Michelle Rentzel

Michelle Rentzel

NAR: SL3497332
  •   5   (4 reviews)

About Michelle

Originally from York, Pennsylvania, my various entrepreneurial careers helped to create the person I am today…one who loves helping others! My love for real estate was generated with years of experience in Human Resources, Title Insurance, and hands-on experience in design, decorating and rejuvenation of tired spaces. My mission when I opened, owned and operated a successful multi-service Salon and Spa while managing 13 employees was to make the experience ALL about the client…and I succeeded! My mission today is the same…to make buying or selling a home ALL about the client! I believe your home is your sanctuary and should be treated as such. Whether you are buying your first home or seeking that dream retirement residence, the experience should be a happy one. I am here to help my clients navigate the challenges that often occur during the home buying and selling process, with the end result being a wonderful experience. Having built a home in Sarasota, I have first-hand knowledge in dealing with local builders, designers, and pool companies. My attention to detail and commitment to my clients are qualities I take great pride in. Clients always say my ability to listen and provide exactly what they want is what sets me apart from others. When taking time off from real estate, you will find me spending time with my family, basking in the Florida sunshine, kayaking, baking…my specialties are cupcakes and truffles, or helping my neighbors whether restoring furniture or interior decorating. As a wife, mother, and homeowner myself, I understand that your home is more than just a place to live – it's where you make long-lasting memories. Let me show you how the client comes first and foremost. Give me a call today at 941.993.7676!

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 4 reviewsacross 3 different locations, showing 4.
Review Michelle
about 3 years ago
Great Realtor

Michelle was a pleasure to work with. Michelle understood are concerns and was able to help us understand or resolve them. We’d recommend Michelle to others without hesitation. Peter and Pam Baranyai

about 3 years ago
Wonderful!

We are both licensed Real Estate Agents in another state and we were searching for a 2nd home in Florida. Michelle listened to our needs and emailed us properties that were exactly what we were looking for. We have worked with many, many agents and I must say that Michelle went above and beyond for us. She was very knowledgeable and found us the perfect place. She made the process exceptionally easy for us, especially closing remotely in a different state. I would highly recommend her. I could not have asked for better service.

over 3 years ago
She’s the Best!

Michelle has gone out of her way to help me find the perfect place in Florida! She had answers to all my questions and guided me through the whole process. This is a Big step for me and her guidance has helped me feel this is exactly where I need to be… thanks Michelle for being the special person that you are!

almost 4 years ago
Best realtor in Sarasota!!

Michelle was genuinely interested in helping me with every aspect of selling my home. She help me stage what I had in my home to make it more appealing to buyers. She’s the best!!

Michelle's properties

Michelle hasn't had any property sale activity in the last 12 months

EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent