Gale's profile

Gale's reviews

  5  
Gale has 91 reviewsacross 29 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Gale's qualities as told by our client reviews: attentive, supportive, great negotiation, clear communication, responsive, reliable, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Great experience with a long distance move
almost 3 years ago
Great experience with a long distance move

Moving from MO to FL. I got Gale’s name through a friend. Very glad to have found her. We looked at homes three times. First time made an offer and rescinded after a poor inspection. Gale was there throughout and so helpful in trying to negotiate. Second was virtually, made an offer that was verbally accepted then declined. On my third trip to the area, Gale had a lot of houses on the list. I was very interested in one and she helped my to put together my best offer and we got the house. Throughout, Gale has been communicative, very easy to reach, very helpful with contacts for all of the needs of someone moving. Super job.

Seller review
Thank you!
almost 3 years ago
Thank you!

Thank you Gale for helping me sell my mother in laws house. We appreciate your time and energy to sell it. It was a bit of a complicated one, but you stuck through it with us!

Seller review
Gale Milgrim embodies the qualities that make a successful realtor
about 3 years ago
Gale Milgrim embodies the qualities that make a successful realtor

Gale Milgrim embodies the qualities necessary to quickly sell your home with the least amount of stress. She is the quintessential realtor who goes the extra mile for both seller and buyer. Gale sets the bar high for other realtors.

Buyer review
First Class Professional
about 3 years ago
First Class Professional

Gale is a first class professional real estate agent. She was a delight to work with when we moved from Portland Oregon, looking for a home in Orlando. She helped us select the right neighborhood and with limited inventory and a challenging market for buyers, guided us in finding the ideal home for our family. We think so highly of her that we referred our close friends whose home she sold in one weekend, at a premium price.

Buyer review
Gale is an EXCELLENT REALTOR!!
about 3 years ago
Gale is an EXCELLENT REALTOR!!

Recently, Gale helped me find the perfect house for an elderly relative of mine who can be difficult. Gale handled the situation beautifully and with professionalism. She stayed with us for an entire day, showing us houses as she found them. We were looking in a very specific area and she found a house in that exact area that was move-in ready, maintenance free and absolutely perfect for my relative. And yes, it took an entire day. I was really impressed with Gale‘s willingness to help us with any issues, including setting up an email account for my elderly relative, scheduling and handling inspection, and generally interacting with my relative in a kind and sincere fashion. She was really willing to do anything and everything we asked—right down to storing my relative’s car in her own garage while waiting for the closing to occur. I really can’t say enough about how pleased I was with Gale‘s handling a challenging buyer. She was just great. Patient and kind and thorough. Thank you, Gale!

Seller review
A real estate agent head and shoulders above the rest.
about 3 years ago
A real estate agent head and shoulders above the rest.

Gale Milgrim is a true professional in the field of real estate. We have used her for both a purchase and sale and our experience for both was great. She knows her market extremely well. She did extensive research to determine the most appropriate price at which to list our home and it was spot on. We had an offer $5,000 over the asking price the same day the house was listed on the MLS. She is very easy to work with and is always available to answer questions and provide assistance. She has an extensive network of service providers for any job big or small. Those referrals saved us a lot of time, since we didn't have to do research to vet providers. We highly recommend using Gale as your agent.

Buyer review
Gale Milgrim...the consummate professional
over 3 years ago
Gale Milgrim...the consummate professional

Once again, Gale Milgrim, has proven to be worth her weight in gold. This was the first time we were purchasing a townhouse under construction. Gale recommended we hire an outside inspector to inspect at strategic times during the process. At first, I didn't think it would be necessary but followed her advice. The inspector found multiple issues that were brought to the developer's attention and fixed. As we were getting closer to closing, the developer's representative was pushing us to close when the unit wasn't completely finished and Gale interceded. She was our advocate and dealt with the aggressive agent. Finally, at walk through, I relaxed because Gale has an eagle eye. She saw marks on the wall that I didn't see and to be honest, could hardly see once they were brought to my attention. She found a chip on the granite kitchen island and other things I would never have noticed. The construction supervisor finally handed her a roll of blue tape and told her to mark all that needed fixing. And she did! We have bought multiple properties with Gale by our side and she makes the process so much easier. Seamless, really. When Gale is your realtor, she is your advocate. I wholeheartedly recommend her.

Buyer review
She's The Best
over 3 years ago
She's The Best

If they gave Oscars for best Real Estate agent Gale would certainly win a few! This is the third time I have worked with her on purchasing and selling homes in Winter Park and she out does herself every time. There are a lot of moving parts during this process and Gale is on top of her game from start to finish. Nothing falls between the cracks on her watch, and she goes above and beyond with my best interest in mind. Gale is very experienced and knows all the ins and outs of the industry. She makes the process painless and palatable, at the same time. No glitches using her and her amazing mortgage lender, too. I strongly recommend her to you and 5-star service it is. So what are you waiting for? Call her up and go buy something!

Seller review
Experience and Professionalism is what you will receive.
over 3 years ago
Experience and Professionalism is what you will receive.

Working with Shari and Gale for our home sale was an extremely easy process. We have bought and sold a few properties over the years and from the first meeting Gale was super responsive, courteous and driven. She has a great understanding of the area and is resourceful when needed. She was honest with our opportunity and provided results. Our listing was presented in an excellent manner and we were able to exceed our projection and plan. We really appreciate Gale's experience in this market and her insight and honesty. I can't reiterate the respect for Gale and the value that she brings to any customer looking to buy or sell in this area. Not only did she meet our schedule but she brought the exposure to our community that is in a very competitive market. We were able to sign a contract a short period of time which is very challenging these days. I would recommend Gale and Shari for any real estate needs you may have.

Buyer review
Gale is AMAZING.
over 3 years ago
Gale is AMAZING.

Gale did an excellent job with my home purchase. She was very attentive and answered all my questions. She was very involved in several issues that arose with my buyer and lender. She provided quick and prompt service, she has a kind demeanor, and has a low pressure style, which I loved. She has an army of contacts that make the home buying experience a breeze. She even assisted with issues that arose in the home after my closing. I would highly recommend her to anyone interested in purchasing a home. I’ll definitely be using her in the future.

Buyer review
Gale is THE BEST realtor I’ve ever worked with!
over 3 years ago
Gale is THE BEST realtor I’ve ever worked with!

Gale is extremely knowledgeable on each house that she showed us during our buying experience. She always showed up prepared and you could tell she definitely did her homework! On top of that, she had the knowledge and willpower to get us into our home in such a competitive market- overcoming many issues along the way. PLUS, she showed up for our inspection to ensure this was a good investment for my husband and I! We both would recommend her to anyone looking to buy today!!

Seller review
Gale Milgrim's Experience & Professionalism Exceeded My Expectations!
almost 4 years ago
Gale Milgrim's Experience & Professionalism Exceeded My Expectations!

Selling my home in an uncertain financial market with rising interest rates looming ahead was unsettling to say the least, but Gale Milgrim handled every detail - from the recommended home price to reviewing the closing documents - with her usual aplomb. Gale's depth of knowledge regarding the Central Florida housing market enabled me to have multiple offers, all over the asking price, in hand within a few days of the listing going active. Ultimately, the final sale price exceeded the listing price by over $31,000! Gale guided me effortlessly through every step of the process: getting the home ready for photos and showings, making small but impactful interior updates, and understanding the contractual details. We were in constant communication, with ongoing updates from her and her responses to questions from me. Gale understands the importance of keeping her clients informed and at ease during one of life's most important transactions. Without question, Gale Milgrim should be your Realtor of choice for selling or buying a home!

37 - 48 of 91
© 2026 RateMyAgent