Kelly's profile

Kelly's reviews

  5  
Kelly has 42 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Kelly's qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, stress-free process, reliable, responsive, detail-oriented, supportive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Kelly is excellent and knowledgeable on real estate and communication skills is five stars .
1 day ago
Kelly is excellent and knowledgeable on real estate and communication skills is five stars .

Kelly has been in this business since 1992, when I bought my place since then I always reach out to her for RE rentals for past 6 years and with her experience and knowledge have make things move spontaneously and comfortable to evaluate and rent. She is priority on my list for any purchase, Sales and renting of residential property Etc.

Buyer review
A Trusted Partner for Every Step of Our Real Estate Journey
4 months ago
A Trusted Partner for Every Step of Our Real Estate Journey

We truly can’t recommend Kelly highly enough. Our relationship with Kelly goes back five or six years, starting with her helping us find our first rental apartment in Medford. From day one, she stood out for how well she listened, how knowledgeable she was, and how easy she made the whole process feel. Since then, Kelly has been part of some major milestones for us. She helped us become homeowners in the North Shore area, and what impressed us most was how deeply she understood what we were looking for - not just a house, but a place that would truly feel like home. Her market insight, strong network, and thoughtful guidance made a huge difference, especially in competitive situations. Most recently, she supported us in purchasing an investment condo in Lynn, MA. Once again, her strategy, responsiveness, and confidence at the negotiation table were invaluable. Having Kelly represent us always feels like a real advantage, she’s sharp, well-prepared, and always looking out for our best interests. Overall, Kelly’s style, market knowledge, and presence make her a true pleasure to work with. She brings a rare mix of professionalism and warmth, and we feel incredibly lucky to have had her by our side through so many important decisions. If you’re looking for someone you can truly trust in real estate, Kelly is it.

Seller review
Above and Beyond
5 months ago
Above and Beyond

After a long and sometimes challenging real estate journey, I cannot say enough positive things about Kelly Catallo from Cosmopolitan Realty. From start to finish, Kelly was dedicated, professional, and worked extremely hard to ensure the transaction was completed within the required timeframe. She went above and beyond, working closely with the state and attorneys to keep the process moving forward and to resolve every obstacle that arose. Her persistence, attention to detail, and commitment truly made the difference in successfully closing this deal. I am incredibly grateful to Kelly and her entire team for their outstanding effort and support. Their expertise and dedication made what could have been a stressful experience a smooth and successful one. I highly recommend Kelly Catallo and Cosmopolitan Realty to anyone looking for a reliable and hardworking real estate professional.

Seller review
The best of the best
8 months ago
The best of the best

Even though it was a difficult situation, Kelly and her team came through with flying colors! Kelly’s skill and professionalism enabled her to find just the right tenants even though there was much adversity. Did I mention that I am a repeat client? Thanks again for another great experience, Kelly!

Seller review
Market Knowledge
over 1 year ago
Market Knowledge

Kelly, was outstanding to work with!!! Kelly was able to manage the sale of the property in addition to dealing family personalities and different family opinions through the process. If you want the best sale price for your house you should hire Kelly. If you want a realtor available 24/7 to answer your questions Kelly is the one to hire. Kelly was extremely professional, and diligent durning the process.

Buyer review
Kelly is responsive, professional, and knowledgeable
over 1 year ago
Kelly is responsive, professional, and knowledgeable

Kelly guided us super swiftly and expertly through the home buying process. She is lightning quick to respond to an email or text and has so much industry knowledge.

Seller review
Kelly and her team Did it ALL!
over 1 year ago
Kelly and her team Did it ALL!

Kelly came highly recommended by one of my long-term friends, a realtor in San Francisco. Kelly exceeded our expectations by jumping right in and getting our property on the market and sold in one month. From the initial meeting to closing, Kelly and her team where professionals who got it done. Kelly connected us with all the services we needed to get our property ready for showing and completed the sale in without a glitch, from listing advise, staging, negotiations . They did it all while we were out of town throughout the entire process. Excellent job!

Seller review
Kelly Catallo was truly exceptional!
over 1 year ago
Kelly Catallo was truly exceptional!

There are many great things I could highlight about Kelly, such as her professionalism, knowledge, understanding the market and the most phenomenal staging in a home I have ever seen"! But what truly mattered to me was her kindness and compassion in helping me sell my sons home. She supported me through a few bumps that were unexpected, she communicated with me often and found resources for me for whatever I needed. She is truly exceptional!!

Seller review
Great experience!
over 1 year ago
Great experience!

Kelly is a wonderful realtor. She made our experience so easy and stress free. She was always there to answer a question, offer advice and gave suggestions to make this this whole process go smoothly. She was thoughtful and kind, and we would highly recommend her to anyone!! Thank you Kelly.

Seller review
Kelly was extremely knowledgeable and committed to her clients
over 1 year ago
Kelly was extremely knowledgeable and committed to her clients

We recently had Kelly help us sell our families home after my dad’s passing. Not only was she supportive, knowing this was a hard decision but made the process so much easier. Her personal skills and professionalism were impeccable and she was always available to answer any questions we had. She made sure to give us updates weekly on the progress. Would I recommend Kelly.

Buyer review
Strategic, Savvy and Smart
over 1 year ago
Strategic, Savvy and Smart

Kelly is extremely knowledgeable, hands on, not afraid to push the envelope and is results oriented. She knows her business in and out and provides exceptional support and resources from P & S to closing. I highly recommend Kelly and would without a doubt utilize her again if the need arose and refer her to others.

1 - 12 of 42
© 2026 RateMyAgent