Gale's profile

Gale's reviews

  5  
Gale has 88 reviewsacross 28 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Gale's qualities as told by our client reviews: attentive, supportive, great negotiation, clear communication, reliable, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Gale Milgrim is one of the Winter Park-Baldwin Park-Maitland area’s top real estate agents
about 4 years ago
Gale Milgrim is one of the Winter Park-Baldwin Park-Maitland area’s top real estate agents

Gale Milgrim is one of the Winter Park-Baldwin Park-Maitland area’s top real estate agents. I used her as a buyer’s agent in a buyer’s market a decade ago and again in the current seller’s market. We competed in a multiple offer scenario and got the house, following her advice. Decades of knowledge and experience really do make a difference.

Buyer review
Knowledge and Experience Make a Difference
about 4 years ago
Knowledge and Experience Make a Difference

Gale Milgrim is one of the Winter Park-Baldwin Park-Maitland area’s top real estate agents. I used her as a buyer’s agent in a buyer’s market a decade ago and again in the current seller’s market. We competed in a multiple offer scenario and got the house, following her advice. Decades of knowledge and experience really do make a difference.

Buyer review
Gale is the best!!!
over 4 years ago
Gale is the best!!!

Unlike other realtors, Gale has decades of experience. Her patience and professionalism is second to none. She is knowledgeable about the real estate economy and knows how to creatively get you in the home you want. I wouldn’t ever choose anyone else to represent me !

Seller review
Working with Gale means I don't have to worry about a thing!
over 4 years ago
Working with Gale means I don't have to worry about a thing!

After my mother passed, I had to clean out her home and get it in ready-to-sell condition. Gale Milgrim made the process so much easier. Gale came in and gave me an honest assessment of the house and told me exactly what I needed to be done, with names and contact info of various tradesmen. Once the house was ready to go, the house was immediately put on the market and Gale had it professionally photographed and marketed it. It was sold in 2 weeks. Gale has handled several real estate transactions for my family because she is the consummate professional. I have recommended her to a number of people and they are always happy with her performance.

Buyer review
Goes Above and Beyond
over 4 years ago
Goes Above and Beyond

Gale helped me buy a home, and she was great to work with! She always goes the extra mile, and I would recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home in Orlando!

Seller review
I still cannot believe it!!!
over 4 years ago
I still cannot believe it!!!

What can I say about Gale that has not been said already?! From beginning to end it was effortless…Gale is an amazing professional and we are in our temporary abode in less than a month! My husband and are so appreciative, there are not enough words! We will definitely be calling her for our next purchase!!

Seller review
Amazing from start to finish!!
almost 5 years ago
Amazing from start to finish!!

It’s hard to know where to start! Our experience with Gail Milgrim and the entire KW staff was wonderful. We first met with Gail and discussed our house, its potential value and when to put it on the market. We were anxious to get it sold, but Gail advised that we hold off a month. We were hesitant but listened to her and the result was just what she promised. Prices had continued to rise, supply continued to diminish so we ended up getting even more for our house than we anticipated. Gail and her team made the entire process easy. First they advised us on the staging of the house to accent its special features and make it more marketable. Next was their photographer who put together a series of photos that even impressed us! With these pictures and a first rate description the house was listed. We assumed we would get interest, but over 30 viewing in 3 days, was amazing. Gail made this part go smoothly too setting up times and dates for the many showings. All we had to do was leave in the morning and come back “when the coast was clear”. No hassle no problems. We then sat down with Gail and she presented us with a spreadsheet summarizing the various offers and the pros and cons of each. Her explanation of what made one offer better than an other helped so much in our deciding on a buyer. She continued to monitor the rest of the process dealing with inspectors, and any other little unforeseen issue that arose. Finally came the day of closing. Gail met us at the title company to make sure that all went smoothly there as well. From start to finish we couldn’t have asked for more then the professional, considerate and dedicated attention we received.

Seller review
Our selling experience with Gale
almost 5 years ago
Our selling experience with Gale

Gale is a very professional and motivated realtor. She was very helpful from very beginning to the very end, things such as doing market comp/analysis, hiring professionals to stage the house, finding techs to fix the house and hosting Open House, etc. Gale handled things in a timely matter and you don’t ever need to worry about not being able to find her. We are very happy that she sold our house so quickly, it was such a stress free transaction. We highly recommend her to anyone who has a housing need, buying or selling.

Buyer review
Gale homed in immediately on our needs and requirements.
almost 5 years ago
Gale homed in immediately on our needs and requirements.

Gale's lengthy experience in the Orlando area helped make our house-hunting easy and effortless. She is thoroughly familiar with the many neighborhoods and took our needs, desires and budget into consideration to help us find the perfect home.

Seller review
5 stars for Gale!
almost 5 years ago
5 stars for Gale!

I wanted to take a moment to give a shout out to our agent, Gale Milgrim with Keller Williams. Gale was someone that has called us off and on for the past 10 years asking if we would be interested in selling our home. Back in March, Gale happened to call us again, coincidentally on the same day that I received/accepted a new job offer, to ask us if we would be interested in selling as she had a buyer who was looking to move into the our neighborhood. We said "sure, the timing is great so let’s give it a go". Gale toured our home and we quickly came to a suggested sales price. (Editor’s note, I thought Gale was nuts as the price she wanted to list it at was really pushing the market.) Well after one showing we received a very compelling offer and accepted. Gale was also able to get us an extended close date so that our kids could finish school without any disruptions. If you are thinking about selling, I can highly recommend Gale and encourage you to contact her. From first contact to close, Gale was an all-around pro and made the process super easy. I also encourage you to really push the market with your own list price if you do look to sell. The market is on fire so don’t be afraid to ask for top dollar. You owe it to your neighbors!

Buyer review
We were 4 hours away from where we wanted to purchase a home in Longwood, FL
about 5 years ago
We were 4 hours away from where we wanted to purchase a home in Longwood, FL

We were 4 hours away from where we wanted to purchase a home in Longwood, FL. Gale went above and beyond by previewing in person what we could only see on-line. Once we narrowed the field of possibilities, we made the trip from South Florida to Longwood to view three homes. We loved the first one so much, we skipped the others. We wrote an offer that weekend and went back home to South Florida. Gale and her associate, Shari, did all the legwork to make our purchase happen 30 days later. She facilitated work in the house to install a new floor before we moved in and did it all via e-mail and text. She was always available when we needed her and was very responsive throughout the process. She did more for us than she would have had to do with local buyers and we are very appreciative of her efforts. She did a masterful job of coordinating the closing between the three parties (buyer, seller, and title company). Even after the closing and moving into our new home she has made herself available to assist us in settling in to our new community. We highly recommend Gale as a Real Estate agent due to her great knowledge of the community and vast network of contacts to assist with almost anything. She made our experience a pleasure.

Buyer review
My wife and I found Gale on a Facebook group page where she was highly recommended by local Moms
about 5 years ago
My wife and I found Gale on a Facebook group page where she was highly recommended by local Moms

My wife and I found Gale on a Facebook group page where she was highly recommended by local Moms. We were moving to Orlando from Gainesville and not that familiar with the different areas of the city. Gale possesses a comprehensive knowledge of the Orlando and extended area and was able to guide us in finding a neighborhood that aligned with our lifestyle. Gale worked with our schedule so when we spotted houses for sale online, she would set up appointments for us to visit and tour on a day trip. Gale was always responsive. After three or four visits and tours, we found the perfect home in Altamonte Springs and we moved quickly to get it under contract. We just closed this week. Through the entire closing process, Gale kept us informed and on task so everything went smoothly and painlessly. We are making a few minor updates to the house and Gale provided several quality referrals. Overall, it has been a pleasure to work with Gale and I would highly recommend her!

61 - 72 of 88
© 2026 RateMyAgent