Kelly's profile

Kelly's reviews

  5  
Kelly has 36 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Kelly's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, responsive, supportive, reliable, friendly, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
This team leads with wisdom and experience
29 days ago
This team leads with wisdom and experience

Kelly and her team were a joy to work with! Professional, proactive and very experienced in the market. We were brand new to the condo game and they made the whole experience fun and easy. I highly recommend Kelly and her team for any of your real estate needs.

Seller review
Hard worker that knows her business
2 months ago
Hard worker that knows her business

Kelly was very knowledgeable and attentive. A joy to work with. She was spot on with her evaluation of our home, marketed it very well, and guided us through the whole process professionally.

Buyer review
Friendly Professional with Extensive Local Experience
3 months ago
Friendly Professional with Extensive Local Experience

We were first introduced to Kelly when relocating to Fort Collins for work. She went above and beyond to quickly find us the right rental. We had such a good experience in finding a rental, we reached back out to her for exploring the home-buying process. Kelly is everything that you need and want in a realtor. She is the perfect balance of professional and personal connection. Her experience in the industry shines as she connects you with a network of exceptional local experts. Kelly is your number one advocate and helps guide you through the home buying process with wisdom, patience, and ease. We are super grateful to have worked with Kelly in finding our perfect home!

Buyer review
Best Experience
3 months ago
Best Experience

Kelly did such a great job from the day I first called her to the day I signed. She was always there for any questions, always in a great mood and I felt that she went above and beyond. She made this experience so exciting and fun, truly what I imagined buying my first home would feel like. She negotiated in my favor and made sure everything taken care of. I couldn’t have asked for someone better to help me buy my first home, thank you thank you thank you!!!

Buyer review
Loved Kelly!
4 months ago
Loved Kelly!

Kelly is knowledgeable, responsive, caring, helpful in getting answers, and listens.

Seller review
The realtor was good in Understanding the seller’s  psychology of the sale.
4 months ago
The realtor was good in Understanding the seller’s psychology of the sale.

Our realtor had a good understanding of the local markets. She was a quick to accept any new ideas or refreshments. And also give her views about. anything to make it work better. If I had any ideas or complications, she was quick to address it. In short, I wish all realtors were like her more.

Seller review
Kelly is the best!
7 months ago
Kelly is the best!

If you’re looking for a realtor who is trustworthy, hardworking, and truly has your best interests at heart, I cannot recommend Kelly highly enough. This was an outstanding experience, and I would absolutely work with her again and refer her to anyone buying or selling a home.

Seller review
Couldn’t have found a better realtor!
8 months ago
Couldn’t have found a better realtor!

Kelly was not only knowledgeable, and professional, but she was very personable. Made you feel like you existed and weren’t just another paycheck. She’s helpful in many ways that have nothing to do with the sale of the house. She also kept me informed and kept close contact with me, even after I left the state of Colorado to go home to Georgia. I have appreciated her so much on many levels, I consider her a good friend. She was there at every turn when I had questions, and always had answers. I don’t live in Fort Collins, but if I did and ever needed a realtor again she would be my go to person. Once again, thanks for all your help Kelly, I am so thankful I had you on my side 🥰🥰

Seller review
Outstanding Agent!
9 months ago
Outstanding Agent!

Kelly is and excellent agent. She is knowledgeable, and very organized. What I appreciate most is her honesty. She's direct and doesn't sugar coat information. Her willingness to be direct and honest allowed us to make timely, correct decisions. Thanks Kelly!

Buyer review
Highly recommend Kelly Nehls
10 months ago
Highly recommend Kelly Nehls

Kelly Nehls is on top of every phase of the real estate process. If we had a question, she had the answer. If we had a problem, she took care of it. We highly recommend her.

Buyer review
Kelly Nehls The Best Real Estate Agent in Fort Collins
about 1 year ago
Kelly Nehls The Best Real Estate Agent in Fort Collins

It was such a pleasure working with you. We told you what we wanted and you listened and followed through. You showed us many homes and always gave us as much information as possible. You gave us your honest opinion about the home and were fantastic about negotiating our offer. You have excellent knowledge about the market and were always available to answer our questions. We can't thank you enough for all your help.

1 - 12 of 36
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent