Katelyn's profile

Katelyn's reviews

  5  
Katelyn has 18 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Seller review
A trustworthy, capable professional who will fight for you and get results.
20 days ago
A trustworthy, capable professional who will fight for you and get results.

Whether you’re buying or selling, Katelyn provides a premium level of service. I’ve worked with her twice now and can speak to her trustworthiness, knowledge, and skill in her craft. She stays on top of everything, communicates clearly, and makes sure things actually get done.

Seller review
Sold above asking!
6 months ago
Sold above asking!

Katelyn helped us buy our starter home back in 2021 and then sell that same home just 3 years later, quickly and above asking price! Good communicator and very knowledgeable. Thanks Katelyn!

Seller review
Katelyn is wonderful!
8 months ago
Katelyn is wonderful!

Katelyn was patient and supportive throughout our (long...) new home search process. She showed us dozens of houses over an approx. 2-year period, and never once showed signs of impatience or frustration with us always finding reservations to move forward with each one looked at (until we found "the one!") She was always available to meet, call or text to help answer our thousands of questions/concerns about the home search process. I am so incredibly grateful to her patience, support, and dedication to helping find the perfect forever home for our family!

Buyer review
Very helpful. Very patient.
about 1 year ago
Very helpful. Very patient.

Very helpful. Very patient. First time buyer. Made it easy and simple.

Seller review
Superb communication
over 1 year ago
Superb communication

She is very knowledgeable and professional. She works off of your time which makes the process smooth and quick. I recommend her to any and everyone. Her communication skills are 110%. She's very good at what she does.

Buyer review
Katelyn was the best decision we ever made.
over 1 year ago
Katelyn was the best decision we ever made.

Could not recommend Katelyn more. After switching realtors, Katelyn was able to help us get the very first house that we saw with her. Her communication is top notch, as well as her knowledge about the current housing market. Katelyn truly cares about her clients and their future.

Buyer review
Katelyn is so awesome!!
almost 2 years ago
Katelyn is so awesome!!

Katelyn was very knowledgeable and if she didn't know something she would find out. Very down to earth and quite the therapist when the process gets frustrating. Always available with a cheerful attitude and demeanor and genuinely a blessing to the whole process.

Buyer review
Katelyn McCarthy - Exceptional Service
about 2 years ago
Katelyn McCarthy - Exceptional Service

I recently had the pleasure of working with Katelyn McCarthy during the process of buying my home. I am extremely satisfied with the level of service and expertise she provided. From start to finish Katelyn demonstrated a deep understanding of the real estate market and a commitment to ensuring a smooth and successful transaction! Katelyn is a great communicator. She was always prompt in responding to my inquiries, providing updates, and addressing any concerns I had. Katelyn also pays meticulous attention to details, ensuring that all aspects of the transactions were handled with precision. She was also able to secure favorable terms for me by demonstrating a keen understanding of the negotiation process. I truly felt she had my best interests at heart. Overall, I highly recommend Katelyn McCarthy to anyone in need of a dedicated and knowledgeable real estate professional. Her commitment to client satisfaction, coupled with her expertise, sets her apart in the industry!

Buyer review
Katelyn was great to work with!
over 2 years ago
Katelyn was great to work with!

Katelyn was great to work with. She was always available to answer questions and ready to accommodate our schedule to look at houses. We valued her expertise in crafting offers during a difficult time to buy. Highly recommend!

Seller review
Katelyn was fantastic from start to finish
almost 3 years ago
Katelyn was fantastic from start to finish

Katelyn was fantastic from start to finish. She is very knowledgeable and helped us with every question and step in the process of both selling and buying our home. She took time out of her schedule to accommodate many late notice showings for us. Hopefully we don't need to go through this process again anytime soon, but if we did I hope Kate is still working realty.

Buyer review
My wife and I had a great overall experience with Katelyn!
over 3 years ago
My wife and I had a great overall experience with Katelyn!

My wife and I had a great overall experience with Katelyn. This was our first home buying experience and Katelyn made it very easy. She is very knowledgeable on the process, houses, responded immediately to any question we had, and went out of her way to help us whenever we needed anything even after we closed.

Buyer review
Katelyn was the best real estate agent anyone could ask for!
over 3 years ago
Katelyn was the best real estate agent anyone could ask for!

Katelyn was the best real estate agent anyone could ask for! We were first time home buyers and she explained everything in detail and responded well to our 10000 questions. She pointed out things that we didn't even think of and it really felt like she cared about us. She put our wants and needs above all else. We were able to get a house during the crazy market time after looking at 10 houses, which sounds like a lot but during that time it was not! I will recommend Katelyn to anyone who is looking to buy or sell a house!

1 - 12 of 18
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent