Mary's profile

Mary's reviews

  3.8  
Mary has 17 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
about 4 years ago
Patient and Helpful, Respectful and Thorough

Mary is a very thoughtful and caring individual who I met through my neighbor as she was responsible for selling their house quickly and at a great value. Mary and I worked closely and diligently to get my house prepared for a high value sell. Mary helped me through the discouragement of having a high offer after 2 days on the market fall through due to interest rate hikes. Timing was terrible after the rate hike increase as showings abated, but Mary was diligent in keeping buyer interest in the house in the market. Great communication together with confidence in Mary's professionalism helped me close on my house even though I was overseas almost the entire time from offer to close. I would highly recommend Mary as your next broker.

over 4 years ago
Mary stood by us in every area of our lives in order to dind the RIGHT home for us!

Thank you Mary, for being so very compassionate, steady and joyful on our journey to find a home in Boulder to purchase. You were always here for us, never ending positivity and listening to our desires and needs as we sifted through the possibilities of homes to purchase to meet our goals and find a space that we could build our nest.

over 4 years ago
A Role Model for How a Real Estate Agent Should Be

I have worked with more than 25 real estate agents in the last 40 years and I'm happy to say that Mary is the first real estate agent that I felt was actually working to make something positive happen for me and my family. Too often agents are driven by so many conflicts of interest that the customer is seldom the agents top priority. Our experience with Mary was completely different. She was there to make sure things went smoothly for us, while strongly representing our interests. Thank you, Mary.

over 4 years ago
"Mary did a wonderful job when helping our family find and purchase a home

"Mary did a wonderful job when helping our family find and purchase a home. She was professional and genuinely concerned that we would find a home that fit our needs. It is easy to get a sense that Mary is a kind, caring person who has her clients interests at heart. We would recommend Mary for any family looking for a home."

over 4 years ago
Above and beyond!

Mary was such a helpful and kind agent to work with. During my 2 month-long search for a home we saw dozens of properties, some of which were an hour+ drive each way, and Mary was always willing to be available. I've never had an agent that worked so hard to help me find the perfect home.

over 4 years ago
"Mary cares about her work and genuinely wish to satisfy you as her customer

"Mary cares about her work and genuinely wish to satisfy you as her customer. We experienced Mary to be a highly qualified broker for Boulder community and market. She knows her market and how to work with people. She is always looking for the best deal that satisfies both seller and buyer. We consider this capacity as a very important skill, if you want to have a smooth transition between selling and buying. We can highly recommend Mary as a broker. Always met with kindness, respect and clear communication."

over 4 years ago
Mary did a phenomenal job finding our dream home

"Mary did a phenomenal job finding our dream home. She took us on several last minute showings and truly has a heart of Gold!! Plus she pretty numbers savvy, which is great for her clients!"

almost 6 years ago
"Mary Hostetter is a marvelous real estate agent

Mary Hostetter is a marvelous real estate agent. Her patience stands out among her many outstanding qualities. We appreciate how much she did for us as we looked at many homes until we found one that was the ideal one. It was a long process but never tedious. We enjoyed sharing so much time with Mary and she has become a friend that we will always remember.

1 - 12 of 17
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent