necessary updates, staging, and pricing my home correctly in the first place were instrumental in my home selling in one day. Many other homes had been on the market for a number of days, and many had to drop their price at least once. However, Monica's strategy allowed me to avoid having the house sitting and potentially having to drop the price. Additionally, Monica's team did an outstanding job of quickly answering any questions I had and keeping me informed throughout the entire selling process. I highly recommend Monica for your agent.

Seller review
Truly is the best real estate agent out there
almost 2 years ago
Truly is the best real estate agent out there

I really can't say enough about Monica. She is the utmost professional, honest, detail oriented, hard working, a problem solver, and an amazing negotiator. It is so reassuring knowing that she is in your corner and she will always have your back in any situation. We've done 4 transactions with her and I wouldn't consider using anyone else. We've gotten above asking price and under contract quickly every time, and it wasn't because she low balls prices. She knows how to market and her business background gives her an edge. She treats her clients like gold and you will always be in her network family. Her team is simply fantastic. They are on top of everything and walk you through every detail. Nothing falls through the cracks. They are also some of the nicest people you will ever meet. Thank you so much Monica!

Seller review
Highly recommend!
almost 2 years ago
Highly recommend!

Monica and her assistant Nan are simply the best! Monica explains the whole process and keeps you updated on everything. Nan and Monica are a great team and treat you as if you are family. I highly recommend using Monica!

Seller review
Highly recommend Monica
almost 2 years ago
Highly recommend Monica

Monica is a professional, friendly and knowledgeable agent. My husband and I really connected with her on all levels! She was always updating us on any potential buyers and weekly updates in the market. We are super happy with her and highly recommend her for selling or buying a home. Thanks Monica 😊

Buyer review
Easiest Process Ever!
almost 2 years ago
Easiest Process Ever!

I have always heard how difficult and tedious buying a home is… this process was so smooth I was almost concerned it was TOO smooth! Monica and Ni Kari were both incredible and made buying my first home a joy. Thank you both!!!

61 - 72 of 255
© 2026 RateMyAgent