Don's profile

Don's reviews

  5  
Don has 171 reviewsacross 34 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Don's qualities as told by our client reviews: local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent Understanding of the Market
18 days ago
Excellent Understanding of the Market

Don and Cyndi were a great help in selling our home in Beavercreek. They listened to us and helped us determine the best approach in selling. They answered all of our questions quickly. The process was very smooth from start to finish. We would highly recommend them.

Buyer review
An excellent realtor and experience
24 days ago
An excellent realtor and experience

Don was always very responsive when we had questions or found a house we wanted to see. He is very knowledgeable and professional, and helped us understand many aspects of our home buying process. We definitely highly recommend Don as a realtor!

Seller review
Thorough, knowledgeable, and no surprises!
2 months ago
Thorough, knowledgeable, and no surprises!

Don Shurts was excellent to work with when selling my home. From the start, he set up a detailed pre-listing meeting that helped me understand the entire process and feel confident moving forward. His knowledge of the market and selling strategy was very clear, and he took the time to answer every question I had. Don kept me updated throughout the process and made sure I always knew what was happening next. Thanks to his preparation and guidance, the home sold the very first day it was listed. I would absolutely recommend Don to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and dependable realtor.

Buyer review
Highly Recommended
3 months ago
Highly Recommended

Don is amazing and helps work to find the right house for you. Very easy to work with and helps narrow down houses that fit your needs and doesn't try to push you into a place that you don't like. Highly recommend Don to anyone needing a realtor.

Seller review
Amazing Experience selling our home
3 months ago
Amazing Experience selling our home

I highly recommend Don and Cindy! From our initial conversation straight through to the sell of our home, Don walked us through each step and kept in communication with us. He continued to work with the buyers agent through the offer process and help finalize their inspection to determine what should be repaired. If you are looking for a very experienced agent who walks with God and has a calm but effective demeanor, Don or Cindy is an agent you can depend upon.

Buyer review
Exceeded All Expectations (legitimately 6-star quality)
4 months ago
Exceeded All Expectations (legitimately 6-star quality)

This was our first time in the home-buying arena. Don answered every question we had. He talked through a great MANY items for which to pay attention when walking through a home. He talked comparisons between homes when looking at multiple in the same day. He talked through factual property details and provided his own objective point of view for questions/concerns we had. At the end of every day looking at homes, I never felt lost or conflicted about a decision for any home he showed us. During business hours, he responded to texts/emails quickly; he did so even outside of normal hours. He was very professional, even to the point of not allowing distractions when we were out looking inside homes he recommended. I'm glad my wife started our home buying process with Don and I don't think it was luck that he turned out to be as great through the entire process as he was; he's worth a 6th star even if this review site caps at 5. I'm recommending him to all my friends and colleagues getting into the market to buy.

Seller review
Very good experience with Don
4 months ago
Very good experience with Don

Don was very professional and did a great job generating lots of viewings of our house. The digital advertising he did seemed to be very effective as we had a high quantity of viewings. It took a while to sell our house because we probably set the price at too high a point to begin the process. That's why I have this as 4 instead of 5 stars. My only critique is that we would have appreciated a bit more push back on our coming in position on price. Aside from this critique, Don was great with communication and being open with us when we needed to reduce the price of the listing. He was great working with us through the negotiation phase, which was complicated by some big asks from the buyers after inspection. I would definitely recommend Don to someone looking to sell their house.

Seller review
Excellent experience with sale of home
5 months ago
Excellent experience with sale of home

Cyndi was professional and easy to work with. She was sensitive to our needs and knowledgeable of local market values and interest. She sold our historic home in one day at full asking price, and provided wise advice as we navigated post-inspection negotiations. We highly recommend Cyndi!

Buyer review
Great experience for first time home buyer
6 months ago
Great experience for first time home buyer

Don was a great help in buying my first property. As a first time home buyer and a relatively new inhabitant of Dayton, Don helped me guide my search to the areas and types of properties that interested me. With Dons help, inspections and repairs went smoothly and I got the house I wanted in good shape and for a good price. He was willing to tour on weekends, sometimes multiple houses a day, and on short notice. I would recommend.

Buyer review
Great knowledge and professionalism
6 months ago
Great knowledge and professionalism

Working with Don to sell and buy made the whole process seamless. He was able to advocate for our needs on multiple occasions for things we didnt realize until later would matter as much as they did. He is absolutely a seasoned professional in the buying and selling process. Don was also able to provide valuable insight into the mortgage loan process being a mortgage broker himself. If you want your house sold or to buy a new home with someone who has a wealth of knowledge and experience, you can't go wrong with using Don and Cyndi Shurts!

Seller review
Forever Home.... Again!!
6 months ago
Forever Home.... Again!!

Don has been our realtor for many life changes, and his experience and advice have helped us sell three homes and buy three homes in the past decade. Our growing family and changing needs have always been a priority for Don as he has helped buy and sell homes. Our most recent sale of our home was challenging due to the ever-changing market, but Don kept us grounded, addressed any needs or questions, provided suggestions on how we could improve our property, and worked tirelessly to find a buyer. We had a unique property that was in the wilderness and needed the right buyers. Don promoted our property in many markets/digital avenues, finding the right buyer for the sale of our home. As our sale went on, Don shared market analytics and feedback from potential buyers in weekly calls. These calls or feedback sessions reassured us that he was the "Man for the Job...Again"!!! We hope we have found our "Forever Home", but if the time comes again to find another property/home, we will make sure that our sign out front has Don's Name on it!

1 - 12 of 171
© 2026 RateMyAgent