Karey's profile

Karey's reviews

  5  
Karey has 78 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Karey's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, supportive, well-prepared, clear communication, reliable, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Karey was very helpful and professional
over 4 years ago
Karey was very helpful and professional

Karey worked with me to sell the family home. She helped with a recommendation for an estate sale and clean out to get the house ready for the market. Karey provided me with sound advice on the best way to approach the sale on a house that needed extensive repairs and was part of an estate. She was able to answer questions other family members had regarding pricing and repairs. When offers came in she was able to explain the pros and cons of each so we could make an informed decision on which to pick. Throughout the process Karey was professional and accommodating of the special circumstances regarding this sale.

Seller review
Karey Grimsley was the most impressive referral  I have experienced in 37 years of practice
over 4 years ago
Karey Grimsley was the most impressive referral I have experienced in 37 years of practice

Karey Grimsley was the most impressive referral I have experienced in 37 years of practice. You know it’s going well when you get an unsolicited call from the client thanking you for referring to her. They had a difficult and drawn out situation and said she helped them immensely. Karey maintained contact with me and was polite and prompt with the referral payment. If there were more stars to give on the rating she would deserve them.

Buyer review
Karey was my real estate agent in Hollister, Ca, in Spring 2021.
over 4 years ago
Karey was my real estate agent in Hollister, Ca, in Spring 2021.

Karey is an experienced and highly professional real estate agent. Karey listened to needs and requirements for a new home. She surpassed my expectations by far in guiding me to not only a beautiful home as well as a great investment. Karey’s diligence and hard work brought me to a successful home purchase experience. I recommend Karey to new home purchasers in the Hollister area without reservation.

Seller review
I definitely would use her again!
over 4 years ago
I definitely would use her again!

She made the whole experience of selling my family home easy. I’d definitely use her again!

Buyer review
She got us into a perfect home !
over 4 years ago
She got us into a perfect home !

Karey was professional, prompt and never out of contact with us. I've used her services twice now and just like the first time this most recent experience was no different. She navigated us through a complex market and got us into a perfect home. I wouldn't think twice before using her services again.

Buyer review
Great experience working with Karey Grimsley!
almost 5 years ago
Great experience working with Karey Grimsley!

We had a great experience working with Karey on both selling our house in Boulder Creek then finding a new home for us to purchase in Hollister. All of this happened within a few weeks during the holiday period. No hassles or issues, smooth and professional transactions. I recommended Karey to my brother who also purchased a house in Hollister in December.

Seller review
Great experience working with Karey Grimsley!
almost 5 years ago
Great experience working with Karey Grimsley!

We had a great experience working with Karey on both selling our house in Boulder Creek then finding a new home for us to purchase in Hollister. All of this happened within a few weeks during the holiday period. No hassles or issues, smooth and professional transactions. I recommended Karey to my brother who also purchased a house in Hollister in December.

Buyer review
Best Day Ever
almost 5 years ago
Best Day Ever

Karey and I went to check out a couple of the older houses listed. I would often repeat visits to the Redfin website to these visually charming properties. Karey and I quickly realized these were not “the one.” We found “the one” the very next day.

Seller review
Outstanding Professionalism and Superior Customer Service
almost 5 years ago
Outstanding Professionalism and Superior Customer Service

Our experience working with Karey was the best of the best. My husband and I were new to the selling market Karey broke down every detail for us with conference calls and went through in fine detail filling out all the paperwork with us. She was so kind and so gentle in helping understand what was going to happen at every step in the process. We had a weed challenge in the backyard, my husband had just had hand surgery, and she hired someone and took care of it for us. With health challenges she was so accommodating to do everything over the phone and only met in person when necessary. The whole process was seem less. We listed the house on a Thursday and she had a bid for us by that following Tuesday. She helped us sell for $25,000 over asking. The closing process was as simple, she arrange for a title company close to our current home to avoid the hour travel time. Right before we closed we stopped by to pick-up our lamps on timers and she had this beautiful sign by the front door advising people to take off their shoes. What a class act. From the 1st day we meet with her until the last signature and beyond. When we received a property tax bill months later I didn’t hesitate to text her and ask her about it. She said don’t worry they probably have not update the ownership at the county and advised where to call. Sure enough she was right they were sending updates the following week. She always had the time to talk to us no question was to big or to small. She was the most approachable professional person. Select Karey G she will make the whole buying or the whole selling process seem less. She knows the market, the comps of other houses in the area, and extremely professional at every level of the selling process.

37 - 48 of 78
© 2026 RateMyAgent