Karlie Montgomery

Karlie Montgomery

Broker / Luxton Real Estate at Luxton Real Estate
California DRE: 01905914
  •   5   (10 reviews)

About Karlie

Karlie Montgomery is a top-rated Realtor® and California broker (DRE #01905914) helping buyers and sellers in Paso Robles, Atascadero, and Templeton. Broker Owner of Luxton Real Estate in Paso Robles, she has closed 300+ home sales since 2011 and holds a 5.0-star rating with 78+ Google reviews. A Certified Paralegal specializing in real estate law, contracts, construction defect, and wills and trusts, she reviews the fine print and negotiates every step for her clients. A Central Coast local since 1980 and a graduate of Atascadero High School and Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, Karlie also serves San Luis Obispo, Avila Beach, and Arroyo Grande, with a focus on first-time buyers, VA loans for veterans, and investment and short-term rental properties. As an active rental investor herself, she knows that market from both sides of the table.

Karlie's reviews

  5  
Karlie has 10 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 6.
Review Karlie
22 days ago
Karlie Is knowledgeable, personable, and always picks up the phone right away

Karlie Is knowledgeable, personable, and always picks up the phone right away. She helped us both buy an investment property at the right time six years ago, and then helped us sell it recently at the right time. Karlie worked diligently to help both buy the property years ago and then sell it. We highly recommend her.

about 1 month ago
If you are looking for the perfect realtor in North San Luis Obispo County, look no further

If you are looking for the perfect realtor in North San Luis Obispo County, look no further. When we were planning to relocate to North County from the San Francisco Bay Area, Karlie helped us every step of the way. She made it so easy for us and went above and beyond. She found us a short-term, fully furnished rental while searched for our dream home in Atascadero. When we finally found our perfect home for purchase, Karlie successfully negotiated down the price. The home buying process could not have gone smoother, and it’s all thanks to Karlie. She’s more than just a realtor. She is an expert on North County with a large network of people and professionals. You’re in good hands if Karlie is your realtor!

about 2 months ago
A N O T E O F TH A N K S ★★★★★ ★★★★★ Five stars doesn't even begin to cover it For Karlie ✦ If I

A N O T E O F TH A N K S ★★★★★ ★★★★★ Five stars doesn't even begin to cover it For Karlie ✦ If I could give Karlie more than !ve stars, I would. Truly, there are not enough stars for this woman. Karlie is the kind of person who seems to walk around with a literal cloud of glitter surrounding her. "e moment I told her I wanted this house, I swear she arrived on a cloud of gold dust about two minutes later and immediately started working her magic. And magic is really the only way to describe what Karlie does. She doesn't just help you buy a house — she somehow makes the entire experience feel exciting, possible, and incredibly special. She is knowledgeable, responsive, determined, reassuring, and genuinely invested in her clients. When something needs to happen, Karlie makes it happen. When you're nervous, she makes you feel like everything is going to be okay. And when something wonderful happens for you, somehow Karlie is even happier for you than you are for yourself. "at's what makes her so extraordinary. Her enthusiasm isn't an act and her kindness isn't part of a sales pitch, it is simply who she is. She celebrates people. She cares deeply. She brings an incredible energy into every room, and there is a reason she seems to be loved by absolutely everyone who knows her. Buying a home is one of the bi#est and most emotional decisions a person can make, and I cannot imagine having gone through this experience with anyone else. Karlie didn't just help me buy a house — she helped change my life. If you are lucky enough to have Karlie as your realtor, you aren't just getting an exceptional real estate agent. You're getting an advocate, a cheerleader, a problem-solver, a magician, and quite possibly the most joyful human being you'll ever meet — not to mention a friend for life. Karlie, thank you for working your magic and getting me HOME. Five stars doesn't even begin to cover it. · · ✦ · ·

about 2 months ago
Karlie was an incredible partner throughout our home buying process

Karlie was an incredible partner throughout our home buying process. From the very beginning, she took the time to really listen and understand our priorities, and she used that understanding to help us evaluate every property with a clear, educated eye. Her guidance made a huge difference in helping us land on the right home with confidence. What really sets Karlie apart is how responsive and hands-on she is. She was always quick to respond and consistently went above and beyond to support us, not just during the transaction, but even after we closed on our home. She connected us with a network of trusted partners for renovation and maintenance projects, which showed us she genuinely cares about her clients' long-term success, not just closing the deal. Karlie has a fantastic network and a real passion for helping people. If you're looking for an agent who will listen closely, advocate for you, and continue supporting you well after the sale, we can't recommend Karlie highly enough.

2 months ago
If you’re looking for the best realtor in Paso Robles, look no further than Karlie Montgomery

If you’re looking for the best realtor in Paso Robles, look no further than Karlie Montgomery. Selling our condo was an incredibly smooth and stress-free experience and it was not an easy sale. We had a very short escrow—just one week—and everything was handled professionally, efficiently, and with great attention to detail. Karlie was always available to answer questions, kept us informed throughout the process, and made what could have been a stressful time feel easy and seamless. Not only is Karlie an exceptional realtor, but also a wonderful person. We are so grateful for all the hard work and care that went into our sale. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and highly recommend Karlie to anyone buying or selling in Paso Robles!

3 months ago
I cannot put adequate words to how amazing Karlie was to work with

I cannot put adequate words to how amazing Karlie was to work with. I agree with the other reviews here. Karlie is an exceptional human being. She went above and beyond to coordinate the sale of our home. Professional, thorough, kind, well connected, prompt, responsive. All positive! 5 stars are not enough. I'm highly recommend her services.

Show all 10 reviews

Karlie's properties

Karlie has 9 properties for sale and sold 24 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$1,695,000
9350 Via Cielo
Atascadero CA 93422
4
4
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Luxton Real Estate
For Sale
$1,250,000
503 Oak St
El Paso de Robles (Paso Robles) CA 93446
3
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Luxton Real Estate
SoldSep 3, 2026
$815,000
1204 Grassy Hollow Way
El Paso de Robles (Paso Robles) CA 93446
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Luxton Real Estate and Windermere Valley Properties
SoldAug 21, 2026
$640,000
248 12th St
San Miguel CA 93451
3
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Luxton Real Estate and Central Coast Sotheby?s International Realty
Show all 33 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent