Cindy's profile

Cindy's reviews

  5  
Cindy has 54 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Cindy is great to work with!!
over 2 years ago
Cindy is great to work with!!

Cindy is great to work with. She is knowledgeable about the market and cares about her clients.

Buyer review
Cindy Gustwiller - an agent who treats you like family
almost 3 years ago
Cindy Gustwiller - an agent who treats you like family

Cindy is an exceptional agent. She stuck by me throughout the entire process. She offered honest and helpful advice which helped me to make a purchase that I felt good about. Cindy made herself available at anytime of the day or night, as well as working when she was out of town. She is a committed agent and I look forward to working with her on my next purchase.

Seller review
Cindy will do a great job.
almost 3 years ago
Cindy will do a great job.

Ten years ago, Cindy helped me buy my house and did a great job. Guided me through everything step by step. So it was an easy decision to work with her again when it was time to sell. She cam to our initial meeting armed with all sorts of comparable sales and helped set a price. She helped sort through the offers and made sure we got the best offers from the most qualified buyers. She took me through all the steps, inspection and appraisal and kept me informed the whole way even when the buyers had some unexpected delays.

Buyer review
Excellent!!!!
almost 3 years ago
Excellent!!!!

Our experience with Cindy was incredible. She answered every question, gave us honest input and overall was just an enjoyable person to work with. We needed a realtor and ended up with a friend. We can’t thank Cindy enough for helping us find our first home! I recommend her to anyone and everyone !

Seller review
Top Performing Agent
almost 3 years ago
Top Performing Agent

One of the best I have used in over 30 years. Excellent market knowledge. She went well above and beyond my expectations with her services.

Buyer review
The KEY to your new home
about 3 years ago
The KEY to your new home

When our family was first exploring relocating to Archbold area we contacted KEY Realty. Cindy met with us and helped us identify a couple of homes in the area in our price range. She helped us find the right home and even negotiated an early occupation option. This allowed us to move in and begin acclimating to the area while we worked to complete the sale of our previous home. Cindy helped navigate the paperwork and kept us appraised as we moved forward. Cindy was a pleasure to work with. Thanks

Buyer review
Don’t go with anyone else!
about 3 years ago
Don’t go with anyone else!

Cindy made the home-buying process so smooth for us as new homebuyers. She always answered our questions promptly and was quick to communicate updates to us. We trusted her opinion - which ultimately led us to our first home!

Buyer review
Great agent
about 3 years ago
Great agent

Would recommend her.

Seller review
Would pick her every time
about 3 years ago
Would pick her every time

Her communication was amazing. No matter how early or late I reached out she responded almost immediately. Choosing Cindy as your realtor gives you an advantage with selling or buying a home

Seller review
Great experience
about 3 years ago
Great experience

Cindy was there for us every step of the way

25 - 36 of 54
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent