Katie Crotty

Katie Crotty

  •   5   (11 reviews)

About Katie

Katie Crotty specializes in residential real estate in the New Tampa area. With many years of experience working with the best in the business there is no challenge you can't face with a connected professional by your side! Before becoming licensed, Katie worked as an investor & property manager assisting over 400 homes & specializing in contracts and sales. At home, Katie has three dogs, a Dalmatian, a Pitbull, and a Boxer to help keep her on her toes! As a previous Division 1 athlete, Katie is very competitive, which you will see in negotiations. Specializing in luxury listings, Katie stays ahead of the curve with modern techniques and a strong social media base. Just google “Katie Crotty LLC” to see some of the recent things she has been working on and get to know her a little better! Please check out Katie’s previous success, and how much her clients have enjoyed working with her, on Rate My Agent. You won’t find a more dedicated or communicative agent in the New Tampa area! With strong sense of community, you will often find Katie involved in school sponsorships, donation initiatives, and she pledges a portion of commissions to a charity of her client's choice. Give Katie a call today to be instantly connected to a network of tried-and-true professionals all working hard in your corner.

Katie's reviews

  5  
Katie has 11 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 6.
Review Katie
about 2 months ago
Polished professionalism, enthusiastic energy, and unwavering commitment to her clients

We chose Katie Crotty to assist with selling our home, and we couldn’t be happier with the experience. She has a keen eye for real estate and offers direct, thoughtful feedback delivered in a positive and gentle way. Katie also has a warm presence, a beautiful smile, and a pleasant, calm voice that immediately puts you at ease. Katie truly listens to your needs and concerns, and she is always available by phone or text. She prepared our listing with beautiful photos that captured everything we loved about our home and wrote an enticing description that showcased it perfectly, highlighting its very best features. She held several open houses, walked the neighborhood with flyers to personally invite people, and used social media to reach an even wider audience, her dedication was truly impressive. Throughout the process, she calmly guided us through each step; from navigating potential buyers to helping us understand all the paperwork once we received an offer. We highly recommend Katie to anyone looking to sell or buy their home. She is knowledgeable, supportive, and genuinely passionate about what she does! You will be genuinely thrilled with your decision to hire Katie.

9 months ago
Katie is an excellent realtor!

In the recent marketing and sale of my home, she deftly navigated the complex housing market, providing experienced guidance on pricing strategy. Katie was consistently accessible, friendly, and professional. Katie is a very hard worker. She met unexpected challenges with our buyers with poise and persistence. Katie was a clear and firm negotiator when needed. She worked hard to bring solutions to the table, ultimately paving the way for the sale finalize. Thank you, Katie! You have been an invaluable partner to me, as I know you are to all of your clients!

about 1 year ago
Stays on top of things and works for you

Katie was a professional agent again! Easy to work with and gets results for her clients. Stays connected and for any first time buyer she will be at your side helping and giving her expertise until closing. She cares about you and her commitment to help you achieve selling or buying real estate with honesty and integrity.

over 2 years ago
Katie Excels in Service!

I can't recommend Katie enough! Her exceptional communication and reliability were important during our challenging situation with my husband overseas. She not only clarified real estate complexities but also personally invested effort in prepping our house for market success, going the extra mile to tidy up the yard for the perfect photo op. Katie's dedication and support made the process smooth, and I confidently endorse her services. Katie truly embodies a heartfelt commitment to her clients, consistently going above and beyond to ensure their satisfaction and success in the real estate journey. Highly commendable! Thank you, Katie.

over 2 years ago
On the ball, fantastic

Katie is very creative, knowledgeable and professional when it comes to real estate. She gets the job done and keeps you informed along the way to closing!

almost 3 years ago
This realtor is REAL!!!

Katie first of all was very patient. She was the first realtor we met when we visited Florida in February. We told her we probably would not be buying until later in the summer. During those months, she continually sent us properties to view. Along with that, she called us several times just to check in and see if we needed anything. Whenever we had a question, she would always respond promptly. When she showed us properties, she always made sure we saw the property for what it was, good and bad. She was very helpful in writing and executing the contract. In our final walk through, she made sure, everything was in working order. Her knowledge, energy, and persistence, was always at the highest level. Some realtors have only one goal and that is to sell! Katie's goal is to sell her clients the house that is right for them and will do what it takes to accomplish that! Katie made our long distance move enjoyable and helped cut down our stress level. We are very appreciative for all she did for us!

Show all 11 reviews

Katie's properties

Katie has 1 property for sale and sold 3 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMar 12, 2026
$337,000
34448 Cedarfield Drive
Ridge Manor FL 33523
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of BHHS FLORIDA PROPERTIES GROUP and AGILE GROUP REALTY
For Sale
$309,000
33018 Frosted Clover Way
Wesley Chapel FL 33545
3
3
1
Townhouse
Listing courtesy of BHHS FLORIDA PROPERTIES GROUP
SoldAug 7, 2025
$310,000
33030 Major Oak Drive
Wesley Chapel FL 33545
3
3
1
Townhouse
Listing courtesy of BHHS FLORIDA PROPERTIES GROUP and EXIT KING REALTY
SoldAug 7, 2025
$310,000
33030 Major Oak Drive
Wesley Chapel FL 33545
3
2
1
Townhouse
Listing courtesy of BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICE
Show all 4 properties
Email
© 2026 RateMyAgent