Karey's profile

Karey's reviews

  5  
Karey has 71 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Karey's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, detail-oriented, supportive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Karey worked very hard for me in a difficult market
about 1 month ago
Karey worked very hard for me in a difficult market

Karey worked very hard for me in a difficult market. I was truly impressed with her honesty, professionalism and knowledge shown while selling our home! She’s awesome, hard working and went above expectations throughout the entire process. I recommend her highly without reservations.

Seller review
San Benito County has a lot of outstanding realtors, and Karey is definitely one of the best
2 months ago
San Benito County has a lot of outstanding realtors, and Karey is definitely one of the best

San Benito County has a lot of outstanding realtors, and Karey is definitely one of the best. She has assisted myself, children and friends with both purchasing and selling properties for over 25years. Her trusted team of assistants, title experts and lenders give you peace of mind through what is always an exciting but challenging process.

Buyer review
Karey Grimsley is truly an exceptional real estate professional, and we are incredibly grateful to h
3 months ago
Karey Grimsley is truly an exceptional real estate professional, and we are incredibly grateful to h

Karey Grimsley is truly an exceptional real estate professional, and we are incredibly grateful to have had her as our buying agent for our first home. From day one, she guided us with patience, clarity, and genuine care. Buying a first home can feel overwhelming, but Karey made the entire process smooth, well organized, and far less stressful than we expected. She was always responsive, detail oriented, and proactive. She took the time to explain every step, answered all our questions, and made sure we felt confident before making any decisions. We always felt that she was looking out for our best interests, not just trying to close a deal. Her market knowledge and negotiation support were invaluable. We feel very happy and lucky to have worked with Karey. Thanks to her dedication and support, we are now excitedly preparing to move into our new home. We could not have asked for a better experience. We highly recommend Karey to anyone buying or selling a home. She goes above and beyond for her clients.

Buyer review
Living the Delightful Country Life
7 months ago
Living the Delightful Country Life

Karey helped us find the home we were looking for even when we weren't sure exactly what we were looking for. We have landed in just the right spot and are living a delightful country life. Last night's sunset and ensuing full moon rising are an example of the delights!

Seller review
Dedication and knowledge - our experience with Karey Grimsley was exceptional.
11 months ago
Dedication and knowledge - our experience with Karey Grimsley was exceptional.

I can’t say enough good things about Karey Grimsley! I first worked with her back in 2011 when I was buying my home, and even then, I was so impressed by her patience, dedication, and deep knowledge of the market. She took the time to really understand what we were looking for and stuck with us through the entire process until we found the perfect home. Fast forward to 2025, and I didn’t hesitate to call Karey again when it was time to sell that same home — and once again, she exceeded expectations. The selling process went exceptionally well from start to finish. Karey was organized, professional, and clearly experienced. She guided me through every step, provided smart advice, and made what could have been a stressful situation feel smooth and manageable. It’s rare to find someone who is not only amazing at what they do but also genuinely kind and easy to work with. Karey is that person. I truly appreciate everything she’s done for me over the years, and I would absolutely recommend her to anyone buying or selling a home!

Buyer review
It was an honor to work with Karey as our realtor
about 1 year ago
It was an honor to work with Karey as our realtor

It was an honor to work with Karey as our realtor. She consistently exceeded our expectations in both selling our house and helping us find our dream home. Karey guided us patiently through every step of the selling process and the search for our forever home. She always responded promptly to our questions and concerns. We genuinely appreciate her professionalism, responsiveness, and dedication. We wholeheartedly recommend her to anyone seeking a reliable and knowledgeable real estate agent.

Seller review
It was such a pleasure to have worked with Karey in selling our home
about 1 year ago
It was such a pleasure to have worked with Karey in selling our home

It was such a pleasure to have worked with Karey in selling our home. We found Karey to be a very knowledgeable, professional and a very helpful real estate agent. Karey tried her best to sell our home by marketing it, holding weekly open houses and promptly answering our phone calls as well as our text messages. Karey listed our home for sale at Twin Oaks Community but unfortunately we were not able to sell our home due to a very slow market. We decided to take our home off the market until the market stabilizes.

Buyer review
Working with Karey on the purchase of our first home was great experience
over 1 year ago
Working with Karey on the purchase of our first home was great experience

Working with Karey on the purchase of our first home was great experience. From the very beginning, she impressed us with her attention to detail, ensuring that every aspect of the process was handled thoroughly and efficiently. Karey took the time to truly understand our needs, preferences, and budget, which made us feel supported throughout what could have otherwise been an overwhelming journey. What stood out was how attentive she was during every step of the process. Whether it was answering our endless questions, promptly addressing our concerns, or walking us through complex paperwork, Karey went above and beyond to make sure we felt confident and informed. Beyond being knowledgeable and professional, Karey was also incredibly supportive. Buying a first home comes with its fair share of stress, but she remained patient, understanding, and encouraging the entire time. Karey never pushed us to rush into a decision and always had our best interests at heart, which we appreciated. Thanks to Karey, we found our dream home, and we couldn’t be happier. If you’re looking for someone who truly cares about their clients and will guide you through every step of the way, you cannot go wrong with Karey.

Seller review
If I need a Realtor, Karey is my first choice.
over 1 year ago
If I need a Realtor, Karey is my first choice.

I've had the pleasure of doing business with Karey Grimsley many times over the years. She has always been the utmost professional, trustworthy, kind, and helpful. Her marketing is top notch, and she is well educated as to the many intricacies of the real estate contract. I have since retired and have been able to refer past buyers and sellers to her. Each time, the clients have been very happy with her service and professionalism. If I need a Realtor for myself, my family, or my past clients, Karey is my first choice. Cheryl Calhoun Real Estate Broker CA DRE #01251851

1 - 12 of 71
© 2026 RateMyAgent