Meridith's profile

Meridith's reviews

  4.8  
Meridith has 12 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Fantastic experience!

Meridith is the best! I had a fantastic experience. As I was a first-time seller, Meridith explained all processes to me and provided answers to any questions. When closing time neared, she made sure that deadlines were being met and things were getting done. Meridith also helped me secure new accommodations. She listened to my needs and found something that exceeded my expectations. She never missed a beat!

almost 4 years ago
Meridith Stalnaker is a dynamite agent that can not be beat!

I had interviewed several top selling agents in the Venice and surrounding area and Meridith outshined them all. Meridith's knowledge regarding real estate prices was superior. She believed I could list my home at a much higher price than any of the previous real estate agents interviewed. She conducted an extensive review of my neighborhood and surrounding areas. She also is very perceptive of her clients and knows who will most likely write an offer over those who do not. I am most impressed with her calm demeanor and knowing instinctively the right words to say at the right time. She was able to sell my home in a very short period of time. I could not be more pleased with Meridith's skills in communication, knowledge of real estate or her exemplary professionalism. You will be very pleased if you hire Meridith as your realtor.

about 4 years ago
I reached out to Meredith over a year ago.

We were looking for a rental in Florida. We had reached out to several brokers. Meredith was the only one that gave us the time off day. She found us a rental and during the year approaching our rental time, she was very responsive in answering any question we had about the rental. While in the rental there have been some issues, but Meredith had been quick to get them addressed. All the while she continued to send us appropriate listing of rentals as well as homes for sale. When she found the villa that we ended up purchasing. Meredith researched all of our questions and took the time to allow us to visit the villa on multiple occasions to help us in gathering info needed to make our transition of this purchase easier. She has been amazing. Always professional and knowledgeable and extremely pleasant and personable. You are very luck to have someone like Meredith. She is truly an asset.

about 4 years ago
Our rental and purchase experience was excellent.

Meredith was knowledgeable, helpful, patient, and professional in both our rental and purchase negotiations. She answered all of our questions, and there were a lot of them, and her knowledge of real estate was a big help to us. She was very accessible and responded to texts and emails in a timely manner. Finally, we would enthusiastically recommend her to anyone who asked.

over 4 years ago
Meridith is extremely attentive and responsive to a seller's needs.

Meridith clearly had a vision of the market value and although we thought we could capitalize on the inflated prices, we actually sold the condo very close to her original POV. She was responsive to my questions, follow up and follow through on this transaction and a previous condo sale.

over 4 years ago
Amazing experience

We sold our home in Bradenton (Heritage Harbour) and had the pleasure to work with Meridith Stalnaker. She made what could have been a stressful and difficult process, as seamless as could be. Meridith really listened, she cares passionately about her job and her calming manner worked wonders for us. She was there every step of the way (literally right there!) From inspection, to showings, to closing and that put us at such ease. You MUST use Meridith Stalnaker from American Realty Of Venice for all of your home buying, selling and renting needs!

over 4 years ago
Outstanding Real Estate Professional

I have been a customer of American Realty since 2007. Excellent company, terrific staff and service. When it became time to sell one of my homes I contacted their agent Meridith Stalnaker about listing my property. In a matter of days she researched the property, suggested a listing price, and gave me a complete and valuable review of market conditions in Venice. We listed the property and in a within days had multiple offers at over asking price. Meridith is not only a delightful person to work with, but a true and experienced professional. Extremely responsive with great market knowledge. I strongly suggest that if your looking for or selling property she is the right person for you to contact.

over 4 years ago
Greate expirianse and amazing services

From: Marko B I am really grateful that I dealt with Meridith. She is very polite, well organized. Meridith A. Stalnaker helped me to find nice tenants and rent out my duplex in Venice, FL. She was taking care of my building for 4 years. Dealing with Meridith, I realized how lucky I am, she solved all of my issues with my building and in the end Meridith helped me to sell my duplex for over expected price in short period of time. She was really good with managing, decorating, staging, and other staff. I really recommend Meridith as Realtor agent to every one. She is the one with who you would enjoy to deal with and she would know how to solve any problems for you. Thank you Meridith It was a pleasure to deal with you and your team Sincerely, Marko B 1 Show original message Delete Move to Forward Reply

almost 5 years ago
Sales person personified

Meredith has shown that she is a person of great sales ability. She always maintained contact with the seller and buyer. Property was in Florida and I was in NY yet we never missed a beat everything was accomplished via the internet and emails. The sales persons proficiency in all aspects of the sale was purely professional. I recommend her for your perusal in real property sale!

about 5 years ago
Very average experience

Meridith is a good agent in many respects but I wouldn't recommend her to my friends. Very hard to get in touch with and does all her communication via text. Sometimes it's best to communicate directly with your client in certain circumstances in a real estate deal.

almost 6 years ago
Meredith is the best!

Meridith was not your typical real estate agent. She went above and beyond to help me and my sister find the perfect condo for us on Venice island. Our experience with Meredith was that she was a very caring and responsive. She made the real estate process a pleasant experience. We told her what we were looking for and she was able to deliver! We had one minor problem with the condo at the end of the process - which was not Meredith’s responsibility - and she quickly fixed the problem. If I had to rate Meredith on a scale of 1 to 10, I would easily give her a 10!

1 - 12 of 12
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent