Deborah's profile

Deborah's reviews

  5  
Deborah has 157 reviewsacross 46 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Deborah's qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, honest, friendly, clear communication, supportive, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Deborah helped me sell my moms home in Scotch Plains.
over 7 years ago
Deborah helped me sell my moms home in Scotch Plains.

I’ve interviewed at least 2 dozen realtors to sell my mom's house. All were wonderful, seasoned professionals, but Deborah rose to the top of my choices based on her personality, knowledge, and strive to do what is needed to get the job done. Being from out of state, Deborah always took the reins and took care of any situation that arose, from helping me pull up carpets to scrubbing floors at 9:00 at night to raking mud in the back yard after a disaster septic tank removal mess. I had the Buyers from Hell, and Deborah, no matter what time of day or where she was, always answered my call or returned my text. I’ve laughed with her and cried to her...She many times, talked me “off the ledge” and gave me the strength to push through. She was my “Rock”. She’s knowledgeable, energetic, professional, and does what it takes to get the job done. With her smiling face and bubbly personality, She’s not afraid to talk to people to get answers and fix what needs to be fixed. Obviously, I can’t talk highly enough about her. Without hesitation, hands down, Deborah is the BEST out there. Not only did I find a great realtor, but I also found a new friend. ??

Seller review
#1 across the board
over 7 years ago
#1 across the board

I’ve interviewed at least 2 dozen realtors to sell my mom's house. All were wonderful, seasoned professionals, but Deborah rose to the top of my choices based on her personality, knowledge, and strive to do what is needed to get the job done. Being from out of state, Deborah always took the reins and took care of any situation that arose, from helping me pull up carpets to scrubbing floors at 9:00 at night to raking mud in the back yard after a disaster septic tank removal mess. I had the Buyers from Hell, and Deborah, no matter what time of day or where she was, always answered my call or returned my text. I’ve laughed with her and cried to her...She many times, talked me “off the ledge” and gave me the strength to push through. She was my “Rock”. She’s knowledgeable, energetic, professional and does what it takes to get the job done. With her smiling face and bubbly personality, She’s not afraid to talk to people to get answers and fix what needs to be fixed. Obviously, I can’t talk highly enough about her. Without hesitation, hands down, Deborah is the BEST out there. Not only did I find a great realtor, but I also found a new friend.

Buyer review
Deborah is an amazing person to work with!
over 8 years ago
Deborah is an amazing person to work with!

Deborah is an amazing person to work with! She’s so professional and available to help you at any given time. She goes out of her way to make sure you get everything you need to make the transition as smooth as possible.

Buyer review
In my life I have bought and sold numerous houses for my employer and I have dealt with many realtor
almost 9 years ago
In my life I have bought and sold numerous houses for my employer and I have dealt with many realtor

In my life I have bought and sold numerous houses for my employer and I have dealt with many realtors, but none compares to the service and results Debbie provided. From the point when we decided to sell our personal home and Debbie told me what she could sell it for (much more than we thought), to the advice as to what improvements we should make to maximize the sale price, to guiding us to reputable contractors, to solving emergencies, to getting the listing posted, to getting an offer for the full asking price in 13 days, Debbie never failed to exceed our expectations. n nAs Christians, my wife and I rely on the Lord to guide us and He guided us to Debbie. We can't say enough about Debbie's integrity and professionalism! n nIf you need a realtor - call Debbie, you will not be disappointed!

Buyer review
Deborah makes the experience easy and not stressful at all
almost 9 years ago
Deborah makes the experience easy and not stressful at all

Deborah makes the experience easy and not stressful at all. We bought our new home with Deborah and are now renting our previous house. She is a master negotiator and will check out every nook and cranny of the house (even things I wouldn't think of to look at.) she is very honest, professional and always puts her clients first. I would highly recommend her and will be using Deborah in the future for all our real estate needs.

Buyer review
I could not be happier that I met Deborah Citarella
almost 11 years ago
I could not be happier that I met Deborah Citarella

I could not be happier that I met Deborah Citarella. I was a first time home-buyer and Deborah was ready and willing to help me every step of the way, no matter how small my issue was. I have complete faith in her opinions, as she clearly just wants to make sure that the homeowner is getting exactly what they want. For anyone who is looking for a realtor, please, look no further!

Buyer review
Deborah is an amazingly patient and enthusiastic real estate agent
almost 11 years ago
Deborah is an amazingly patient and enthusiastic real estate agent

Deborah is an amazingly patient and enthusiastic real estate agent. She had a very good idea what we were looking for right from the start. And she was relentless at helping us find it. But her best attribute was her want for us to be happy. She made sure her team inspected the home from top to bottom to make sure that nothing would make us regret our purchase. And I must say we couldn't be happier.

Seller review
I can honestly say that Deborah Citarella is one of most caring and honorable professionals I have d
almost 11 years ago
I can honestly say that Deborah Citarella is one of most caring and honorable professionals I have d

I can honestly say that Deborah Citarella is one of most caring and honorable professionals I have dealt with. She is passionate about her work, and goes above and beyond to ensure the best outcome for her clients. I have found her advice and guidance invaluable in purchasing my new house, making improvements to it, and getting my previous home ready to sell, which I'm listing with her of corse. I highly recommend Deborah!

Seller review
Deborah Citarella is the best of the best! What more is there to say? She helped me in all aspects o
about 11 years ago
Deborah Citarella is the best of the best! What more is there to say? She helped me in all aspects o

Deborah Citarella is the best of the best! What more is there to say? She helped me in all aspects of selling my home, from the very first moments of my thinking about it, on to cleaning out the house, making improvements in the house to enhance its value, and then sold it for me, and all the while communicating with me every step of the way, after I had moved cross country. All this, and she's a wonderful person, too!

Seller review
I have rarely met a person with such love for what they do
about 11 years ago
I have rarely met a person with such love for what they do

I have rarely met a person with such love for what they do. Deborah has been a straight shooter from our first meeting. You may not like what she says ( like what we the seller thinks our house is worth) but she explains why and backs it up with documents. I had an agent before Deborah that at the end of that contract I was not going to use another agent and sell on my own. I was lucky enough to be introduced to Deborah by a friend and I couldn't be happier.

Buyer review
Deborah was incredibly patient and supportive in our entire home buying process
about 11 years ago
Deborah was incredibly patient and supportive in our entire home buying process

Deborah was incredibly patient and supportive in our entire home buying process. As 1st time home buyers, we dragged her out almost every weekend for months to show us houses and every time, she met us with a smile, excited to find us the right home. We never felt like she was trying to sell to us or push us on a house- she kept us armed with information we needed to know and helped us come to our own decision on what was right. She really took the time to get to know my husband and I and ended up finding us our dream home even before it hit the market!! She KNEW we were going to love it and she was right. Deborah TRULY cares about her clients and will dedicate as much time as needed to ensure we find the right home!

Buyer review
Deborah is an outstanding realtor!  For anyone buying a home I can not recommend her strongly enough
about 11 years ago
Deborah is an outstanding realtor! For anyone buying a home I can not recommend her strongly enough

Deborah is an outstanding realtor! For anyone buying a home I can not recommend her strongly enough! Deborah knows the market well and has a high level of expertise about home structures. She is honest, friendly, and dependable. No level of detail or concern was too small for her, and she was in our corner through the whole buying process. Thanks to Deborah we found just the right home for our family.

145 - 156 of 157
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent