Holly's profile

Holly's reviews

  5  
Holly has 37 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Holly's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, great team, supportive, clear communication, reliable, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Phenomenal experience
almost 3 years ago
Phenomenal experience

Holly and her partners, Katina and Ken Shanahan, did an amazing job for us. They made every step very easy, from the listing, to the staging, to the Open Houses, to the negotiation of the sale, to the inspections, and the closing. Holly was present and available every step of the way. Communications and managing our expectations were fantastic.

Seller review
When you want the very best
about 3 years ago
When you want the very best

Couldn’t possibly find enough superlatives to describe our experience selling our home with Holly. Knowledgable, responsive, helpful, great personality, attractive, the whole nine yards. Unquestionably the best in the business! ,

Buyer review
Excellent Experienced Realtor
over 3 years ago
Excellent Experienced Realtor

From our first meeting with Holly we knew we were in the right hands. She is very friendly and has a vast knowledge of the real estate market. Most importantly, was that she listened to us and understood exactly what we were looking for. She only showed us homes that fit our must haves list and that was in our price range. Even after we decided that we wanted to live in a different area that was outside her normal range she stuck with us to make sure we found our dream home. She has an amazing eye for details and caught several things that we would have overlooked. We would highly recommend Holly if you are looking for a realtor!

Seller review
The Very Best
over 3 years ago
The Very Best

Holly is the only Realtor we use. She is professional and so knowledgeable…she’s like family to us. Outstanding all around Realtor if you are selling or buying…..couldn’t have done it without her.

Buyer review
Great service!
over 3 years ago
Great service!

Need I say more , Holly has helped our family in the sale and purchase of three homes which speaks for itself ! Professional yet very personal service !

Buyer review
Truly professional Agent—with a great team!
over 3 years ago
Truly professional Agent—with a great team!

We called Holly after meeting her at Open Houses in our target area. She remembered us, and what we liked, and so we called her when we needed an Agent. We were in good hands from the start. Not only is Holly conscientious, knowledgeable, and resourceful, she has a great support team who made sure we were covered at every step—from house viewings, to insights and guidance, to contacts for every need. Highly recommend you contact her!

Seller review
Great experience with a true professional
over 3 years ago
Great experience with a true professional

Holly was on top of everything from the beginning, providing expert advice and guidance on our house, market conditions and the sales process. The entire experience was smooth, orderly and highly professional. Holly provided constant communication and was quick to respond to any questions with great advice and guidance. I would highly recommend Holly.

Seller review
FANTASTIC!
over 3 years ago
FANTASTIC!

Holly and the entire group were fantastic! Their professionalism, efficiency, and friendliness were above and beyond. Holly, Katina, Ken, and Tyler all worked incredibly hard for us. Holly’s incredible negotiating skills not only got us top dollar for our home, but also all the small details on the offer to purchase that were important to us. Working with the Pascarella Shanahan Group was the best real estate decision we have ever made.

Seller review
Exceptional Service, Communication & Results
about 4 years ago
Exceptional Service, Communication & Results

Holly & their entire Organization was excellent to work with, they went over and beyond through out the whole process. Great to work with, fast, efficient & effective. Photos were excellent! So the whole experience was more then I can ever ask for, just perfect!

Seller review
Holly was hands on for every aspect of our home sale from pricing to staging to negotiating, etc.
about 4 years ago
Holly was hands on for every aspect of our home sale from pricing to staging to negotiating, etc.

Holly has an in depth knowledge of our local market including pricing, home presentation and staging, and marketing. She's a true professional. She is hand on with every aspect of the sale and negotiated a higher price than listing and still sold the house in one day. She worked closely with us to make the sale seamless and communicated with us frequently and returned our calls promptly. We highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in Lakewood Ranch and surrounds.

Seller review
Review of Holley Pascarella
about 4 years ago
Review of Holley Pascarella

Holley is an experienced sales agent. She shares her knowledge of the market with the seller and listens to the sellers needs. She has wonderful taste in staging your homes for open houses. We appreciated frequent contact through our sales experience.

Seller review
Hands down the best realtors in town!
over 5 years ago
Hands down the best realtors in town!

Holly and Mary Helen of the Pascarella Group are hands down the best realtors in town! They represented us in the sale of two homes, and the purchase of a home. They were professional, kind, and responsive all the way through, and worked hard from beginning to end. They were honest and provided us with helpful feedback. I couldn't recommend them more!

25 - 36 of 37
© 2026 RateMyAgent