Holly's profile

Holly's reviews

  5  
Holly has 62 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Holly's qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, resourceful, great negotiation, honest, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Very thorough excellent communicator.
22 days ago
Very thorough excellent communicator.

Holly is very knowledgeable, she knows her real estate, and she will get to the bottom of whatever she has to get to. There’s no doubt. She always responds so quickly. She can be aggressive when she needs to be which it’s nice to have someone that isn’t afraid to speak her mind and have your back. I would highly recommend Holly to anyone who wants a very go-getter realtor. It is always a pleasure to work with her. We love, Holly!! And I think anybody else would too.

Buyer review
Patience of a Ssint
about 1 month ago
Patience of a Ssint

This is the second time I have worked with Holly on. real estate transaction. She communicated with me every part of my purchasing my new home. She kept me informed about inspections, surveys, appraisals, what stage of the loan we were at. Her professionalism is always present. The negotiation skills: MIND BLOWING! That is all I am saying. As far as market knowledge, she knew the value of every house on the street where I bought my home.

Buyer review
Absolutely fantastic
3 months ago
Absolutely fantastic

Holly was so wonderful helping us with our transition of purchasing a house as well as assisting us with the sale of our house. We couldn't have done it without her!! Thanks Holly!!

Seller review
Painless Process
5 months ago
Painless Process

Holly made us feel like family and was very supportive. Her knowledge of the market and the process made us feel at ease, even though we were in areas that were not familiar to us. Star quality all of the way. Holly, thank you so much. Debbie and I are very happy.

Buyer review
Easiest purchase of my life!
6 months ago
Easiest purchase of my life!

Holly was such an incredible guide to have help me through my first home purchase. From finding the perfect home, to walking me through each step of the process, holly made this one of the best and easiest purchases of my life. No ask was ever too much and any questions I had along the way were promptly fielded. Holly thank you for everything you do, and for making my dream home a reality!!!

Seller review
BEST EVER!!
7 months ago
BEST EVER!!

Holly has been our realtor thru 3 purchases and 2 sales. She is the absolute best! This sale was challenging in the current market, but Holly never let us down. She is not only our realtor, but also now a dear friend.

Seller review
Holly is the BEST
7 months ago
Holly is the BEST

She went above and beyond and made sure we weee comfortable the entire time and kept us in the loop and helped us maximize our proceeds.

Buyer review
Holly Schmidt Magnolia Homes and Land
8 months ago
Holly Schmidt Magnolia Homes and Land

I had an outstanding experience working with Holly Schmidt from Magnolia Homes and Land. From our first meeting, Holly demonstrated a level of professionalism, expertise, and genuine collaboration that truly set her apart. What impressed me Knowledgeable and Insightful: Holly has an excellent grasp of the local market, including neighborhood trends, pricing, and inventory. She took the time to explain the current market conditions in clear, actionable terms. Responsive and Accessible: Whenever I reached out with questions or updates, Holly replied promptly. Her communication was consistent without being overbearing, which made the process smoother and less stressful. Personalized Service: She listened carefully to my must-haves and budget, then curated a tailored list of options that matched my criteria. Her attention to detail ensured we didn’t waste time on properties that wouldn’t fit. Skilled Negotiator: Holly’s negotiation tactics were thoughtful and effective. She advocated fiercely on my behalf while maintaining a professional and respectful demeanor, ultimately securing favorable terms. Trustworthy and Transparent: I appreciated her honesty about property pros and cons. She provided balanced perspectives, including potential long-term value and any hidden risks, so I could make informed decisions. Support Throughout the Process: From scheduling showings to coordinating inspections, appraisals, and the paperwork, Holly kept everything organized and moving forward smoothly. The outcome Thanks to Holly’s guidance, I found a property that checks all the boxes and negotiated a fair deal. The entire experience felt seamless, and I felt confident every step of the way. Who I’d Recommend Holly Schmidt To Buyers who want a proactive, knowledgeable agent who explains every step clearly Sellers looking for a strategic marketing plan and strong negotiation skills Clients who value integrity, responsiveness, and a person-first approach

Seller review
Best Realtor Ever!!!! LOOK NO FURTHER!!!
8 months ago
Best Realtor Ever!!!! LOOK NO FURTHER!!!

We had our Florida home in The Villages listed for 6 months with the first agent. We had little communication and felt deflated from our experience. After searching for a new agent, we came accross Holly's page. We read her reviews and decided to reach out. From that moment forward, we felt like we mattered. She communicates clearly, effectivly and often. She makes you feel important and prioritized. Within a few weeks, we had offers (as a side-note, these offers came in the most off-season time for Florida-summer). Our home closed a month later-no issues. Holly will guide you, support you and keep you in the loop. If you are searching for the best agent - look no further. Take my advice. You will not be dissappointed. Smooth, easy and fun. She also has a dynamic personality. Thank you Holly Schmidt! We adore you! The Ackermans

Buyer review
Quick , simple , and professional
9 months ago
Quick , simple , and professional

Any issues I had were resolved quickly , Holly communicated well with my agent , I am content .

Buyer review
Best realtor ever
10 months ago
Best realtor ever

Holly and her team went above and beyond throughout the whole process. Words cannot express my gratitude to them!

Seller review
WE WERE STUNNED!
10 months ago
WE WERE STUNNED!

Holly is amazing. From our first meeting, we knew she would be our Realtor. She is probably the most positive person I have ever met. She solved every and any problem that arose. Actually our Home sold quicker than we ever imagined. She is professional, knowledgeable, and stayed in constant communication with us. Anytime I would get nervous or fearful - which is normal for a Seller I hear - she has the ability to calm and reassure. She always treated us with nothing but respect. We had a completely positive experience. Get to meet her, you won't be sorry!

1 - 12 of 62
© 2026 RateMyAgent