Matthew's profile

Matthew's reviews

  5  
Matthew has 36 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Matthew's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, patient, friendly, responsive, clear communication, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
First-Time Homebuyers Couldn't Have Asked for a Better Realtor!
5 days ago
First-Time Homebuyers Couldn't Have Asked for a Better Realtor!

As first-time homebuyers, we honestly didn’t know what to expect when we started the process, but we couldn’t have asked for a better realtor than Mathew! From the very first time we met him, Mathew was honest, transparent, and upfront about what to expect in the current housing market. He took the time to truly listen to what we were looking for and carefully tailored the homes he showed us to fit our needs and preferences. What really stood out to us was how he consistently went above and beyond. He didn’t just show us houses; he took the time to show us nearby parks, neighborhood amenities, and everything the surrounding communities had to offer so we could make an informed decision about where to raise our family. His communication was excellent throughout the entire process, and he was always responsive, patient, and willing to answer our many questions. When we finally found a home we instantly fell in love with, Mathew continued to be an invaluable resource. From connecting us with lenders to recommending masons, plumbers, movers, and so many other professionals, his support extended far beyond simply helping us purchase a home. We are incredibly grateful for his dedication, professionalism, and genuine commitment to making our first homebuying experience such a positive one. We were so impressed with his service that we have already recommended him to several of our colleagues, and we will continue to do so without hesitation. We truly couldn’t have asked for a better realtor! We are extremely happy with our experience and look forward to working with Mathew again in the future. If you’re looking to buy or sell a home in Northwest Arkansas, Mathew is your guy! We highly recommend him!

Buyer review
Fantastic realtor who made our out-of-state move and home purchase seamless
12 days ago
Fantastic realtor who made our out-of-state move and home purchase seamless

We can't say enough good things about Matthew. We were moving from another state, which could easily have made buying a home stressful and complicated, but Matthew made the whole process seamless from start to finish. From day one, it always felt like he was in our corner. He looked out for our best interests at every step, and we never once felt like just another transaction. He made everything easy, kept things moving, and took the stress out of what could have been an overwhelming experience, especially from a distance. Beyond being great at what he does, Matthew is simply a great person to deal with. He's genuine, easy to talk to, and someone you can trust. If you're looking for a realtor, especially if you're relocating from out of state, we highly recommend Matthew. We're so grateful for his help in finding and purchasing our new home!

Seller review
persistent in a challenging market and good communicator
16 days ago
persistent in a challenging market and good communicator

great market knowledge, supportive throughout the process. was responsive to questions, suggestions and giving recommendations. Worth the wait, Matt sold my home to a wonderful family and found me the perfect home to move to. Was super at communication between sellers and buyers. Always positive and looking at new ways to promote the property. Matt was a pleasure, looking forward to having him over for a cuppa soon.

Seller review
Excellent and very responsive and detailed
24 days ago
Excellent and very responsive and detailed

My experience was as easy as it comes. Matthew provided responses in a timely fashion as well as handling our home with care. I appreciate him being diligent and swift while taking the time to properly price our home to sell and maximize profit.

Buyer review
If ease is important to you
27 days ago
If ease is important to you

Matthew made us feel secure and comfortable during our first home buying experience. While patient and kind, Matthew is great at tackling complex situations and taking any worry or stress out of the equation. Would recommend him time and again!

Seller review
If I could give him 100 stars, I would!
about 1 month ago
If I could give him 100 stars, I would!

100 stars out of 5. Matthew Bastain is amazing at what he does! He took so much stress off of my shoulders during the selling and buying process. He always had an answer or solution for everything and was always quick to respond. He is also a genuinely kind person. I highly highly recommend!!

Buyer review
Matthew is great
about 2 months ago
Matthew is great

Fantastic expertise with Matthew. Would recommend him to anyone.

Buyer review
10/10 experience with Matthew! Would highly recommend
about 2 months ago
10/10 experience with Matthew! Would highly recommend

If you are moving to NWA, we highly recommend working with Matthew. Getting moved from Tulsa was a huge transition for our family, but Matthew’s market knowledge, negotiation skills, and personable approach, made the process significantly easier for us. What we wanted in a house was not easy to find, and Matthew had the utmost patience with us. His responsiveness and level of urgency is unmatched. Cannot say enough positive things about our experience from start to finish!!

Buyer review
A fantastic experience all around!
2 months ago
A fantastic experience all around!

We had an excellent experience working with our realtor. We had just recently moved to Bentonville, AR and didn’t know him beforehand, so we weren’t sure what to expect. From the very beginning, he was fantastic—always quick to respond, extremely knowledgeable, and willing to go the extra mile to help us navigate the process. He made us feel comfortable and confident throughout the entire experience and was always professional, friendly, and approachable. We really appreciated how much time and effort he put into helping us, especially as newcomers to the area. Beyond being a great realtor, he’s just an all-around great guy. We’re so glad we found him and would absolutely recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

Seller review
Best realtor and it's not even close!
2 months ago
Best realtor and it's not even close!

Loved everything about working with Matthew. He was my realtor four years ago when I bought the house and was my realtor again when I just sold my house. He recommended I stage my house and it resulted in me getting $50k more than I had hoped. Matthew answered every call or text immediately. He sent me screen shots of all texts he had with the Buyer's agent so I could exactly what was said rather than a filtered view. Matthew listens. He tells me what he thinks and then if I have a different idea, he doesn't reflexively dismiss it but actually listens. Both when I bought my house and again when I sold it, I can think of examples when I had an idea that he was a little skeptical about, but said he trusted my gut and we should try it. Each time it worked to perfection. Working with Matthew was like having a professional team member on my personal team to guide me every step in the process. I wouldn't even think about buying or selling a home in NWA without first reaching out to Matthew Bastian. He is simply the best. Matthew is knowledgeable, professional, responsive and the hardest working realtor there is. Nobody, and I mean nobody, outworks Matthew. My only regret on this recommendation is being limited to 5 stars for this review. I wish I could give many more. Matty Boy is the best!

Seller review
Helped us get our little fixer upper sold
2 months ago
Helped us get our little fixer upper sold

Matt has great knowledge of the market and helped us get our little starter home sold. He is very helpful and has connections with people that were able to help us get over the finish line with minimal roadblocks on our end. The listing looked amazing and got a lot of traction. We are very thankful for his help in getting our home sold!

Buyer review
Excellent Experience
2 months ago
Excellent Experience

Matthew was outstanding to work with! His laid-back, approachable style made the entire home-buying process comfortable and stress-free. He is extremely knowledgeable about the market and all aspects of the buying process, and I always felt like he had my best interests in mind. He provided sound advice, was responsive when I had questions, and made me feel confident throughout the process. I truly appreciated having someone I could trust in my corner. I highly recommend Matthew to anyone looking to buy a home!

1 - 12 of 36
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent