Michelle's profile

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 200 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Michelle's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, well-prepared, reliable, friendly, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Easiest and Most Pleasant Realestate Experience Ever!!
8 months ago
Easiest and Most Pleasant Realestate Experience Ever!!

We met Michelle a couple of years ago at an open house. We really liked her positive personality and willingness to help her clients. We knew who to call when it came time to sell our house in Green Valley. Michelle goes the extra mile for her clients. We felt so taken care of throughout the entire process. The  photographer Michelle used did an outstanding job - we didn't realize our house was so beautiful. The listing was very well written. The photos and listing were so inviting. Michelle is a very effective communicator and listener. She was there for us anytime and any day of the week. 

Seller review
Knowledgeable, personable and helpful are the descriptors I'd use for Michelle and Andy!!
9 months ago
Knowledgeable, personable and helpful are the descriptors I'd use for Michelle and Andy!!

From the first time we reached out to Michelle we were impressed with her preparedness and willingness to help us. She and Andy came to our home and talked through the process with us. When we were ready to list she hired an excellent photographer to take the pictures, which I feel played a large part in our very quick sale. When our home was listed, a FULL price offer was received within the first 24 hours! I really feel their attention to detail, from the great pictures, to the detailed descriptions of our home, is what made that happen. In our opinion, a home seller or buyer would not go wrong with Michelle and Andy supporting you. Any time we had questions during the process we always received a fast response. For those of you who are not believers in the power of St. Joseph, we can attest to his help. And reading the prayer each day until your sale closes is important. It certainly worked for us! Choosing Michelle and Andy as your realtors and you won't go wrong!

Buyer review
The best!!!
9 months ago
The best!!!

We have purchased and sold many homes and the process has mostly been stressful. Michelle Metcalf made the search and the purchase of our current new home a breeze. She is super knowledgable of all aspects of real estate and is driven to make the entire process flow smoothly. We appreciate everything Michelle has done for us and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to purchase or sell a home. Thank you Michelle!

Seller review
Great agent, made selling easy!
10 months ago
Great agent, made selling easy!

Selling my late mothers home from 2000 miles away wasn't something i was looking forward to. Michelle made the process easy and seamless. I would recommend her to anyone selling(or buying) in the Tucson area!

Seller review
5-Star All The Way!
11 months ago
5-Star All The Way!

Michelle and her partner Andy Anderson are simply “ must use” realtors. Every problem that cropped up was quickly resolved. Andy really went the extra mile. Saying we are “super satisfied” still doesn’t quite describe it. We always felt we were in VERY capable hands. And… our home sold in 3 days!!!

Seller review
We were very satisfied with our choice of Michelle  Metcalf
11 months ago
We were very satisfied with our choice of Michelle Metcalf

We think Michelle is the hardest working agent you could choose. Even though this is a slow market this year, through advertising she managed to draw many people to our open houses, one time 20 couples. She anticipates problems before they happen and tells you how to solve them or sends out reasonable priced knowledgeable technicians to solve them for you. She was always available when you had questions. A great negotiator. We were 100% happy with our pick of Michelle for our realtor.

Seller review
Successful Sale.
11 months ago
Successful Sale.

We were selling in a challenging market. Michelle and Andy did a great job explaining the market and guiding our pricing decisions. Communication was always responsive and any follow-up done promptly. It was a pleasure working with both Michelle and Andy. Although I was hoping for a higher price, where we closed was realistic for the market.

Seller review
Happy with the quick sale
11 months ago
Happy with the quick sale

Michelle did a good job of keeping me informed regarding the sale of my home. I was new to buying and selling real estate and she made it much easier by promptly answering all my questions and found a buyer more quickly than we expected. She and her associate Andy went above and beyond the call of duty to help us make the house as attractive as possible for listing. I want to thank them for their help. Their efforts were very much appreciated.

Seller review
5 Stars - Outstanding Experience with Michelle Metcalf
12 months ago
5 Stars - Outstanding Experience with Michelle Metcalf

Selling a home can be stressful, but working with Michelle Metcalf made the entire process smooth, efficient, and even enjoyable. From our very first conversation, Michelle impressed me with her deep knowledge of the Green Valley market, clear communication, and genuine commitment to helping me achieve the best outcome. She guided me through every step—from pricing and staging to marketing and negotiations—with professionalism and care. Her attention to detail and strategic approach resulted in a quick sale at a great price. Michelle was always available to answer questions, provide updates, and offer honest, thoughtful advice. I truly felt like I had a partner in the process. Beyond her real estate expertise, Michelle is simply a wonderful person—warm, trustworthy, and dedicated. I couldn’t have asked for a better agent, and I would recommend her without hesitation to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Green Valley area. Thank you, Michelle, for going above and beyond!

Seller review
Big help in a unique and challenging market
12 months ago
Big help in a unique and challenging market

Michelle understood the local market well, and she was knowledgeable and responsive in managing the complete sales process.

Buyer review
Competent and Responsive
12 months ago
Competent and Responsive

Michelle was all I could ask for in a RE agent. I had to boot another agent who was obviously of a lesser talent and hiring Michelle to act as my agent made the entire purchase process easy. Michelle has been very good at responding to my questions and I wouldn't hesitate to use her services again.

25 - 36 of 200
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent