Katelyn Montrony

Katelyn Montrony

Licensed Real Estate Agent
  •   5   (19 reviews)

Katelyn's sales performance at a glance

See how Katelyn has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

3
Reviews
8
Properties for sale
15
Sold properties
$722k
Average sale price
$10.1m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

About Katelyn

Meet Katelyn Montrony, a licensed real estate agent with a remarkable track record in the bustling New York real estate market. With a deep understanding of the local areas like Medford, Selden, and Sayville, Katelyn consistently delivers outstanding results. Over the past 12 months, she has expertly managed both the buying and selling processes, leading to impressive achievements. Katelyn has successfully sold 25 properties, predominantly focusing on Single Family homes, demonstrating her ability to cater to families looking for their dream home. Her sales strategy ensures minimal market time, with properties averaging just 18 days. This efficiency showcases her dedication to both clients and industry standards. With three active properties currently on the market, Katelyn offers a range of options to potential buyers, backed by her extensive market knowledge. Her average sale price stands at over $625,000, contributing to an overall sales volume of approximately $15.6 million. Katelyn’s success is reflected in her stellar 5-star rating from satisfied clients, highlighting her commitment to providing exceptional service and personalized attention. Trust Katelyn Montrony to guide you through your real estate journey with confidence and expertise in New York's vibrant market.

Languages spoken

English

Social profiles

Katelyn's reviews

  5  
Katelyn has 19 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 6.
Review Katelyn
Buyer review
An incredible advocate who helped us win in a crazy market!
2 months ago
An incredible advocate who helped us win in a crazy market!

Kate was an absolute pleasure to work with throughout our home buying journey. In a market where bidding wars are happening like crazy, we were amazed that she helped us successfully secure the very first house we put in offer in for. We truly appreciated her deep market knowledge, expert negotiation skills and constant responsiveness whenever we had questions. She navigated the entire process with professionalism and made us feel supported from start to finish. We are so happy in our new home and highly recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor who genuinely cares about her clients' success.

Seller review
Very knowledgeable and excellent communicator.
3 months ago
Very knowledgeable and excellent communicator.

Katelyn was always available to answer our questions or concerns. She guided us through a very stressful and emotional time. Her marketing strategies were amazing. All her hard work and knowledge was the reason the sale of our house was such a success. I would recommend Katelyn to anyone who needs to sell or buy a home.

Seller review
It was great working with Katie
9 months ago
It was great working with Katie

Katie was amazing throughout the entire process of selling our house. It sold quickly. She explained everything along the way and was always available when I called or texted her. I will definitely use her again.

Buyer review
A Five-Star Agent with a Fantastic Team
over 1 year ago
A Five-Star Agent with a Fantastic Team

Working with Katie as our real estate agent was one of the best decisions we made during our homebuying journey. She was incredibly organized, always responsive, and made us feel supported every step of the way. As first-time buyers, we had a lot of questions, and Kate was always just a quick text or call away with helpful answers and reassurance. She also had excellent recommendations for her extended team, from bank attorney and mortgage lenders to inspectors, which made the process so much smoother and more efficient. When we hit some bumps with seller repairs, Kate went above and beyond to keep things moving and advocate for us through a difficult close. We truly felt like she had our best interest at heart the entire time, and we couldn’t be more thankful. Thanks to her hard work and dedication, we’re now settling into our first home! We highly recommend Katie to anyone looking for a trustworthy and compassionate real estate agent.

Seller review
Consummate Professional
over 1 year ago
Consummate Professional

Katie was an amazing performer throughout a difficult time for our family. Her eagerness to understand what we needed and wanted, while being detail oriented to help get the best result for all involved. Her follow up was second to none and she went the extra mile to ensure we crossed the finish line. I cannot speak highly enough for how grateful my sisters and I are, to be able to work with Katie throughout this process. If you are looking for someone who is professional, detail oriented, thoughtful and very likable, then Katie is correct choice for you!

Buyer review
Excellent
over 1 year ago
Excellent

Very knowledgeable and helpful, always available to answer my questions and when she didn’t know something she made it her business to find out for me. Great to work with!!

Show all 19 reviews
map

Katelyn's properties

Katelyn has 8 properties for sale and sold 15 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldJul 31, 2026
$739,000
33 Fischer Avenue
Islip Terrace NY 11752
4
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Hedgestone Homes LLC
For Sale
$499,000
302 Bentley Court West
St. James NY 11780
2
2
1
Condo
Pending
$929,999
9 Florgate Road
Farmingdale NY 11735
4
3
Single-Family
SoldJul 20, 2026
$730,000
495 Windmill Avenue
West Babylon NY 11704
5
2
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of X Marks The Spot Home Svcs Inc
Show all 23 properties

Katelyn's sold properties

Katelyn has sold 15 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
33 Fischer Avenue, Islip Terrace, NY, 11752
33 Fischer Avenue
Islip Terrace NY 11752
4
2
1
Single-Family$739,000Jul 31, 2026
495 Windmill Avenue, West Babylon, NY, 11704
495 Windmill Avenue
West Babylon NY 11704
5
2
3
Single-Family$730,000Jul 20, 2026
4 Awixa Place, Farmingville, NY, 11784
4 Awixa Place
Farmingville NY 11784
4
2
Single-Family$675,000Jul 17, 2026
89 Pinelawn Avenue, Shirley, NY, 11967
89 Pinelawn Avenue
Shirley NY 11967
2
3
Single-Family$545,000May 28, 2026

Browse nearby locations

© 2026 RateMyAgent