Kelly's profile

Kelly's reviews

  5  
Kelly has 42 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Kelly's qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, responsive, supportive, attentive, friendly, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Recommend Completely
5 days ago
Recommend Completely

Kelly Nehls Coonrod handled much of the day-to-day support of our home sale—with prompt responses, support and expertise. Her professional and positive attitude made working with her a pleasure, and her analytic skills a very real asset. She has been central and effective in dealing with various parties during and following our home sale. We could (and did) rely on her in dealing with every aspect of our home sale and recommend her completely.

Buyer review
Confident and kind professional
about 1 month ago
Confident and kind professional

Kelly helped us turn our dream into reality! Her professional polish, confident kindness, and caring support took care of us every step along the way! We are so incredibly thankful for her! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

Seller review
Kelly was patient, professional and kept us informed about everything
about 2 months ago
Kelly was patient, professional and kept us informed about everything

Kelly and Laura were informed of the market and what is going on. When I was worried about so many lookers and no offers Kelly assured us that we were getting enough activity that it would sell soon. They each did an open house for us. They kept us informed of everything throughout the process. We would recommend them and would use them again!

Seller review
Great selling experience
about 2 months ago
Great selling experience

Communication was great, with frequent updates about everything along the way, including showings, offers, inspections, etc. Market knowledge was fantastic, resulting in a well-priced listing that went under contract in just over 1 week. Strong negotiation, keeping the buyers focused only on large issues, making for a quick and easy closing.

Buyer review
Exceptional service.  A new friend!
3 months ago
Exceptional service. A new friend!

Kelly is exceptional! She listens, she stays on top of all the things that come up or the unexpected. We were so grateful she represented us! She is warm, friendly but the consummate professional at making all things work in their proper order. Ours was a difficult cross country move. She was way more than the buyers agent, she “Mommied” us through all the challenges, changes, inspections right to the closing table. Forever grateful. A prime asset to the business!

Buyer review
This team leads with wisdom and experience
4 months ago
This team leads with wisdom and experience

Kelly and her team were a joy to work with! Professional, proactive and very experienced in the market. We were brand new to the condo game and they made the whole experience fun and easy. I highly recommend Kelly and her team for any of your real estate needs.

Seller review
Hard worker that knows her business
5 months ago
Hard worker that knows her business

Kelly was very knowledgeable and attentive. A joy to work with. She was spot on with her evaluation of our home, marketed it very well, and guided us through the whole process professionally.

Buyer review
Friendly Professional with Extensive Local Experience
6 months ago
Friendly Professional with Extensive Local Experience

We were first introduced to Kelly when relocating to Fort Collins for work. She went above and beyond to quickly find us the right rental. We had such a good experience in finding a rental, we reached back out to her for exploring the home-buying process. Kelly is everything that you need and want in a realtor. She is the perfect balance of professional and personal connection. Her experience in the industry shines as she connects you with a network of exceptional local experts. Kelly is your number one advocate and helps guide you through the home buying process with wisdom, patience, and ease. We are super grateful to have worked with Kelly in finding our perfect home!

Buyer review
Best Experience
6 months ago
Best Experience

Kelly did such a great job from the day I first called her to the day I signed. She was always there for any questions, always in a great mood and I felt that she went above and beyond. She made this experience so exciting and fun, truly what I imagined buying my first home would feel like. She negotiated in my favor and made sure everything taken care of. I couldn’t have asked for someone better to help me buy my first home, thank you thank you thank you!!!

Buyer review
Loved Kelly!
7 months ago
Loved Kelly!

Kelly is knowledgeable, responsive, caring, helpful in getting answers, and listens.

1 - 12 of 42
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent