Caitlin's profile

Caitlin's reviews

  5  
Caitlin has 7 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 7.
7 months ago
10 Stars if I could!

Considering our short timeline due to a health emergency, Caitlin went above and beyond to support and facilitate the process through to the sale. She is professional, knowledgeable, intuitive and intelligent. I trusted her judgment on several issues and was never disappointed. As a former Realtor myself, I can say with 100% certainty, Caitlin is an outstanding and affective agent plus negotiator. I would definitely recommend her to anyone buying or selling real estate!

over 1 year ago
Fantastic partner in the sales process

Caitlin was great to have in my corner of the sales process. She fought for me every step of the way and made sure I was protected legally. She will definitely be my realtor on everything I buy and sell.

almost 2 years ago
The agent you want & need!

Don’t even think twice. Caitlin has represented us in selling our investment property and our residential property — and we only wished she was also licensed out of state to help us with ALL our real estate transactions. If you want someone who goes above and beyond, who tells it to you straight, providing the potential pros and cons of each decision, while offering her best advice and ultimately leaving the choice up to you…then doing everything in her power to make the best possible deal on your behalf…you want Caitlin Montoya. You’ll never wonder if she’s working hard for your best interests. She expertly and unflinchingly navigates tough negotiations. Caitlin is a cut above any agent we’ve ever had, and we’ve moved a lot. Don’t hesitate. Call Caitlin and see what she can do for you!

almost 3 years ago
In 25 years of buying and selling property, Caitlin is the most qualified we've used.

Ada County Idaho is in a difficult spot for real estate. The dramatic increase in interest rates have been hard on property values. We purchased a unit near the top of the market. When it came time to sell we were concerned about the potential for a loss resulting from a lower sales price than what we paid. In hot real estate markets it is easy for any agent to turn a profit for the seller. In depressed markets only the skilled realtors can come through for their seller. Caitlin does that. She has an amazing breadth of knowledge, is highly intelligent, has an amazing work ethic, and was able to guide us through the process. Ultimately we were able to sell the property for an excellent price! We will use her for our transactions moving forward!

about 3 years ago
Fantastic, timely, knowledgeable with mission accomplished.

Caitlin had shown us several homes that allowed her to see what we were looking for. Each home we looked at appeared to get closer to what we wanted. The home we purchased had only gone the market that morning and she contacted us early in the day. We made a morning appointment to see the property and after we conferred with each other, made an offer that afternoon at the listed price. The seller decided to sell pending inspection results. There were a few things that needed attention and Caitlin was able to negotiate a discount equal to one half of the carpet replacement. Things went very smooth with our financing and Caitlin walked us through all the step we needed to complete the transaction. Would do it again!!

over 4 years ago
Best Agent

Caitlin provided me with the best experience of buying a home. Caitlin took the time to understand what I was looking for and what my budget was, not showing me homes I could not afford. Caitlin worked on my behalf from the start to the signing at closing and getting the keys, she was there for me every step of the way making it easier for me. Fantastic person. , ,

over 5 years ago
Professional easy going agent

Caitlin was easy to work with throughout the sale. She is friendly and professional and helped as needed.

1 - 7 of 7
© 2026 RateMyAgent