Joe Mathias

Joe Mathias

Ohio: 2003003298Michigan: 6501332766
  •   5   (60 reviews)

About Joe

Having earned the top sales award (Pinnacle of Performance) every year since 2011 from the Toledo Regional Association of Realtors, Joe knows how to get results. Joe is not only among the top agents in the Toledo metropolitan area; but also, he ranks among the top 1% of all agents across the nation. Joe could not help as many clients as he does without first earning their trust. He brings a passion to real estate and is an expert negotiator. Besides being a professional with deep market knowledge, Joe is a devoted husband, father of two, and a black belt in karate. In addition to receiving a bachelors degree from Indiana University and an MBA from the University of Toledo, Joe has received advanced training from top real estate experts across the country. Prior to starting his real estate career, Joe spent seven years with Harbor Capital Advisors, giving him an extensive background in finance, technology, and sales that has benefited his real estate clients. If you are searching for the right agent to help buy or sell a property, Joe is ready to give you great service and expert advice.

Joe's reviews

  5  
Joe has 60 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 6.
Review Joe
about 8 years ago
Joe listed and sold our home in Ottawa Hills and was extremely professional

Joe listed and sold our home in Ottawa Hills and was extremely professional. He was willing to have the sometimes difficult and necessary conversations on staging and pricing. We never doubted his goal to sell our home. If we could, we'd work with Joe again. No question.

over 8 years ago
We relocated from New Jersey and we were unfamiliar with the area

We relocated from New Jersey and we were unfamiliar with the area. Joe was extremely responsive, easy to work with and genuinely engaged and concerned. You know when someone's just handling you and when they are actively involved and with Joe we got the involved attention we required in selecting our home. I can't imagine a better agent.

over 8 years ago
Joe did a wonderful job with helping in our relocation to the area

Joe did a wonderful job with helping in our relocation to the area. He was very helpful in identifying candidate properties & helping us narrow down the selections. When he took my wife around the first time, he had a very good process for helping her compare among the dozen homes she went through. He was available more than a few times to take us through homes - even for multiple visits to the same homes. He guided us through the process of negotiating the price and the inspection process and results - and fully supported the mortgage and closing. He and his team kept in touch to make sure we were pleased with our new home and our acclimation to the area. I would definitely recommend Joe & his team!

over 8 years ago
Joe helped me buy a house in Ottawa Hills in March 2017

Joe helped me buy a house in Ottawa Hills in March 2017. He was very accommodating for when I was able to view houses, and he answered promptly whenever I contacted him about any stage of the process. This was especially great considering that I did not live in the area and had to travel to visit, and Joe set up numerous viewings to maximize my time in town. As a result, I was able to find and close on a house in less than six weeks total. After nine months, I'm extremely happy with my house!

over 8 years ago
Joe was of the most help to find and close a deal on our house

Joe was of the most help to find and close a deal on our house. His knowledge, experience and interpersonal abilities were key for the negotiation. We were very stress because we came from another country and did not know how to deal with all the details for buying a house, Joe did the difference to ease the search and closing. Greatly appreciate all his support, technical and emotional.

Show all 60 reviews

Joe's properties

Joe has 13 properties for sale and sold 59 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 20, 2026
$735,000
5645 Keener Rd
Lucas County OH 43542
6
5
12
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of The Danberry Co and RE/MAX Preferred Associates
SoldMay 18, 2026
$405,000
3008 Estuary Place
Maumee OH 43537
3
2
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Preferred Associates and Serenity Realty LLC
SoldMay 15, 2026
$350,000
351 East Temperance Road
Temperance MI 48182
2
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Preferred Associates and KW Professionals
SoldMay 15, 2026
$1,000,000
4201 Thornbury Court
Perrysburg OH 43551
4
6
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Preferred Associates and Loss Realty Group
Show all 72 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent