Melanie's profile

Melanie's reviews

  5  
Melanie has 21 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Melanie's qualities as told by our client reviews: local expert, responsive, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Great experience with the sale of my home
23 days ago
Great experience with the sale of my home

Melanie was a great communicator, keeping me updated about the sale of my home while I was out of state. The marketing was amazing. Beautiful pictures of the house and property. Robyn and Melanie were very professional letting me know everything needed to sell and make good decisions. Thanks to them I received bids over the asking price and was very happy with the sale of my home.

Seller review
Thorough, competent, and inspiring
24 days ago
Thorough, competent, and inspiring

We have worked with Robyn and her mother over the years on the purchase of two houses and the sale of one. After Ava's retirement, Melanie is a great addition to the team. I believe there are no realtors who know Lake Mohawk better than Robyn and Melanie. Their professionalism, thorough analysis of our property, helpful and supportive approach, and availability to ask questions and make suggestions made our latest sale process the best it could have possibly been. They complement each other well. We recommend them highly.

Seller review
I had a wonderful experience with Robin and Melanie.
about 2 months ago
I had a wonderful experience with Robin and Melanie.

As soon as I contacted Robin, she went to work advertising my home on all platforms. The first interested buyer was from Texas. And the actual buyer is from Pennsylvania! The team worked together to give me all the attention I needed.

Seller review
Robyn & Melanie were a great help!
about 2 months ago
Robyn & Melanie were a great help!

They shared what to pack away before staging for photos for the listing. They worked around our schedule. They kept us updated about what potential buyers said about the house after they had showings.

Buyer review
Robyn Clark
4 months ago
Robyn Clark

Robyn was easy to work with. She communicated well. She was professional. We recommend her.

Seller review
Seamless process
4 months ago
Seamless process

Very knowledgeable in the market Made things easy and stress-free

Seller review
Leading us through the process
4 months ago
Leading us through the process

Robyn worked with us to get the best price for our property. We appreciate the time the team invested in getting our property sold.

Buyer review
Excellent experience.
4 months ago
Excellent experience.

We were very pleased with Robin& Melanies performance throughout entire transaction. We were provided with answers to all our questions in a timely manner and would not hesitate using Cutler Realty again. Thanks again.

Buyer review
Melanie helped me find my retirement home!
4 months ago
Melanie helped me find my retirement home!

Melanie is terrific! She is patient, knowledgeable, and worked with me until I found what I was looking for. She went above and beyond all of my expectations.

Seller review
Melanie is the best!
6 months ago
Melanie is the best!

Melanie helped my sister and me with a number of transactions. She is patient, communicates and helps you navigate the process even when it’s quite complicated. I highly recommend Melanie and am very grateful for her professionalism and expertise

Seller review
Excellent!!
9 months ago
Excellent!!

Janet will send detail review and submit details! Thank you all !!

Seller review
Exceptional Experience – Both Buying and Selling
10 months ago
Exceptional Experience – Both Buying and Selling

We had the absolute pleasure of working with Melanie and her team, and we truly couldn’t have asked for a better experience. From start to finish, they were professional, personable, and completely in tune with our needs. They took the time to genuinely understand what we were looking for, which meant every property they showed us was carefully selected—no wasted time on anything that didn’t fit the bill. Their communication was outstanding throughout the entire process. Every detail was handled with precision to ensure we met our deadline without stress. What really set them apart was how they made us feel—we weren’t just another transaction. They treated us like family, always keeping our best interests front and center. We were also fortunate enough to work with Melanie’s team on the selling side, and if possible, that experience was even better. Their dedication, guidance, and personal touch made a typically stressful process feel smooth and confident. We wholeheartedly recommend working with Melanie and her team—you won’t regret it. They’re the real deal.

1 - 12 of 21
© 2026 RateMyAgent