Kelly's profile

Kelly's reviews

  5  
Kelly has 39 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Kelly's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, reliable, supportive, attentive, friendly, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Above and Beyond
about 2 years ago
Above and Beyond

Highly recommend Kelly. My husband and I had no clue what we were doing as this was our first home. Kelly was professional, kind and trustworthy. She taught us the in’s and out’s of buying a home. Kelly was always quick to respond with our million questions. She listened to what we were looking for and knew exactly where to find it. She went above and beyond our expectations and provided us with the perfect home. On a professional note, Kelly was on time, personable, well educated in her field. Kelly can get you anything you need to make your experience great. Highly recommend.

Seller review
Kelly was Spot On
about 2 years ago
Kelly was Spot On

Kelly was great from minute one. She knew market values, helped us with all of the details to get our house on the market at a good time, she helped coordinate all of the big and little things to get things ready to show the house, suggested to have a realtor open house then walked through schedules for the open houses for the public, was great at communicating with us, was a fantastic listener and was there at closing to make sure all went well.

Buyer review
Kelly is the best! She truly cares about finding you the perfect home.
over 2 years ago
Kelly is the best! She truly cares about finding you the perfect home.

I honestly cannot say enough good things about Kelly. Buying a home is a wonderful yet challenging experience and Kelly was instrumental in guiding us through the process of finding our beautiful new home. We were looking for a multi-generational home which meant we had to find something that worked for both me and my parents, and we all have different priorities and opinions about our needs and wants. We also had the added complexity of my parents being out of state. Luckily for us, Kelly took the time to help us move from 'all over the place' to a solid list of criteria to find a place that works wonderfully for all of us. She knows the area and the market so well and was so quick to answer all of our many questions that came up during the process. She even looked at potential properties for us when we were unable to, and sent us tons of pictures and videos so we didn't miss out on any opportunities. I 100% recommend Kelly to anyone looking for a super knowledgeable, caring realtor to help them find the perfect home!

Buyer review
See our review below.
over 2 years ago
See our review below.

Kelly did a great job and helped us find a home. She is easy to work with, answered all our questions, had good resource suggestions when we needed outside help. We never felt rushed or pressured. She’s good at what she does. Yes, we would use her again and highly recommend her.

Buyer review
Wonderful!
over 2 years ago
Wonderful!

Kelly was extremely communicative, polite, and helpful! We really enjoyed working with her and look forward to having her as a neighbor.

Seller review
Very professional, competent, and produced above expectations
over 2 years ago
Very professional, competent, and produced above expectations

March 4, 2024, our home sold!!!! This was all do to Kelly Nehls! Her, positive, competent, effective, kind and sweet manner is the perfect mix of skills that Kelly gives you as you sell your home. I have never seen so much activity procured by her in one day! Not only that but Kelly calls or emails or texts you for an update almost every day! Our home had not sold for 5 months! So in December, 2023, we changed our relator to Kelly Nehls of ReMax & things started happening! She got it staged, changed some lights, & made it look absolutely beautiful!!! Within 3 weeks, someone fell in love with it & by January 1, 2024 we had a contract. We are simply so grateful that Kelly Nehls was there for us! My husband & I believe that if anyone can sell a property, it would be Kelly, you would be in the best of hands.

Buyer review
Kelly is a great agent!
over 2 years ago
Kelly is a great agent!

Kelly helped us find our home in Johnstown after looking in other communities in NoCo. She was very helpful and timely and very organized. Even after we walked away from a home after the inspection revealed a host of problems, she was still encouraging. We were relocating from Southern Colorado and she made great use of our time. She was happy to work with our chosen lender and when we were able to close early, she was available the day after Christmas to make it happen. Her knowledge of the area was great. We valued the fact that she helped us make good decisions for us…not for her. That is a mark of a great agent!

Seller review
Kelly is the best of the best
over 2 years ago
Kelly is the best of the best

Kelly is an expert in her field. She knows what she's doing, articulates well and is awesome at negotiating. I could not have asked for a better agent, friend and teammate to get this deal worked out. I'm glad to have had Kelly in my corner, her expertise is priceless. Hire her, you'll be glad you did.

Seller review
Fantastic Agent!
almost 3 years ago
Fantastic Agent!

Kelly recently helped me sell my house that I didn't love, so I could buy the house I wanted, we had a tight turnaround and she worked hard to make it happen. From the beginning when I was making renovations to improve my selling price, to helping me find contractors in my new home, Kelly has been there for me. Kelly is very friendly and easy to work with, she is professional and punctual. She has a lot of experience in Northern Colorado and is a great human.

Seller review
Prompt/Patient
almost 3 years ago
Prompt/Patient

Kelly is knowledgeable about the inter-working of selling your home. She was excellent in communicating with us about the next steps thru-out the process. Always available for any questions with a quick response. Thanks Kelly! You are Awesome!!

Buyer review
Exceptional realtor experience, highly recommended! Kelly made everything stress-free.
about 3 years ago
Exceptional realtor experience, highly recommended! Kelly made everything stress-free.

I had an outstanding experience working with Kelly Nehls as my realtor. From the moment I reached out to her, she was incredibly welcoming and made me feel at ease throughout the entire process. Her communication skills were top-notch, and she always kept me informed about every step of the home-buying journey. Kelly's straightforward approach was refreshing and helped me navigate the sometimes overwhelming world of real estate with confidence. She patiently answered all my questions, no matter how big or small, and never made me feel rushed or pressured. Her extensive knowledge of the local market and real estate industry was evident, and she provided valuable insights that helped me make informed decisions. I truly appreciated Kelly's reliability and dedication to finding my home. She was always available when I needed her, and her responsiveness was impressive. I felt like a priority to her, and that made a significant difference in my home-buying experience. In summary, working with Kelly was an absolute pleasure. Her professionalism, expertise, and friendly demeanor made the entire process enjoyable and stress-free. I couldn't have asked for a better realtor, and I highly recommend her to anyone looking for a trustworthy and reliable partner in their real estate journey. Thank you, Kelly, for helping me find my home!

Seller review
Easy Transaction
about 3 years ago
Easy Transaction

Kelly accurately predicted next steps and potential risks and had easy to understand weekly summaries to know where in the process things stood. I always felt informed and comfortable with the upcoming steps.

25 - 36 of 39
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent