Karen's profile

Karen's reviews

  5  
Karen has 28 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Karen's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, hard-working, responsive, trustworthy, clear communication, well-prepared, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
When preparing to sell our home we were interested in using a broker with acute market knowledge and
almost 8 years ago
When preparing to sell our home we were interested in using a broker with acute market knowledge and

When preparing to sell our home we were interested in using a broker with acute market knowledge and experience in our local area. We also wanted someone who used marketing tools to reach a broad audience via social media and other web based platforms to maximize exposure. It was important to us that our broker use staging, photography and videography for a strong advantage in the market. Karen worked with us from the beginning of the process and brought with her a bevy of resources to ready our home for sale. She was with us every step of the way during all phases of the process. She even helped us find a painter on short notice and a mover to help us move out. We were thrilled by the full price offer we received within 3 days of listing with her. Our house closed smoothly, thanks to Karen's diligence. We are so grateful for an excellent experience. Karen is a consummate professional. She is extremely knowledgeable in her field and in the area she works. She executes all of these skills while continuing to be patient with her clients, and steady under pressure. Karen is always there for us when we need her. Karen Kitzmiller goes above and beyond to exceed expectations!

Seller review
Karen did a great job
almost 9 years ago
Karen did a great job

Karen did a great job. She was on top of all the details involved in the transaction and kept things moving along. We even went to see a couple of houses after I had signed the contract just to make sure I was comfortable with my decision. I'm glad I called Karen! Karen provided appropriate guidance without being pushy. Much appreciated, I would definitely recommend Karen to friends and family!

Seller review
Karen was absolutely essential to the sale of our home
almost 9 years ago
Karen was absolutely essential to the sale of our home

Karen was absolutely essential to the sale of our home. We had many issues that had to be addressed prior to listing, and she was instrumental in the success of each of those items. She was able to make suggestions, provide referrals for companies who could perform the work, "talk me off the ledge" in more than one instance, and keep us on track towards a listing date. My experience was fabulous. I have already referred a neighbor who is considering selling to Karen, and would do the same for any friend with absolutely no hesitation. Excellent is not a high enough rating. She was absolutely exceptional in all aspects.

Buyer review
Karen is a fantastic agent
almost 9 years ago
Karen is a fantastic agent

Karen is a fantastic agent. She worked diligently on our behalf and always had our best interests in mind while going through the purchase process.

Buyer review
Karen was availabe,  always responded in a timely manner, very knowledgeable of market and what was
almost 9 years ago
Karen was availabe, always responded in a timely manner, very knowledgeable of market and what was

Karen was availabe, always responded in a timely manner, very knowledgeable of market and what was available. Karen did what she said she was going to do and kept us informed. Karen has a trustworthy disposition; personable in a genuine way but maintained a high level of professionalism. We have friends in the mid west contemplating moving into the area. Karen will be their agent!

Seller review
We have worked with Karen both as a buyer and seller
almost 9 years ago
We have worked with Karen both as a buyer and seller

We have worked with Karen both as a buyer and seller. She is the best agent I have ever worked with. Seriously. She is a master negotiator, she is honest, she is incredibly hard working and super responsive. Not only that, but she's a great person too. We couldn't be more thankful to her expertise!

Buyer review
Karen Kitzmiller has been our broker three times now and never disappoints
almost 9 years ago
Karen Kitzmiller has been our broker three times now and never disappoints

Karen Kitzmiller has been our broker three times now and never disappoints. She is absolutely amazing in everything she does and puts us right at ease. Karen goes above and beyond in every way and is there for us every step of the way. I would recommend her a thousand times over and will never consider using anyone else. We would be lost without her and her services.

Seller review
We had a hard situation with our house
almost 9 years ago
We had a hard situation with our house

We had a hard situation with our house. There were many factors to it that could have been messed up very easily. We chose Karen Kitzmiller because we knew she was able to handle this. Her experience, knowledge and connections to the right people to complete the sale was exactly what we were looking for. We knew she could handle the challenge and she did with flying colors! We closed and it went beautifully thanks to Karen and her crew! Thank you Karen for everything! We are already working on our next deal with her!! If you need someone who can and will get the job done, definitely talk with Karen.

Seller review
It was a pleasure to work with Karen again! We had used Karen's services to rent a house and then ye
almost 10 years ago
It was a pleasure to work with Karen again! We had used Karen's services to rent a house and then ye

It was a pleasure to work with Karen again! We had used Karen's services to rent a house and then years later to buy a house. Karen's patience with us through the process was comforting and her guidance was essential. When we needed to sell our home, Karen's ability to accurately determine a sales price that was both profitable for us and enticing to the market made our sale in days. Our trust in Karen to guide us through such an important process really paid off.

13 - 24 of 28
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent