Holly's profile

Holly's reviews

  5  
Holly has 37 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Holly's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, great team, supportive, clear communication, reliable, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Your Your search should start and end with Holly
over 2 years ago
Your Your search should start and end with Holly

Holly took the time to fine tune exactly what we were looking for. We had a lot of requirements and she made sure to check the boxes. She did not hesitate to bring in other professionals to assist in evaluations and to provide after purchase vendors with whom she has had previous favorable results.

Buyer review
The only realtor you need! Holly Pascarella of Coldwell Banker Reality
over 2 years ago
The only realtor you need! Holly Pascarella of Coldwell Banker Reality

The only realtor you need! Holly Pascarella of Coldwell Banker Reality . Professional, dedicated to the sale, extensive years of experience in the area with many awards to speak to how accredited and in demand she is in the housing market. We recently completed our second home purchase with great satisfaction using Holly and her team as our agent.

Buyer review
Experienced, readily available and committed to securing a contract!
over 2 years ago
Experienced, readily available and committed to securing a contract!

Holly Pascarella, highly recommended for her professionalism and extensive years of knowledge in the housing market. We have now purchased our second home with Holly and both were exactly what we wanted. With her experience she effortlessly handled a contract for us virtually while we were out of the country and another new build from out of state. These purchases and contracts required negotiations and bidding to be the best offer for the sellers to consider. She is very personable, devotes herself to getting the deal done even when it requires work beyond normal hours. We highly recommend the team she employs to offer you a level of attention and wide reach of resources that will serve your needs all while not wasting your time! Her sales and closing awards will tell you the rest. Holly Pascarella, the only relator to contact.

Seller review
A very great experience
over 2 years ago
A very great experience

It is great to have the expertise that Holly and her team provides the client. I would advise using their services as you need the best in your real estate dealings.

Buyer review
The Best Realtor
over 2 years ago
The Best Realtor

We have used Holly’s services multiple times and although I expected her role to be more limited this time, it was not. She was available to me for any recommendations or advice along the way. We have no reservations about recommending her to other buyers and sellers.

Buyer review
Far and away the BEST
over 2 years ago
Far and away the BEST

This transaction was our 21st lifetime sale/purchase. Holly ranks number one BY FAR of all the agents we have ever used. Unsurpassed!!

Seller review
Very happy
over 2 years ago
Very happy

We used Holly to sell our house. She and her team did a great job. Our house sold in two weeks. We would definitely recommend her.

Seller review
Thank you for outstanding service!
over 2 years ago
Thank you for outstanding service!

The Pascarella Shanahan Luxury Group has been a pleasure to work with. The three experienced realtors have extensive knowledge of the Sarasota/Bradenton area and they worked extremely well as a team to achieve our objectives. We had certain requirements which were challenging to address but the team handled it easily. They kept us informed at all times, and helped us to address a few minor concerns which arose during the process. We have transferred properties several times before, but we’ve never had realtors who were as professional as Holly and her team. We send them our sincerest thanks! M & J

Buyer review
Top Professional
almost 3 years ago
Top Professional

My husband and I used Holly to help us purchase a new home in Florida. She was responsive, helpful and a delight to work with. We now consider her a friend.

Seller review
Very professional experience. Efficient.
almost 3 years ago
Very professional experience. Efficient.

Holly is personable, always responded very timely. She is knowledgeable of the market and her history in the area makes it very beneficial.

Seller review
The BEST in a very competitive business!
almost 3 years ago
The BEST in a very competitive business!

After researching Realtors in my area for their market knowledge I found Holly at the top. During the most stressful time of my life, losing my husband, Holly guided me through selling our home and downsizing to a villa. She was there for me every step of the way, answering myriad of questions, always returning phone calls and texts in a timely manner, if she couldn't be there one of her competent team members would be. Sometimes just her smile and sunny personality would make my day. The selling of our home went so smoothly, in less than a week. Looking for a villa was a bit more difficult but Holly knew me and knew what I wanted. We looked at many communities and she was quite frank with me. I would sometimes overlook things that were obvious to Holly. The same with looking at villas. Well, I ended up in a lovely community in a perfect villa by listening to the wise advice of Holly and her team. I cannot praise Holly Pascarella enough!!

Seller review
Best in the Business
almost 3 years ago
Best in the Business

Holly and the entire team are a delight to work with. We are delighted with the results. Each member of the team worked professionally and tirelessly to achieve our expectations.

13 - 24 of 37
© 2026 RateMyAgent