Catherine Fagan

Catherine Fagan

Broker / Buyer's Agent / REALTOR® at Keller Williams - La Jolla
DRE: 01210747
  •   5   (16 reviews)

About Catherine

Cat's Story DRE #01210747 Catherine has been helping families achieve their real estate goals for over 25 years here in San Diego. She started working exclusively with buyers in 1996 as a “Buyer’s Specialist” in the Mission Valley Prudential office; her 3rd year as a realtor, she had represented over 62 buyers in 1999! Helping her clients buy and sell and now even keep their properties as rentals as the market continues to change is what Catherine loves to do, and she does it well. She prides herself on her sharp negotiating skills and keen knowledge of our beautiful San Diego county, specializing in Solana Beach, RSF and Del Mar but also an expert in the whole county. From Otay to Oceanside, Valley Center to Mission Valley, Coronado to Kensington, Catherine can help you buy or sell in these areas so that when past clients call with questions about their next move, Catherine is ready, willing and able to help them make smart investments and determine the best route for them to take in finding their step-up or move-down homes. Constantly on the cutting-edge of technology so that she can provide her busy clients a streamlined, stress-free experience, Catherine surrounds herself with a team of hard working and ethical agents who support her service and education goals for her clients. The Mercer Real Estate Group at the Luxury KW Real Estate office achieves just that: top notch service by way of internet savvy, technology savvy marketing but still with personalized care and attention to detail by the same girl you hired years ago! So it’s the best of both worlds: Cat teamed up w local area expert Patrick Mercer so that they can help all buyers and sellers here in “America’s Finest City!” Their clients benefit from hand holding service like that from yesteryear streamlined with all the “bells and whistles” of the 21st century!! Call Cat to talk more about how she can help you acheive your real etate goals here in "America's Finest City!" #GodBlessAmerica

Catherine's reviews

  5  
Catherine has 16 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 6.
Review Catherine
almost 4 years ago
Catherine got the job done.

Catherine knows the market and provided appropriate advice. She worked with the buyers to keep them in the negotiations. In the end we got the best price possible.

about 4 years ago
Extremely Responsive and Helpful Agent

I was fortunate to work with Catherine on a condo purchase in February 2022. Catherine was fantastic to work with. I really appreciated her energy level, she was very communicative, promptly answered my emails and texts and was always able to make a showing happen on my busy schedule. We ran into a snag with the sellers not following through on a few things and Catherine was on it each step of the way. She advocated for me to make sure I was getting what I was supposed to while also making sure I was aware of what all my options were at each point. In the end, we were able to get it done and Catherine made sure I was satisfied even after the sale closed. I have worked with multiple real estate agents over the years and Catherine is one of the few that I will be very happy to work with again in the future!

about 4 years ago
The Very Best!!!

Catherine is the very best! She kept in contact with me for over a year and never gave up. When it was finally time to make a move she really pushed to getting it done, making my dream of having my own place come true. I am really glad that I found her on Zillow. I will definitely work with her again if the opportunity for buying a home happens again. Thank you 😊!!!

over 4 years ago
Excellent muy bueno

Catherine was very knowledgeable of the market. Very easy to get a hold of and work with. Will definitely be using her services again.

over 4 years ago
Excellance througout.

Catherine has been my Real Estate agent since 2000. That alone should tell you everything, we have done over the last 21 years 9 transactions both personal residence and investment properties. Every transaction was flawless. I would highly recommend for Catherine for your next real estate transaction.

over 4 years ago
Amazing Grace under pressure I have been impressed with Catherine's ability to deal with multiple is

Amazing Grace under pressure I have been impressed with Catherine's ability to deal with multiple issues with clarity and quick response under very stressful circumstances. She has been a blessing for me during my journey of exploring the real estate market in San Diego and very helpful in bringing about purchase of property. She has been a delight to work with and I recommend her as one of the best brokers I have worked with so far -hard working ,available and pleasant .

Show all 16 reviews

Catherine's properties

Catherine has 4 properties for sale and sold 14 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldApr 17, 2026
$400,000
134/3535 Madison Ave
San Diego CA 92116
1
1
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of Compass and Keller Williams - La Jolla
For Sale
$1,099,000
4087 Normal St
San Diego CA 92103
3
3
3
Townhouse
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams - La Jolla
SoldApr 14, 2026
$978,800
4348 Aragon Way
San Diego CA 92115
3
1
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Real Blue Properties and Keller Williams - La Jolla
SoldApr 6, 2026
$1,375,000
4448 Felton Street
San Diego CA 92116
3
2
5
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Compass and Keller Williams - La Jolla
Show all 18 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent