Kelly's profile

Kelly's reviews

  5  
Kelly has 43 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Kelly's qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, stress-free process, reliable, responsive, detail-oriented, supportive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Great Experience Selling my Condo!
about 4 years ago
Great Experience Selling my Condo!

I reached out to Kelly about selling my condo in Medford as I was moving out of state. Kelly made everything very easy, which I appreciated as I had already bought another house and was in the process of moving. Kelly gave me great insights into the market, and what I needed to do to get the best possible price. She handled everything from putting me in touch with painters and connecting me with a lawyer, to staging, photography, open houses and negotiations. Within a few days of being on the market, I had several offers way over the asking price. Kelly and her team did a great job and made the whole process effortless. I would highly recommend Kelly and her team for anyone considering buying or selling real estate in the area.

Seller review
Highly recommended!!
over 4 years ago
Highly recommended!!

I have known and worked with Kelly for over 10 years as she rented out my property. When it came time to sell she did not disappoint. Her professionalism and knowledge of Medford had my house sold within days. She goes above and beyond for her clients!

Seller review
Amazing experience selling with Kelly Twice!!
over 4 years ago
Amazing experience selling with Kelly Twice!!

Kelly has such wonderful knowledge in her field, she makes the processing of selling your home as simple and hassle free for you as possible. I sold my first home with Kelly a little over a year ago and had such a wonderful experience that I wanted to work with her again to sell my second one. The staging she provides really puts everything in your home together and makes it feel ready for any buyer. I highly recommend her as she is just so great at her profession and overall very willing to help.

Seller review
Excellent service
over 4 years ago
Excellent service

The agency is extremely knowledgeable about real estate. The team worked very close with us during the sale process for a successful sale. Thank you.

Seller review
Very focused and very honest right from the beginning.
over 4 years ago
Very focused and very honest right from the beginning.

Kelly handle all aspects of the process from the very beginning, Communications with timely all questions were answered effectively and quickly and most important when offers were made they were submitted it to us immediately and with relative information about each buyer . I would highly recommend Kelly services to anybody looking for somebody in the Boston area that is focused competent and professional.

Seller review
  I have owned a few income properties but have limited experience in the real estate sales area
almost 7 years ago
I have owned a few income properties but have limited experience in the real estate sales area

I have owned a few income properties but have limited experience in the real estate sales area. Kelly is assertive and took charge of the complete process, She had an excellent plan and executed it flawlessly. She worked closely with my attorney as well as the buyers agent and attorney to insure a smooth process. Kelly was accessible and always kept me informed as to what was going on during the negotiation and sale process. She is very professional and knowledgeable of the real estate business. I highly recommend her as your agent!!

Seller review
~Kelly Catallo~ Trust this realtor, to execute and deliver!

Not a big 'reviews' guy but wanted to s
over 8 years ago
~Kelly Catallo~ Trust this realtor, to execute and deliver! Not a big 'reviews' guy but wanted to s

~Kelly Catallo~ Trust this realtor, to execute and deliver! Not a big 'reviews' guy but wanted to share a very positive recent experience. Kelly was the third realtor I interviewed for a quick sale of a small Medford property in disrepair. At first, skeptical of her proposal as she insisted on listing the property $100K over the other two realtors asking prices, her expertise was validated when we closed within sixty days with $70K over what was first expected. Kelly had insight of a new market uptick in Medford that the other realtors are just figuring out now. I really liked her proactive, real world/contemporary approach. Using state of the art analytic tools with algorithms to discover this market trend, she networked with local developers and investors through social media and on-line means for superior visibility for opportunities. Assisted by her researching & background checks, we weeded out the low ball offers from the wannabe buyers (which there were many) and focused on the real solid offers from reputable developers . Another great feature of this whole transaction was the ease of execution; The bid negotiation, P&S and closing documents, were all signed through an on-line portal making the process so easy,, I really only met face to face with Kelly twice. I went into this selling process expecting months of hassles, fearing the worst,, but was pleasantly surprised at the automation and contemporary approach of Cosmopolitan Real Estate's process. ~Easy Peasy~

Buyer review
My wife and I and very happy with service and support we received from Kelly Catallo and her associa
about 9 years ago
My wife and I and very happy with service and support we received from Kelly Catallo and her associa

My wife and I and very happy with service and support we received from Kelly Catallo and her associates. As first-time homebuyers in a very aggressive market, what could have been a daunting road to finding our home was rendered effortless through supportive consultation and constant, rapid communication. We are very happy with the home that we found, it took virtually no time to find it due in no small part to the diligence of Kelly's team. While we certainly don't foresee moving anytime soon, if we did, we wouldn't hesitate to rely on Kelly and her team again. Thanks!

25 - 36 of 43
© 2026 RateMyAgent