CINDY's profile

CINDY's reviews

  5  
CINDY has 23 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Cindy and her assistant Charis were a joy to work with!

Cindy and Charis exceeded our very high expectations and were with us every step of the way. Our experience included rapid responses to our inquiries, clear expectations set, and the vast majority of milestones met. The few milestone that were missed were professionally explained in advance. I would definitely recommend them to friends and family!

over 3 years ago
Great experience, highly ethical and seasoned team.

From my experience I assume it would be hard to find a better agent in Steamboat than Cindy MacGray. What won our family over was three items. Cindy is very action oriented and has great follow through. We were in a situation where we wanted to move fast and she was constancy available and working for us. Cindy is well connected and has an deep understanding of the community. If you are new to town her insights and connections are really helpful. Most importantly, the level of integrity Cindy and her team provided was exceptional. That is something one can take for granted until it matters. We had a situation where and her team had to help us through a hard decision. The level of support we received far exceeded expectations. I have trust and first hand experience Cindy will do what’s right and help you and your family find a great property.

over 3 years ago
Always Available!

My wife and I were very happy with the service that Cindy and Charis provided us with our recent home sale and move to Steamboat! They were always available to ask questions and seek advice. I recommend them to help you with your future purchase or sale!

over 3 years ago
Experienced professionals

Cindy is an experienced real estate professional with a lot of connections and relationships within Steamboat. Cindy is very responsive and was always willing to support us with various items throughout the process which was great as we are no longer living in the area. Cindy helped us navigate multiple offers and helped keep the deal going despite some unforeseen hiccups along the way.

over 3 years ago
Great Experience, Smooth Transaction

Cindy was patient while we looked for the right one. She listened to what I wanted and showed me a few options across a limited scope to get a better idea of how I reacted to each. Once we had that dialed in, she wasn't pushing me above or below my needs and wants. More importantly, she was NOT a yes man. If she thought the property was priced too high or too low, she let me know. If she thought my offer was off, she pushed hard against me to not waste everyone's time with bidding wars. She set reasonable expectations and over delivered. Very few agents/brokers excel at that. Sometimes you walk away feeling like it was a bit of a bait and switch and I never felt that even remotely with Cindy. As we came up on the Due Diligence/Option period expiration she reminded me that I was NOT obligated to follow through with the transaction if I wasn't feeling it. Good and gentle nudges at the right times. Truly a great experience and a lot of fun to work with.

over 3 years ago
Terrific Experience

Cindy was a pleasure to work with. Her knowledge of the market and attention to detail helped us set a price and present our property in the best light. We were kept appraised of every showing and a summary of the potential buyers thoughts. We also were informed of how many views the property was getting on line and from where the world it was being viewed. We gravely benefited from Cindy and her teams support. Thank you!

over 3 years ago
Outstanding from start to after finish

As other reviewers have said, Cindy is very knowledgable and professional. Additionally she is a good listener and provides terrific service. As a consequence I always felt that Cindy wanted to do what was best for me -- not just to make a sale. This was a long distance sale and she was quite flexible and answered my many questions. After the sale she even called one of my new neighbors to welcome me to Steamboat! Cindy is clearly "Steamboat nice."

almost 4 years ago
One of the Best Real Estate Agents I've Worked With...Anywhere!

Cindy is warm, enthusiastic without being pushy, and a wealth of knowledge about Steamboat Springs and the greater Routt County area. She served as the transaction-broker in our 2022 purchase of land, and did a phenomenal job facilitating a smooth transaction process, answering questions, walking us through the process, and keeping us on track with deadlines. And then post-sale, she has been instrumental in helping to introduce us to the community. Highly recommend Cindy (and Charis) to anyone looking to buy or sell in and around Steamboat Springs.

almost 4 years ago
Professional, Experienced, Knowledgeable

Cindy was a pleasure to work with. She made the process of selling our home efficient and simple. I truly enjoyed working with her and Charis.

about 4 years ago
Couldn’t have had a better experience

Cindy was incredibly patient with us. We started looking for land in Steamboat in mid 2018. Here we are in 2022 and we finally bought the “perfect” property. Not only did she stick with us through over the years, she was diligent about sending over listings that met our needs and would follow up on a regular basis. We couldn’t have had a better experience. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to purchase a property in Steamboat.

about 4 years ago
Knowledgeable & Timely

Cindy is extremely knowledgeable about real estate sales in Steamboat Springs. She gave us advice pre-sale on home improvements that would help sell and add value. She provided comps to set price and communicated in a timely manner throughout the sale and close process. Our listing had multiple viewings and offers that helped navigate and explain.

over 4 years ago
Experienced and professional

Cindy and her team are very attentive to her clients' needs. We appreciated her timeliness, honesty, no-nonsense attitude and professionalism. Cindy helped us purchase a townhouse 4 years previously, purchase our current home and sell that townhouse, and we will definitely use her services again. We highly recommend Cindy.

1 - 12 of 23
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent