Brenda's profile

Brenda's reviews

  5  
Brenda has 43 reviewsacross 29 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Brenda's qualities as told by our client reviews: detail-oriented, stress-free process, honest, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
fantastic - highly recommend
about 1 year ago
fantastic - highly recommend

Frank and Brenda helped my husband and I purchase our first home. They were so patient and understanding and they never made us feel dumb for asking questions, which they were always happy to answer. They really worked patiently with us to find us the right home, not just any home. They have lots of experience and due to Frank’s accounting background, they were able to provide us to valuable knowledge and perspective that we may not have received elsewhere. They really value the client relationship, and we also shared several laughs along the way. While Frank took the lead on helping us, Brenda was also involved as they work together as a team, so we really felt supported in having our needs met. I strongly recommend them to anyone who is purchasing, and we fully intend to call them and no one else in the future to help us with the process of buying our forever home. Thank you Frank and Brenda!

Buyer review
Excellent and Experienced Realtors
about 1 year ago
Excellent and Experienced Realtors

My fiancé and I were buying our first home. Initially was just to look and get an idea, but my fiancé would pile up homes she wanted to view from Zillow. Frank and Brenda stated they would show us home they knew we’re available that may not have been on Zillow or the like. We would sometimes see up to 7 homes in one day at no charge! Frank and Brenda knew the ins and outs of the entire process very well. Whenever I had questions about the process or what was next, they had an answer. They have experience renovating homes themselves and were honest about the repairs that would need to be made to any home and how much that may cost. Having done some work myself I knew they could be trusted after the first home we viewed. They were available call, text, or email at any time and we never had issues having them available to us when we needed them. When it came to closing documents, they made sure to manage expectations well- the seller was a real estate investing firm. With their help we were able to offer a competitive price and ended up paying nothing in closing costs- saving money for us to fix things we needed done to the home. I could not be happier with our real estate agents- good, honest, knowledgeable people!

Seller review
Excellent, kind, knowledgeable
about 1 year ago
Excellent, kind, knowledgeable

Frank and Brenda were excellent agents. They empowered us to make decisions regarding the sale of our home and we could trust their expertise while also feeling like we were being well taken care of. Frank is a wealth of knowledge and information and knows Indianapolis very well. Highly recommend him to anyone interested in buying or selling their home. We have done both processes with him and he made it easy both times. Very easy to communicate with and quick response on any and all things. Any time I had a question or needed something, they promptly responded and were very willing to be there to support our process. They were quick to offer solutions to any issues that arose and offered excellent advice in both buying and selling.

Buyer review
Awesome Duo!
about 1 year ago
Awesome Duo!

Frank and Brenda have been amazing to work with. They are extremely knowledgeable and make the whole process of buying a new home/land seamless and easy. They are always quick to respond to texts/emails and are always thinking one step ahead to make sure they meet all your needs. They truly go above and beyond for their clients!

Buyer review
Knowledgeable and Kind Realtors
over 1 year ago
Knowledgeable and Kind Realtors

We had no idea about the home buying process until we met with Tinsley Realty. They were so friendly and responsive throughout the entire process. We ended up buying a home in our price range that met all of our requirements. I highly suggest the Tinsley team as your realtor!

Buyer review
Great experience
over 1 year ago
Great experience

Frank is fantastic! He and his wife Brenda were very knowledgeable and guided us thru the home buying process as first time home buyers. We had a million questions and they had answers or found answers for us. I would do this process again with him.

Buyer review
Excellent experience
over 1 year ago
Excellent experience

Frank Tinsley made the process of buying a new home and selling a home a very seamless. He was always available for questions or concerns along the way.

Buyer review
Frank did an amazing job helping me buy my first home
almost 2 years ago
Frank did an amazing job helping me buy my first home

Well, first off I was buying my first home and as a single low income buyer I was nervous. Frank made the process smooth and made sure to give me the knowledge I needed to make an offer on my favorite home. It was an awesome feeling to close on the my top choice in a safe beautiful neighborhood. He has experience being a dual agent and also gave several tips on owning a home. I would suggest Frank Tinsley and Highgarden Realty to any friend or family member who is ready to buy. 5 stars, attentive, efficient and personable.

Seller review
Absolutely fantastic!
almost 2 years ago
Absolutely fantastic!

Frank Tinsley put forth his most endearing effort to make everything go as smoothly and timely as humanly possible. I could not have had a better experience with going through this sale and I could have not have gotten luckier to have him through the entirety of the process. I highly recommend him to anyone and everyone!

Buyer review
Found us the perfect house!
about 2 years ago
Found us the perfect house!

Frank is wonderful and we sincerely appreciated his expertise and timely responses. We ended up finding the perfect house!

Seller review
First Time Seller
about 2 years ago
First Time Seller

Working with Frank was a fantastic experience. Frank helped me purchase my first home and I couldn’t think of using anyone else to help me sell! He was incredibly knowledgeable about the market, responsive to our needs, and guided us through the entire process with expertise. Highly recommend Frank for anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

Seller review
Love Frank and Brenda!
over 2 years ago
Love Frank and Brenda!

I sold my house with Frank and Brenda and from start to finish they were always professional and friendly to work with! We had some bumps in the sale due to the buyers and Frank and Brenda were always prompt with their responses and shared updates at any time of the evening. Love working with them and definitely would again in the future.

13 - 24 of 43
© 2026 RateMyAgent