Deborah's profile

Deborah's reviews

  5  
Deborah has 157 reviewsacross 46 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Deborah's qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, honest, friendly, clear communication, supportive, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Debbie was a pleasure to work with - very responsive & knowledgeable
over 5 years ago
Debbie was a pleasure to work with - very responsive & knowledgeable

Debbie was a pleasure to work with - very responsive, knowledgeable, and familiar with the area. She was relentless in searching for us, and was always accessible, which we really appreciated. She also gave us great counsel - lots of pro tips. We love our home and our neighborhood. Thanks Debbie!

Seller review
Deborah went above and beyond
over 5 years ago
Deborah went above and beyond

We had initially engaged with another Realtor, the guy who is guaranteed to sell your home or they buy it....what a mess. Deborah was recommended to us and after a thorough evaluation of our home, couple of Open Houses it was sold in a short time at a reasonable price. We also had a very odd issue where a previous mortgage pays off was not recorded with the county, almost 20 years ago, what a mess, Deborah went above and beyond to assist in getting it cleared.

Seller review
Extremely knowledgeable, great to work with
over 5 years ago
Extremely knowledgeable, great to work with

Deborah helped me sell my father’s home in Scotch Plains. She helped us through every stage - prepping the home to sell, closing out permits, pricing, and so much more. If you are looking for a knowledgeable, supportive agent who can help you navigate the process of selling your home, I highly recommend Deborah.

Buyer review
Agent who puts your needs first
over 5 years ago
Agent who puts your needs first

Deborah helped our family purchase a home in Scotch Plains. She is clearly very knowledgeable of the town and put our best interests in mind through the home search process. Helped negotiate the best price possible for us and we are very happy. HIGHLY recommend.

Seller review
Compitent and Helpful
over 5 years ago
Compitent and Helpful

We were very pleased with the handling of our house sale process. The knowledge and information they provided gave us confidence.

Buyer review
Deborah helped me realize the true value of a good realtor.
over 5 years ago
Deborah helped me realize the true value of a good realtor.

I hear it is a familiar story – we weren’t really looking to move, but we were just checking out some Open House on a few Sundays. It was mostly just for fun to check-out different homes. Most of the realtors at the Open Houses were very “pushy / salesy”. Then one Sunday, we met Deborah at an Open House that she was hosting for a fellow realtor. We connected right away with Deborah. It’s hard to explain, but she is just one of those people with really good energy. We started working with Deborah the following week as we placed an offer on the Open House home that she was hosting. I could literally write a book about the challenges we encountered over the four months from June – September 2017. We had buyers pull-out, sellers pull-out, comical inspection requests (including a request to fix a doorbell that worked intermittently), issues with lawyer responsiveness, issues with buyers mortgage, and on and on. (There was a time when I considered FSBO, but Deborah helped me realize the true value of a good realtor. ) Throughout the ENTIRE process, Deborah was a rock star. Every challenge, she would hit head on and take ownership to get resolved. Even issues that weren’t her responsibility, she would chase down whomever needed to be contacted and drive the issues to resolution. Deborah is ALWAYS available and responsive to our needs. We had text/calls with her as early as 730am and as late as 11 pm. In July, Deborah had a family vacation planned to Hawaii. I felt guilty but amazed at how responsive Deborah was, even in Hawaii. She joined calls and responded to emails at 4am her time (she insisted she couldn’t sleep anyway). Deborah is also a great baker – make sure you ask her for a batch of her homemade cookies! If you are looking for an experienced, passionate realtor with endless energy & unmatched responsiveness, look no further! Deborah Citeralla was absolutely amazing throughout the process of selling and buying a home in Westfield in NJ.

Buyer review
AMAZING EXPERIENCE!
over 5 years ago
AMAZING EXPERIENCE!

AMAZING EXPERIENCE! Do not even think twice about using Deb - I used her summer 2018 to purchase a home and sell a home, and couldn't have been happier with her. She's completely hands-on, knowledgeable, friendly, and puts her clients 1st. She is collaborative with attorneys, inspectors, and anyone else involved. But what sets her apart is how much she goes above and beyond for her clients. There's so many stories of times Deb came to my rescue -friends and family couldn't believe everything she did for us. Truly the best there is.

Seller review
A wonderful experience!
over 5 years ago
A wonderful experience!

Deborah was my dream realtor. She was honest and always available! She told me that my house would sell in two days and it did and over asking price! If anything came up, she handled it. Selling my house was a wonderful experience.

Buyer review
Deborah is an amazing realtor
over 5 years ago
Deborah is an amazing realtor

Deborah is an amazing realtor. She made our first home buying experience such a pleasure. No matter how many questions we asked she always had a kind response or could refer us to someone else that could help even better. Deborah is very honest, caring, and reliable. If we ever need a realtor again she will be our first call. I can't recommend her highly enough.

97 - 108 of 157
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent