Lisa McAteer

Lisa McAteer

(PA): RS344103
  •   5   (65 reviews)

About Lisa

Lisa McAteer: Global Award-Winning Leader & Real Estate Market Maker Co-Owner & Team Lead, McAteer & Will Estates | Keller Williams Real Estate Lisa McAteer is a transformational business leader who has redefined the standard of real estate service in Northeastern Pennsylvania. As the Co-Owner and Team Lead of McAteer & Will Estates | Keller Williams Real Estate, she has built one of the most recognized and productive real estate brands in the region, grounded in a philosophy of education-based representation, structural accountability, and profound community investment. Global Recognition & Leadership In 2026, Lisa McAteer was named a TITAN Women in Business Awards Dual Gold Winner, earning the highest global tier of achievement in two prestigious categories: Outstanding Female Executive – Outstanding Market Maker Outstanding Female Executive – Outstanding Transformation Leader These accolades represent a global declaration that Lisa has not merely succeeded within existing frameworks—she has fundamentally reshaped her market. Whether she is executing high-stakes negotiations or architecting the team’s next phase of market dominance, Lisa’s leadership is defined by the same clarity of purpose that has driven her career from day one. A Proven Track Record of Excellence Lisa’s professional reputation is built on hard data and consistent performance. With over $438 million in career real estate sales across more than 1,400 transactions, her results place her among the elite tier of real estate professionals nationwide. National Standing: Recognized by RealTrends 2024 as #1 in her city, #10 in Pennsylvania, and #144 nationally. Top-Tier Production: Individually closed 108.5 sides in 2025, cementing her status as the top-producing agent in Pike County. Elite Designations: Named a 2026 Keller Williams International Luxury Agent, honored with the 2026 Global Recognition Award™ for strategic vision, and recognized as the "Best Real Estate Agent in Milford, PA" by the 2026 Quality Business Awards. Regional Dominance: #1 Team in Units & Volume (KW Greater PA Region, 2025); KW Top 100 (2026); #1 Listings Taken (2025). Education-Based Representation Lisa’s operating principle is simple: Empowerment through education. She transformed the local real estate landscape by replacing the traditional, informal agent model with a sophisticated, data-driven, team-based infrastructure. Whether she is mentoring new agents or leading public workshops on market timing, estate planning, and financial readiness at 402 Broad Street, her goal remains the same: to ensure that the people of Pike, Wayne, and Monroe Counties are the most informed consumers in the market. Civic Commitment & Legacy Leadership, to Lisa, extends well beyond the business transaction. She is deeply invested in the fabric of the community, a commitment that has been recognized at the highest levels of government and local civic organizations: Pennsylvania Senate Commendation: Formally recognized by the Senate of Pennsylvania (sponsored by Senator Elisabeth J. Baker) for her significant contributions to Pike County’s economy and community development. Rising Star Award: Honored by the Pike County Chamber of Commerce. Hometown Hero Award: Recipient of the McAteer & Will Estates "Hometown Hero" designation from the Pike County Chamber. In an industry often driven by volume, Lisa McAteer is driven by impact. She is a visionary who leads from the front, manages with precision, and serves with a commitment to long-term client success that has become the gold standard in the Poconos. Contact Information: Office: 402 Broad Street, Milford, PA 18337 Direct: (570) 832-4425 Web: mwestates.com

Social profiles

Lisa's reviews

  5  
Lisa has 65 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 6.
Review Lisa
Lisa's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, attentive, well-prepared, friendly, fast sale, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Smooth sailing
about 1 month ago
Smooth sailing

For our first home purchase, we could not have had a better experience. Ariana was transparent, beyond helpful, and got back to our questions right away. Even after closing, she made sure things that had to get done were seen through. Lisa made closing fast an easy. She took the time to explain every document prior to signing and still was very efficient in doing so. We are beyond grateful to have had both of them during this process.

Seller review
Quick and Easy Sale
about 1 month ago
Quick and Easy Sale

All team members were professional, attentive, responsive and extremely nice to work with. 5 star rating all around 😊👍🏻😊

Buyer review
A Quick, Easy, Stress-Free Experience!
about 1 month ago
A Quick, Easy, Stress-Free Experience!

Evita was wonderful to work with! We wanted to get our home sold quickly and that’s just what she did- it was listed mid week and we had an accepted offer by the weekend! The closing process was smooth and simple; Evita sent us all documents in a timely manner and helped us through the process. I would recommend her to anyone looking for a smooth selling experience!

Buyer review
Evita Renee Eversdyke professionalism was consistent
2 months ago
Evita Renee Eversdyke professionalism was consistent

Evita Renee Eversdyke professionalism was consistent. She always on time for appointments and provided reliable advice. Their reliability was crucial during the closing stages, ensuring a smooth final transaction.” ”We trusted Evita Renee Eversdyke because of their excellent reputation in the real estate business, and they did not disappoint. Their reliability and expertise ensured a smooth home-buying process, and we’re beyond grateful for their help.” We very Happy with our need Home

Seller review
There are not enough positive or superlative words to describe my agent Hector Quintero and the McAt
3 months ago
There are not enough positive or superlative words to describe my agent Hector Quintero and the McAt

There are not enough positive or superlative words to describe my agent Hector Quintero and the McAteer & Will Estates/Keller Williams Real Estate agency. Hector had the most positive attitude, was very responsible, supportive, and resourceful. Not only did he have the best real estate skills, but also the personal skills necessary to develop an effective and confident agent/client relationship. The process of selling my home was both emotional and practical. Hector understood both. He was empathetic regarding the meaning my home had for me, and why it was necessary to sell now. He assisted me in preparing the home for market as there were necessary issues to address. As this was not my primary home and I lived out-of-state, Hector facilitated getting the appropriate qualified resources to address the issues. He always went above and beyond in getting and managing the contractors who worked with me. He was always in communication with and accessible to me. Hector was on top of it all! He was never performative but always made me feel he was truly in the process with me. He kept me abreast of everything, considered my opinions, and gave his recommendations when asked. Simply stated, Hector is the best! Hector was an A-1 agent and, as we got closer to the sale of the home, the agency staff that I worked with were very professional, respectful and friendly too. They were prompt in responding to my questions and assisted with my needs, e.g., IT issues, completion of forms, etc. In summary, Hector and the agency staff are highly knowledgeable, responsible, respectful, accommodating and caring professionals. Hector used these qualities and his skills to achieve the very best outcome regarding the preparation and sale of my home. Hector Quintero is certainly an asset to McAteer & Will Estates/Keller Williams Real Estate agency. Hector and the team receive my highest recommendation.

Show all 65 reviews
map

Lisa's properties

Lisa has 87 properties for sale and sold 162 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$375,000
182 Southwynd Dr
Gold Key Lake PA 18337
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams RE 402 Broad
For Sale
$449,000
46 Fairview Avenue
Mount Pocono PA 18344
4
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams RE 402 Broad
Pending
$399,900
438 Cummins Hill Road
Milford PA 18337
3
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams RE 402 Broad
SoldJun 17, 2026
$812,585
125 Senate Road
Milford PA 18337
4
5
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams RE 402 Broad
Show all 249 properties

Lisa's sold properties

Lisa has sold 162 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
125 Senate Road, Milford, PA, 18337
125 Senate Road
Milford PA 18337
4
5
3
Single-Family$812,585Jun 17, 2026
391 Butternut Road, Newfoundland, PA, 18445
391 Butternut Road
Newfoundland PA 18445
3
2
Single-Family$96,000Jun 15, 2026
355 Bear Creek Lake Drive, Jim Thorpe, PA, 18229
355 Bear Creek Lake Drive
Jim Thorpe PA 18229
3
1
1
Single-Family$750,000Jun 12, 2026
157 Mountain Lake Drive, Dingmans Ferry, PA, 18328
157 Mountain Lake Drive
Dingmans Ferry PA 18328
3
2
Single-Family$550,000Jun 8, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent