Cindy's profile

Cindy's reviews

  5  
Cindy has 54 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Went very smoothly
over 3 years ago
Went very smoothly

Cindy did a very good job

Buyer review
Highly recommend Cindy!
over 3 years ago
Highly recommend Cindy!

Cindy was amazing to work with. She cared a lot about what we needed and wanted in a home and was ALWAYS readily available for all of our questions! She gave us her real opinion on things and was a huge help when we were unsure. Thank you so much for your great service and friendship through buying our first home!

Seller review
Cindy did a great job handling the sale of our home.
over 3 years ago
Cindy did a great job handling the sale of our home.

Cindy did a great job handling the sale of our home. She knows the area well and is very knowledgeable with the sales and homes in the area. She was quick to respond to all of our questions and gave us good guidance throughout the process. She moved quickly to get our home sold fast. She is a great realtor and we recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell. She walked us through the process and helped us understand all of the steps to sell our home. Selling a home can be stressful, especially the first time, but Cindy had everything under control and made sure everything was taken care of.

Seller review
Working on the Golden years...
over 3 years ago
Working on the Golden years...

We can't say enough about Cindy Gustwiller! She has been our "go-to" realtor for 6 years with our previous home to the sale of our farm ground recently. We had to "downsize" our life due to medical issues and Cindy was with us every step of the way! She spent "endless time" doing what's best for us listing our old home, helping us buy our smaller home, to selling our farm ground 5 1/2 years later. Between emails, texts & calls throughout these dealings, we were always informed and advised professionally by Cindy. She definitely was one our "best investments" in life...

Seller review
Wonderful experience
over 3 years ago
Wonderful experience

Cindy was on top of everything. She was adaptable to our suggestions and gave us helpful hints. We called her several times and she was always courteous. Cindy was knowledgeable, organized and professional.. If she didn’t know the answer to our questions, she researched for the answers and diligently called us back. She advertised in multiple listing, real estate magazines and had open houses. Cindy made the process smooth from listing to closing. Thank you Cindy.

Seller review
Excellent Realtor
over 3 years ago
Excellent Realtor

Cindy was very knowledgeable about the current market. She was willing to hear our thoughts and ideas and respected us and our property. This is the second time we have worked with her and we would chose to work with her again.

Seller review
Another GREAT home-selling experience with Cindy!
over 3 years ago
Another GREAT home-selling experience with Cindy!

This is the second home Cindy Gustwiller has helped me sell. She has also helped me with home purchases. Cindy is professional and personable. She works hard to help the process move along quickly and smoothly and has a great understanding of the local markets. I highly recommend selecting Cindy to help with your real estate needs!

Seller review
Cindy is awesome 👌
over 3 years ago
Cindy is awesome 👌

Cindy was excellent as usual. She made the process very simple for us and took a lot of stress away. Thanks Cindy!

Seller review
Great experience!
over 3 years ago
Great experience!

Cindy got our house on the market quickly with lots of photos. This allowed us to sell it quickly. She scheduled many showings and advocated for a closing date in our benefit.

Buyer review
Very knowledgeable
over 3 years ago
Very knowledgeable

Cindy is very knowledgeable and helpful. She give great advice and communicated well between buyer and seller

Seller review
Selling Our Home
over 3 years ago
Selling Our Home

We asked Cindy Gustwiller to help us sell our home because we knew her as both a friend and as a successful real estate agent in our community. Cindy understands well the real estate market in Archbold and in the surrounding area. When called or emailed, Cindy always responded quickly to our questions or concerns. The pictures of our home looked great, too. Cindy is a very trustworthy agent, always having our best interests in mind.

Seller review
Excellent
over 3 years ago
Excellent

Cindy goes above and biting for her clients. I knew selling our house would be stressful, but Cindy made sure to work endlessly to do anything and everything in order for us to feel less stressed! We can’t thank her enough!!

37 - 48 of 54
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent