Donna's profile

Donna's reviews

  5  
Donna has 159 reviewsacross 45 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Donna's qualities as told by our client reviews: trustworthy, pleasant, supportive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Donna Maicher – The Realtor Who Got It Done (Even When the Other Side Panicked)
8 months ago
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Donna Maicher – The Realtor Who Got It Done (Even When the Other Side Panicked)

If you're looking for a realtor who shows up, smiles, shakes hands, and hopes for the best… keep looking. If you're looking for someone who gets results, keeps it real, and strong-arms deals across the finish line when necessary — then let me introduce you to Donna Maicher. Donna helped sell my mother-in-law’s house and somehow managed to make the process (mostly) painless — no small feat when you're juggling paperwork, emotions, and family group texts. She was always a step ahead, incredibly responsive, and somehow managed to explain every confusing real estate form in plain English, not ancient Realtor-speak. Now for the best part: a few days before closing — A FEW DAYS — the other agent drops the bomb that “the deal might not happen on time.” Oh really? That’s cute. Donna didn’t panic. She didn’t flinch. She put on her metaphorical aviators, walked into the situation like a negotiator in an action movie, and squeezed the other side (politely, but firmly) until the deal did happen on time. Honestly, I don’t know what she said or did — and I’m not sure I want to — but by the end, the house was sold, the papers were signed, and the other side probably needed a nap. Donna is professional, fierce, funny, and exactly who you want handling something as big (and occasionally dramatic) as selling a home. We’d use her again in a heartbeat… although we’re hoping no one else in the family moves anytime soon.

Buyer review
Like working with family
9 months ago
Like working with family

My fiancé and I were referred to Donna by a friend of mine and I couldn't have been more grateful. Donna and her team were so friendly, open, communicative, and a lot of fun to work with. She got to know us as a couple, and in doing so got a feel for what we were both looking for in our future home. Buying a house for the first time can be an overwhelming process, but she made it easy. Donna and her team were always readily available to answer questions and made us feel like we were a top priority. I can't recommend her enough! Thank you for finding us our dream forever home.

Seller review
Highly Recommend for Selling Your Home
9 months ago
Highly Recommend for Selling Your Home

Donna Maicher made selling my mom's house so easy! Great communication, super knowledgeable, and always on top of things. The whole process was smooth and quick, and I felt like I was in good hands the entire time. Thanks to her expertise, the home sold quickly and at a great price. Highly recommend!

Seller review
Donna is terrific!
9 months ago
Donna is terrific!

I highly recommend Donna for either a purchase or a sale! Over the last few years, I have successfully bought a house, then sold a house and now sold another house with her help. Every time it was easy and seamless. She successfully found the buyers for each house. I am glad I worked with Donna and you will be too!

Seller review
Knowledgeable, Helpful, Responsive
9 months ago
Knowledgeable, Helpful, Responsive

Donna helped me work through selling a house through an estate process. I wasn’t local and she made herself available to me when I was in the area. She answered all of my questions in a timely manner and was a great resource for issues that did come up through the process.

Buyer review
Amazing agent!!
10 months ago
Amazing agent!!

Donna was so helpful with helping us purchase our first home. She answered all of our questions and was so knowledgeable. I truly do not know how I would have gone through this process with out her! She made everything so easy!

Seller review
Excellent Realtor
10 months ago
Excellent Realtor

I highly recommend Donna. She is professional, knowledgeable and dedicated. My house was sold in a day!

Buyer review
Love working with Donna!
11 months ago
Love working with Donna!

As always she is on top of everything that needs to get done. Flawless settlement. We wouldn't use anyone else.

Buyer review
Best Realtor
11 months ago
Best Realtor

We have known Fonna for many years and have bought and sold several houses with her help. She is pleasant, helpful and responsive. I would highly recommend her to anyone

Buyer review
Highly recommend Donna
11 months ago
Highly recommend Donna

It was a pleasure to work with Donna to find my new home. Donna is responsive, knowledgeable and understands the market. More importantly, it is simply fun to work with her. I cannot say enough good things about my experience. If I buy or sell property in the future, Donna will be my agent!

Seller review
Exceptional service from an outstanding realtor!
11 months ago
Exceptional service from an outstanding realtor!

Donna is honest, knowledgeable, professional and genuinely passionate about helping her clients. Her attention to detail, responsiveness and understanding of the market made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Donna took the time to understand exactly what we needed, offer honest advice, and went above and beyond to ensure that we got the best offer. If you’re looking for a realtor who’s experienced, trustworthy, and genuinely cares, I couldn’t recommend Donna enough! As long as Donna is doing real estate I would never use anyone else!

Seller review
First time selling a house, great experience
11 months ago
First time selling a house, great experience

We felt quite comfortable and confident with Donna from the first time meeting her.Very professional.Her personality shines with positivity.Questions answered almost immediately and she made the transition go smoothly.We highly recommend Donna.

13 - 24 of 159
© 2026 RateMyAgent